I'm not sure if it's canon at all, but the Asajj vs. Anakin duel in the Clone Wars cartoon is one of the best lightsaber battles in any Star Wars medium, period
Posted Mar 13, 2019, 5:42 AM UTC
Posted Mar 13, 2019, 5:42 AM UTC
I’ve heard there’s an interview where Dave Filoni says he likes them and tried to keep his Clone wars from contradicting Tartakovski’s too much because he considered it canon but that might be false
I think at this point Filoni sort of is trying to make them go together hand-in-hand. It seems like it may work. Somewhat. Although I do prefer the 2003 over Filoni's.
That first Clone Wars set of “micro-episodes” from Gendy Tartakovsky was just masterful. It should be made canon. It’s great.
Some things don’t match up sadly. It kills Asajj for one thing
It kills Asajj for one thing
She falls off a cliff into a dark abyss. If Maul can survive being bisected and falling down a hole, then Asajj could've totally survived that.
Hmm true
I mean that didn't match up with the old EU either, so everyone just ignored it and assumed she survived somehow.
I'll raise you Sidious VS Maul & Opress in TCW. Best lightsaber battle/duel in the history of the saga.
Nah, Obi-Wan vs Maul in Rebels.
That's my favourite concise and emotional fight...but it's not really a lightsaber duel for the ages that is almost like a dance.
Fantastic duel. My mouth was practically on the floor, I loved seeing Sidious’s movements in that fight. Had a very lean, trickster whimsy if that makes sense. And after it’s established how strong Opress and Maul are, for Sidious to so easily handle them
Yep. That's what I liked about it as well. He fights like a true Sith...the blades into the floor as he carves upwards into them...just amazing "character" in his fighting. Not easy to do/portray in a sword fight.
I wish this show was still airing. I feel like it was the best representation of how powerful and skilled the clones were.
You wish the show had gone on for 15 more years of 3-minute episodes of all visuals, no plot?
Asajj's fate is detailed in the novel "Dark Disciple" which was adapted from an unused Clone Wars storyline. Yes, it's unfortunate that some things from the 2D Clone Wars is not canon, but based on the movies, they probably made Mace Windu a bit too strong (not that it wasn't a good episode!).
i mean they did fight again in the 3D series. and Ventress' personality was pretty much the same. in a way this was groundwork for a lot of the 3D TCW.
The rain drops on the blade were a very cool effect imo.
I prefer this version to the 3D Clone Wars. I particularly love the episodes without dialogue. The animation and design is on-point and it just got on with telling CLONE WARS stories rather than going off in all different directions.
The clone commandos!
The wonderful thing about animation, when it comes to combat, is you don't have to worry about stage fighting. In live-action the strikes are always aimed at the defense, rather than the target. Blades are aimed at blades instead of bodies, fists are armed at forearms instead of faces or bellies, and if you look at it too closely it starts to stand out.
Animation doesn't have to worry about that, animation can feature fights where it really looks like the characters are actively attempting to maim or kill one another. I've always felt like that gave Clone Wars and The Clone Wars a huge advantage when it came to lightsaber fights, the choreography always looks so much more satisfying.
EDIT: Although I must say, I'd forgotten how much I detested Asajj's design in Clone Wars. She makes me think of Jack Skellington, or Kaminoan Zombie, and I find it impossible to take her seriously.
If I remember correctly, there's a deleted scene in the Clone Wars movie where Anakin and Ventress allude to the events of this duel.
Can't be canon, Asajj Ventress had the high ground on several occasions but Anakin still defeated her.
Not canon, but I loved this series so much more than what we have now.
This series introduced us to General Grevious, and he was such a BADASS, straight taking out a whole squad of Jedi like nothing... movie him was so underwhelming.
Also helps that it's Samurai Jack styled.
I dunno... The 2003 fits better into the slot between ATOC and ROTS. The longer you keep something going the more unstable it becomes. It even fits Greivous's cough into the mix. Therefore, it HAS to be canon because that and the Chancellor's capture fit directly into the films. Whereas Filoni's gives nothing that leaks into the films, that I've seen anyways.
I mean... it literally isn't recognized as canon... where as the later series is (for the most part).
Right. But it does fit better. I think in part because it was created before ROTS came out. Making something afterwords can always leave room for making anomalies.
Oh for sure. Like I said, I prefer it.
When the rain starts to hit the lightsabers omg we need this effect in star wars live action sonetimes
IIRC I believe you can see it in TFA but with snow.
It is very interesting. If you pay attention, it seems Anakin's anger is immensely kindled after Ventress knocks his lightsaber out of his hand. You can see the shock on her face that seems to suggest she hadn't expected this seemingly un-jedi like change in attitude and fighting. Perhaps the duel wouldn't have ended here if she knew he had known that he has a history of using his anger.
I believe this ultimately fits better than Filoni's also in regards to Anakin himself in his portrayal. In the 2003 version, Anakin is brash, weak, immature, and impulsive. He's practically a child. He was easily manipulated by Palpatine BECAUSE he was naive and immature. He's kind of whiny because he isn't a Jedi master. He sounds and LOOKS young in the films and here. In the new 2008-2014 verison. Anakin has this very weird deeper voice, looks older than he does in the movies, has wisdom which he passes on to his padawan, which in the films and the old 2003 CW he never would have had because of his immaturity, and ultimately didn't strike you as the sort of character that was naive. 2008-2014 almost seemed like the cinematical Obi-wan, like he had years of maturity and experience or something. This 2003 version ultimately fits better whether Filoni tries to make it canon or not.
Unfortunately, this series is not canon
It's very odd to me how a company can buy an ip that's existed for decades and say "this isn't real anymore, this never happened."
Just make something of your own, then.
Exactly. If fans can say "Han shot first" even though Lucas himself decided differently, SW can be whatever you make of it.
It's very odd to me how a company can buy an ip that's existed for decades and say "this isn't real anymore, this never happened."
They didn't, though. It was Lucasfilm's decision to reset canon, and it probably would've happened anyway had Lucas decided to make the films himself. Plans for the canon reset were in the works before any talks of a buyout began.
It isn't real. It never happened. It's fiction.
It's silly to argue about which fictional events and characters "really happened" and which ones didn't.
All they're saying is their new stories aren't going to use those other older ones as sounces (until they decide they do want to use parts of them) because that heavily limits what they can do, and there's a bunch of those old stories that are probably best left forgotten.
Hmmm... No one said anything about it being "real," just questioning the logic if their acquisition decisions.
[removed]
See, it's one of those things that's weird with how canon exists. I know that broadly speaking, the series isn't canon, but there are a bunch of elements that it introduces that are, so...
I know it's probably not canon, but that's a damn shame, because this fight is an awesome action and character development piece.
Yes, i have watched the whole series and I think the biggest thing that make it non Canon is how some characters are overpowered compared to the animated series
I mean Grevious is introduced with the cough in 3D series, so that contradicts Mace giving it to him
There are things in this series that ties the films together. So in a way IT IS canon. Or it isn't. As I said, if fans can say "Han shot first" even though Lucas made it the other way around, you can decide what happened or what didn't.
And it is about the only thing showing where Anakin got his scar. Such a huge thing and it’s no where in the newer Clone Wars.
It doesn't show how he got his scar. That was in the Republic comics.
Could have sworn I saw a battle in the Genndy Tartakovsky Clone Wars between Ventress and Anakin that she did it. I must be getting oldtimers.
No, their only battle in that series is the one in OP's video. It is Asajj who scars him, though, but in the comic Republic 71: The Dreadnaughts of Rendili, Part 3.
[removed]
"...something's not right"
I know that a lot of stuff in the Clone Wars cartoon made it into actual canon (Grievous, I think Asajj Ventress herself) but I'm pretty sure none of these events are considered canon.
Which is a shame, because this is one of the finest duels in all of Star Wars. There are so many great shots and moments - I'm a sucker for the rain hissing off the lightsaber blades - the animation and choreography is really solid, it's excellently paced.
There's also so much symbolism here. Anakin having to literally enter the dark to pursue his foe, the ground shattering underneath him as he gives in to his rage much like his son will decades later, the red of Yavin overhead bathing him in the color.
It's a superb battle in an oft-overlooked entrance in the Star Wars franchise and more people need to know about it, dammit.
Grievous was added in this show as a teaser for the then-upcoming Revenge of the Sith. The reason he is so different here is they didn't actually know his personality in the film, just that he is a biological alien in a droid shell and kills Jedi to take their lightsabers. Once the film came out and we got the coughing general, volume 2 released to tie the end of the first show into the beginning of the film and they used that opportunity to "explain" the cough.
As for Asajj, she actually was created from the concept art from Attack of the Clones. Originally the new Sith apprentice to replace Darth Maul was going to be a female alien and concept art was made for her before they settled on the Count Dooku route. When Dooku needed an assassin to be a Sith hopeful in this show, they went back to the AotC concept art and decided to use her. Bonus fact, her original name was Juno Eclipse. After it was changed to Asajj, that name was shelved until the game The Force Unleashed came out and used as the love interest's name there.
Since you seem to know alot about this I will ask you, I though Asajj was ripped from Komari Vosa from the Bounty Hunter game. Is it possible those two almost identical concepts had nothing to do with each other?
So this is where it gets funny. Komari (in legends) dies and asajj gets her lightsabers in the 2D clone wars. So it looks like the characters developed independently but were retconned to share this one trait
Oh yeah I forgot that. They should have kept Vosa. She was more interesting I thought. Her and Darth Talon are my two favorite Sith Chicks.
Great fucking reply
Well, the show was aired as a buildup to Episode 3, which Greivous was heavily featured in. Episode III filmed before the cartoon aired, so it was more the cartoon featuring a Canon character than the film adapting him from the cartoon.
She later appeared in the Clone Wars film and Cartoon Network series, which is canon, so yes.
Afaik, this series isn't canon, but that doesn't mean it's a "shame" imo. Still very enjoyable. The only things pre-Disney that are canon are the original 6 films, and the cartoon network Clone Wars.
And the Darth Maul: son of Dathomir comic originally from Dark Horse (republished by Marvel) but that is a clone wars arc they didn't get to use because it was cancelled so they turned it into a comic.
As it has been republished by Marvel it's Canon now anyway but at the time it was the only comic published by another house that they kept Canon, mainly because it ties to the clone wars.
There's also the novel Dark Disciple published by Del Rey that adapts another Arc from the clone wars, but that was published already under Disney.
Basically they wanted to give closure to the Arcs and rightfully so. I wonder if the new season will be the adaptation of the comic and novel...
I remember watching this the first time. The raindrops on the blades were good, but the second Ventress' lightsaber casts that red glow on his face and the music changes to Duel of the Fates... my hype levels exploded.
I love Mace vs the droid army hand to hand. My other favorite is OB1 v Durge on speeders like a calvary charge of knights.
After Disney took Star Wars I consider the EU and LEGENDS canon and what they’re putting out as non canon.
OK...? It was Lucasfilm's decision to reset canon, and it probably would've happened anyway had Lucas decided to make the films himself.
Lucasfilm was bought in 2012 by Disney. And I disagree Lucas "would have" established Legends as he didn't do it with the PT.
Don't fall for the post hoc, ergo propter hoc fallacy. The canon reset did occur about a year and half after the buyout, but it was in consideration even before talks began in 2011. At that point, the ST was only basic story treatments, but it did exist. Lucas didn't reset canon for the PT because there was little to no canon to reset--besides stuff waaaay in the past like Tales of the Jedi, there were almost no works set in the pre-ANH era. We know that Lucas's attitude towards the old EU was always that it was slightly better than fanfiction to him, something that didn't really affect the story he wanted to tell, but was available for him to pick and choose elements as he wished (most infamously, he planned on having Darth Talon appear in the ST, despite being from an era about 100 years after that period, just because he liked her look). We saw this with how his Clone Wars series (the 2008 3D animated version) conflicted with the established record in the comics and 2003 2D series. There was no definitive, cohesive timeline there until the canon reset. So had Lucas decided to make the ST himself as he had with the PT, canon would've had to have been reset anyway, and you'd be railing against Big Bad Lucas instead of Big Bad Disney.