How Drastic Was the Book Of Thoth Nerf?
So we're a couple patches in and I wanted to just do a little bit of perspective on one the changes for a beloved item in smite. Now I'm not arguing it's bad now or whatever, but for the change is interesting to me becuase of how it affected the mages differently.
For those of you just coming in Book of Thoth is a Stacking Item that drastically increases your mana (+1000) and gives 80 power when fully evolved. At full stacks it used to also do a 5% mana to power boost from all your mana, including the gods own inherent pool. After 6.1 this was changed to do a 9% boost in power but now it's only mana from items.
So inherently I knew I would need to build a pairing mana item (or 2) to make up the difference in power, but I didn't know how much more. So I made a [Dataset] (https://imgur.com/a/aoPtpDM) for giggles. Now this set is only the power from the conversion not total power, but it's the conversion that really matters (becuase that's where the difference is). What I learned, no gods have more power with new Book as their only mana item, A couple gods actually work as well or better with the coversion change when getting 1 other mana item (besides Bancrofts Talon), Third(ly?) there is a 550 mana range for mages. I figured the mana difference was minimal and arbitrary, especially since mage abilities have very similar cost.
Lastly the amount of items that add mana to reach past pre-nerf boost with the same items at the highest range is 4, Leaving 1 for pen (and 1 already being Book). To be fair though even at the highest range 3 additional Mana Items is only like 5 power weaker and only like 5 power stronger at 4. I was just ^slightly under the impression that if we did invest a lot into more mana items we'd shoot up a bit more. I quote "...Players who fully commit to a heavy mana build will see more power than before, but alone it won’t pack quite the same punch."
Actually It's not that big a deal to me personally, the item change makes it more consistent and not unfairly better on one god or another, barring Kukulkan who is has a very public affair with the item. For comparison I made another small data set of gods to compare the old vs new conversion and at the low end of the spectrum you can get up to 22 more power for commiting to mana items ^For ^Freya ^^This ^^was ^^a ^^secret ^^buff ^^for ^^her.
And on it's own it is less powerful by a good bit for some gods. Poor Janus loosing out of a free 36 power. We also have to consider that before this may have been the only mana item you'd buy (though really who are we kidding soul reaver was so good last season) and it did give to much there. It's a consistent 170 now (278 for Kuku) instead of a abritrary ranged 228-264 (297 for Kuku).
TLDR; Book of Thoth changes were mildly interesting.
Posted Mar 10, 2019, 5:28 AM UTC
So how much mana do you think you need for book to be worth it now? On mages that can’t abuse the spear of making tick damage OP, I’ve been building book of Thoth with CDR boots and soul reaver for mana, and sometimes doom orb or book of the dead as a last item. But I skip this on tick damage mages since spear of magus/gem of isolation/shaman’s ring is enough to wreck without having max power.
so 550 extra mana, (CDR boots and Soul Reaver) make 19 of the 30 mages have the same or more power than the previous Book of Thoth. With the added doom orb only Janus, Anubis, Hel, He bo, and Sol have less power than previously but very minimally so. So typically 550 extra is what I'd shoot for when going the mana route. Basically what you've been doing.
Cool, even with soul reaver’s nerfed passive I still think it’s the best option for mages that cant abuse spear of magus, since it synergies with book of Thoth well and other high power items like rod of Tahuti don’t give mana.