My Grandfather's family want's my parents and I to hide from him the fact that a relative died.

Family Loss

My grandfather is 89 he's been somewhat sick and stressed out lately. To make thing worse, one of his 4 brothers died this morning and the remaining 3 (who are a bit younger) have asked my parents and I to not tell him as it might stress him out further.

I can understand their viewpoint, but it will cause him to miss his closest brother's burial ceremony. My parents and I think he should be informed. What would you do in my situation?

EDIT: Thanks for the replies everyone, my grandfather was informed, he was shocked since they didn't even tell him his brother had been hospitalized but apparently didn't take it too badly. My great-unlcles were dissapointed with our decision but don't seem too mad about it.

Oh and for those who asked he doesn't have any mental conditions apart from a bad short term memory and a tendency to get physically sick after hearing news of old friends/family passing away.

Posted Mar 19, 2019, 7:36 PM UTC · edited

47864
jwrig•

He's not a child. Tell him.

253
Letusso•

Tell him. Imagine how he'll feel when he realises he's missed his brother's funeral

215
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
ferocious_llama•

Everyone here is grieving, and it's possible your great-uncles are so afraid of losing another brother that they aren't thinking rationally.

Approach them with compassion and inform them that you will be unable to keep this secret from your grandfather. Nobody has the right to isolate this man from the rest of the family to "protect" him, nor does anyone have the right to deprive him of his opportunity to say goodbye to his brother.

I am sure your great-uncles mean well, but what they plan to do is patronizing and cruel. You and your parents should gently explain your feelings and give them the opportunity to change their minds, but if they don't, please do tell him.

125
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
wwabc•

assume he will find out...think about the stress that will cause him

97
Faiths_got_fangs•

Question, does he have all of his mental faculties?

If he is still coherent, he deserves to know. If he has dementia or Alzheimer's and isn't going to be able to grasp/remember the loss and will just have to suffer the news multiple times only to forget it within hours, maybe not. We had to tell my grandfather that my grandmother was gone 20+ times. Each time he took the news as if it was fresh. We would have avoided it if we could have, especially after the 3rd or fourth time.

71
aelin_galathynius_•

This is such good advice for Alzheimer’s/dementia patients. My grandma talks about her sister and her mom as if she is still 16 - in fact, she thinks the nursing home is her college dormitory. But, instead of telling her every time her family is dead, I always ask her what her favorite memory is of them and redirect.

30
DrgSlinger475•

My approach with dementia patients has always been to tell them about the loss one time. They will retain the information or not. If not, then redirect just as you described, because they shouldn't have to go through that loss multiple times.

I love your suggestion of reminiscing about favorite memories. That's a great way of redirecting!

17
crumbledup•

My family chose not to tell my grandma when my grandpa passed. She had extremely advanced Alzheimer’s and my parents were worried to say anything. She wasn’t “there” anymore, but who knows what actually can get through to her even if she didn’t have the capacity to react to it.

15
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
sashy311•

Tell him. My grandma is in a nursing home with dementia and she was still told when her sister died & we took her to the funeral. It’s not fair to keep that from him. He’ll be devastated when he finds out he missed the funeral. :(

25
AlbertDock•

If he's mentally aware then he should be told. He's 89 so the death of his brother, while distressing, is in some ways, no surprise.
What you should be thinking is, what will he think of you if he finds out? He has one chance to go to his brother's funeral, would you deny him that?

24
KillaBreeead•

Tell him. He's 89 and has known many people who have died.

You don't make it to 89 without making it through some shit. He has a right to know.

21
SuperMommyCat•

Imagine how stressed out he’ll be when he wants to go visit his brother later and finds out he died and no one told him. People don’t like to be coddled, especially about something like this. If he doesn’t feel up to going to the funeral, that should be his decision, but he still needs to be told.

17
dvehz•

Imagine the stress/anger his family will put him through if they let him find this out in his own. And he will obviously know this has been hidden from him. He’s not a child tell him. Best of luck.

9
george_reeves_•

Tell him, he should go to his brothers funeral

8

Ignorance is bliss, but shallow bliss. Knowledge is power... and in this case, knowledge is freedom. It is your Granfather's right to know. More importantly, it is his right to decide how to deal with the loss. The choice to hide the news is selfish. It shows lack of character and lack of respect for your grandfather.

Everyone should have the right to grieve. Everyone. That choice should never be made by anyone else.

6
wewladendmylife•

My grandmother is very old and while she is healthy for her age, shes not doing super great. One of her brothers in Europe died and we decided to tell her. His passing was extremely peaceful and he had a very fulfilling life.

She reacted with sadness but not surprise. I think when you get that age you accept that other people will die before you. I would tell him but talk it over with your parents and the rest of your family. I dont think hiding this is good for him or anybody else.

6
caseycole589•

Tell him

4
JoeCon1999•

He deserves to know. In my opinion I think you should approach his family and tell them that you would like to tell him as you don’t think he should miss the funeral. Maybe make the case that if it were them who didn’t know, they wouldn’t want to be deprived of this knowledge. I don’t know what his mental faculties are, but if they’re sound he’s going to find out anyway and it would be unfair to deprive him of closure. To be honest, whether his family come around or not I’d tell him anyway or maybe get your parents to do it. It just doesn’t seem fair at all to treat a grown man of his age as a small child. Good luck!

4
Hyphylife•

My mom’s family tried that with my grandmother who was very sick with LGD. They didn’t want anyone telling her that her youngest son (my mom’s youngest brother) was killed. She found out anyway and passed away soon after his funeral. I will never forget the way she cried when she found out he died. I wish I could unhear/unsee that.

You need to tell him. It’s selfish not to.

4
Sworishina•

TELL HIM

3
MercyIess•

Imagine how would you feel if you were the one in his situation and found out months later you can't even say goodbye to your BROTHER. He deserves to know, and you must be there to comfort him.

3
MattvLee•

Tell him, I don't think he'll want to miss saying goodbye to him.

3
Scotty_Hassett•

I would tell him. As sad as he might be, missing the burial would probably make him even more sad.

3