r/UofT•
m-mmm

A Different Perspective

Discussion

As many of you may already know, a student passed away on March 17th on school campus; the student committed suicide. Despite such tragic news, it’s hopeful to see that many people care and that our society isn’t desensitized and self-revolving. What’s deeply disappointing, however, is the approach the student body takes in confronting this issue. By no means am I trying to belittle and shame those who are mourning for the fellow peer, it is just extremely frustrating when you come across students who are mindlessly condemning the institution to take responsibility for what happened. And believe it or not, it’s more widespread than you think.

“UofT needs to stop covering up student deaths and take proper action” – what does this even mean? Out of curiosity, I approached few students engaged in the protest and sincerely questioned the nature of their statement. For most part, students believe that the University of Toronto is burying “negative” news for the betterment of their institution and reputation. “They simply don’t care” – they said. And other responses revolve around the idea that this university poorly addresses mental health and fails to provide the necessary means of assistance to students who really need them.

To a certain extent, yes, I completely agree. But for a major part, I don’t.

Honestly, regardless of how the institution decides to take care of this business, there will be parties who strongly disagree with their approach but it’s only right to at least pay our respect to them for attempting to accommodate thousands of students who are emotionally and physically struggling on a daily basis. Burying the news has no correlation to saving their “renowned” reputation – that’s nonsense and just morally wrong. They choose to stay away from mass media as a sign of respect to the fellow student as well as the student’s family; they don’t want the world to talk about their tragic incident, it brings no good. Their decision on keeping it down-low is a pretty pragmatic approach in my opinion… The school definitely has room for improvement, but I doubt they can do much more. Being here for 3 years now, I have witnessed more students abusing the health care system to defer their test and exams in order to receive a better mark – to compensate for their lack of effort and procrastination. It happens way more often than you think. Go to a nearby clinic, doctors are hesitant to give you a proper diagnosis because of all the bullshit that occurs on a daily basis. The amount of prescription they write down clearly doesn’t match the amount of medication you pick up. I don’t blame them at all – and I’m not going to protest against them for giving me a half-assed diagnosis. We deserve it. We, as students, abused the system and made it unfair for the people who actually need it. And yet, the school still continues to provide free health care for those who need it (and for those who don’t). So maybe instead of pointing your fingers at the institution, deliver the right messages to the students and take responsibility. Maybe then, the school will come to us with open minds.

I acknowledge the fact that the health care system in the school underperforms. It takes time and effort to book an appointment - but that doesn't imply negligence. UofT isn't a hospital, let’s get that straight. It will take time to process hundreds of requests, to sort out who gets priority - and remember this is based on a piece of paper you hand in. We're given the privilege of free health care and insurance...it is only right to accept the cost of long waiting times and slow responses. After all, if it’s too serious, you have access to other facilities that prioritize your health over education.

School is hard. Getting a degree isn’t easy. It's stressful and competitive - you get depressed and overwhelmed but that's the sacrifice you accepted when you chose to attend a bit more prestigious school. It's not fair that we compare our school to other institutions who have it a bit easier because in the end, we receive something a bit more rewarding than them.

Let’s just stop and think about those who are desperately in need of help – just like how the 3 students felt before deciding to end things. It’s not about the resources. I know it’s not the same for everyone but for those, including myself, who sincerely experienced isolation, depression, emotional pain, and etc. must know that reaching out is the last thing you want to do. Walk around this institution, I praise them for having posters about mental illness, health accommodations, help-lines…it’s all there, but we’re just blinded by our fight for survival…to care again and to be happy again. Help is everywhere – your friends, your family, the school, your college, the internet, the clinic – but I’m telling you again, none of that matters when you’re hopelessly fighting. I mean isn’t that why campaigns are oriented around speaking your mind and seeking help? Change starts within us. And of course, this doesn't apply to everyone. There are people, many actually, who rather seek help from strangers who share no relevance to their lives. But you got to understand, these resources are finite. It is not plentiful like your friends and family. Long wait times and slow responses are inevitable. It is a price we got to accept.

Life doesn't adjust for you. You can't expect the school to be more lenient because it drives us emotionally insane. It's their functional method and to be fair, they give us a clear heads up to what we’re getting into – they outline everything since day 1 via your syllabus. If you can't handle it, find a place where you can belong. And that isn't a disrespectful comment. Our society is becoming more materialistic; its overwhelming students with the false impression that success is only relevant on a big-scale level. Making a change in your society is success, but so is graduating with a degree. Don’t downplay your achievements because it’s not relevant to the majority of the world. Give yourself the credit you deserve and push aside those who decide to bring you down. If you aren’t content with where you’re at, do something different! Struggling in the same position gets you nowhere. In fact, it destroys a part of your life – your motivation.

It's not about what everyone else does, it’s about what you do and what you make out of it. Make your success personal – and that’s all that matters.

I did not post this here to argue about who is right or wrong – that’s just blatantly disrespectful to our fellow peer. I just want everyone to see a different perspective of this issue and hopefully find your place in it all. In the end, it's our different and unique perspective of things that make us a great society.

There definitely needs some sort of change - suicide is never a good sign. Lets build a positive platform for discourse. Not point fingers.

And lastly, to the fellow peer that passed away, I hope you are in a better place. You left a significant message to all of us and no matter what happens after – you’ll forever be a part of everyone’s life.

Posted Mar 19, 2019, 10:26 PM UTC · edited

18750
OverCamera•

TW.

U of T has LOTS of $$ for indoor bamboo gardens and such, for gorgeous landscaped inner courtyards, for really well built buildings (esp the medical school), for catered meetings, for fancy posters all over campus touting their best scholars. They should immediately and without hesitation install a barrier in Bahen, Its the 2nd act of public self-harm there, to my knowledge. This shouldn't be debated, it should just get done. It can be done yet the school doesn't budge. That alone is worth a protest.

The school should publicize what departments these three suicides this academic year were in, were they domestic or international students, grad or undergrad. They can still respect families wishes by not naming them, but they can publicize some things about it. Everyone knows what went on in the school community and the Toronto community. Its all over reddit anyone deciding to come to U of T will now about these instances. The school looks bad by brushing it under the table as isolated incidents. Shame on the admin.

102
Skyairen•

I think that's hardly wise, it's academically proven that publishing details about suicides increase the chances of copycat suicides. Given how widespread the information around the summer suicide was and how similar it's circumstances are to the most recent suicide, you can see that publicity is not conducive to improving student wellbeing.

22
OverCamera•

Hmmm I thought there was a push to actually talk about suicide so as to de-stigmatize it....and to de-stigmatize depression and mental illness. I guess its a tough call. You don't want copy cats...or to normalize it either...that's really a tough one.

1
Skyairen•

There is a push to de-stigmatize discussions around mental health and suicide prevention. It's all over campus, there's no shortage of resources being advertised at libraries, common spaces, residence dorms, etc.

4
Enigma_101He Who Must Not Be Named•

Truer words have never been spoken

7
spartasveryown•

They should immediately and without hesitation install a barrier in Bahen, Its the 2nd act of public self-harm there, to my knowledge. This shouldn't be debated, it should just get done. It can be done yet the school doesn't budge. That alone is worth a protest.

You expect a University (a government institution), two days after an incident, to respond with an announcement to build barriers?

Lol. That is not how governmental institutions work.

0†
kittenborn•

It's very troubling that the bare minimum response (prevent the same thing from happening again) is being met with scorn because apparently we shouldn't expect the institution to which we pay thousands of dollars to function on a basic level?

10
spartasveryown•

Welcome to reality. I’m not saying it’s good anything, but that’s how it is.

-1
Deckowner==Trash•

Two days? You think this is the first time this happened in Bahen?

10
BornAlbatross•

Building barriers won't help anything- there are other buildings people can find to. Basically, it won't resolve the source of the problem.

3
OverCamera•

Pfft. Universities are hardly governmental institutions anymore, they get more $$ from international student fees and tuition then the governments any more. Its a for-profit educational business, partially supported by government. They can afford a freaking barrier. They shouldn't;t even announce it at all, they should just get it done.

1
suspiciouschipmunk•

This already happened, in the same way, over the summer. It is three days after the most recent incident but 8 months after the first

1
spartasveryown•

I’m well aware of that, but it doesn’t mean they’ll be ready to make this kind of big decision in 2 days regardless.

0
Dr_Seisyll•

I strongly agree with this. I have nothing but good thing to say about the services at H&W and was impressed in the treatment I got from them. People say the wait times are long but around exams and midterms I don't know what people expect? Don't expect an instant appointment during the most stressful and busiest time of the year, and if you are at a crises point they have immediate resources for that too.

In general I thought this protest was really premature and misdirected.

40
sabbrina•

i also agree. i just booked today for an appointment in a weeks time, and usually its only a few days wait. The psychologists at H&W have been very helpful to me.

Its an easily accessible resource and Ive never experienced any long wait times.

10
CallmeRouge•

Well you got lucky. To see a psychiatrist now, you need a referral from a physician. Then they’ll book an appointment for evaluation. When I first started using H&W my first appointment was during the second week of March...and I booked it in the beginning of Jan My doctor has constantly talked about how she’s booked up to the max all the time with existing patients so it makes it really hard to take on more. And she’s right. We need more psychiatrists. We need more counsellors and psychologists. We don’t nearly have enough to cater to such a large student population.

2
sabbrina•

There are also resources you can utilize through UofT's health care plan where 20 therapy sessions are covered per year, at a max of $125 per session. And these can also be done through online video sessions.

http://studentcare.ca/rte/en/IHaveAPlan_UTSU_Health_HealthCoverage_HealthPractitioners_Psychologists

1
CallmeRouge•

And that’s really good! But it should be advertised more because I don’t think many people are aware what their insurance covers. I knew about 125$ per visit coverage not the fact that you can do a video chat. However, I noticed on the site it says anyone with a masters degree in social work can be a consultant. I personally haven’t used it so I don’t know if you get to choose what type of professional you can talk to, but that might be important anyways.

I mean if we really wanna get into it, you can even talk to the suicide hotline - but they’re not ru best in terms of quality. Just trying to understand what the quality of care here is.

1
suspiciouschipmunk•

I am currently visiting one of the off campus therapists through this service. However, she is no longer accepting new patients at due to the influx of students in late February. There are not enough resources there either.

You also need to pay that $125 out of pocket initially and then the insurance pays you back. I am fortunate enough to have that I can pay that but there are many people who often have no money in their bank account. There needs to be more free resources.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
therhythm6562astro•

U of T is responsible for students' education, not their health care.

1
CallmeRouge•

Registrars can often contribute to the stress by giving bad info. Multiple friends of mine have gotten terrible advice in regards to grad school (and yes they’ve often called in to actual grad school admission offices but they often give vague advice). Additionally, you pay for your insurance, the least they could do is make it easier for you to utilize it.

1
work-harder•

H&W

The issue is much broader than H&W.

3
suspicious-math•

I agree. Most people are just trying to push their own agenda.

-5†
stefangeo2000•

Yup. People using a tragedy as leverage against the school. Really gross tbh.

-13
haoareyoudoingHistory•

Leverage for what, better / more mental health services? A more reasonable workload?

Call me naive, but how does one attain leverage against the Goliath known as UofT?

Perhaps there are a few Machiavellians out there, but my assumption is that many people are just concerned students that aren't necessarily trying to attack the school rather, make the school their own and change it for, in their eyes, the better so that they and those behind them will have a better student experience.

25
nsci2eceNΨ dropout, ECE 1T3+PEY•

A more reasonable workload?

This is within the student's control.

In programs where the students have a pre-determined schedule, the professors actually do coordinate to make things reasonable regarding deadlines and test dates. I confirmed this during my first two years of engineering where I wasn't allowed to choose courses. Granted, this doesn't account for people with legit time-consuming responsibilities, e.g. part-time jobs, caring for disabled family members, but it's not as though the people who struggle are exposed to this for the most part. In fact, the people who actually have to juggle responsibilities like that tend to do well...

I'm not pointing any fingers at you as I don't know your circumstances, but this might be interesting: in 2nd year of ECE I knew a bunch of people who kept bugging the professors for extensions or blaming the course rather than themselves when they did poorly. All of them were privileged enough to be living on or near campus, meaning they had the most free time possible. I think it's perfectly reasonable to label these particular individuals as whiny snowflakes.

4†
haoareyoudoingHistory•

You have some valid points! I held two part-time jobs each of the last two school years, my grades did improve, and it probably has something to do with being on a set schedule with set deadlines. I can tell you though, it felt like the walls were closing in on me every week during the first year. I even got an extension without asking for one because one of my professors thought I looked stressed!

So I agree that professors can be accommodating especially with deadlines. Pre-determined schedules via the syllabus do help.

However, I would add that knowing months in advance when a paper is due does no help when the paper rubric is posted a week before it is due.

Regarding fellow classmates, I think we come from two different disciplines and the "average" temperament, or mindset, or worldview (if there even can be such a measurement), while similar can be different. I've known many in my field, including myself, who were complacent in taking a late-penalty here and there, and asked for extensions only as a last-resort accepting the outcome and working equally hard to complete the assignment whether confirmed or denied.

6
sabbrina•

what really upsets me is that student organizations are really pointing the finger at uoft infrastructure - yet they are funded by us and do very little themselves during the course of the semester as leaders to address this matter.

2
suspicious-math•

These are things you should research and know about before you go to any university.

-1†
hippofant•

Serious question: how unreasonable is the workload?

There was a thread this month asking people how much they actually worked here, and the vast majority of responses come in at less than 40 hours, which is a full-time job workload. (Assuming everybody's also going to every class.) And I'm not sure 40 hours would even be a consensus upper threshold on how much work an undergraduate might be expected to put in.

-1
haha_me_too_thanksalpha male•

and getting that phat reddit karma

0
haoareyoudoingHistory•

Lets build a positive platform for discourse.

I think that we can, but first, we must ditch hyperboles and broad overarching generalizations.

"It happens more than you think" and the other variant you use in your perspective doesn't justify a claim, let alone an anecdote. If we're going to come together, listen to different perspectives, and find a solution, one side cannot claim authority by using that idiom even if it is an idiom. Do you know how I think?

Also, one cannot assume that the students who condemn the institution are "mindlessly" doing so. Maybe they are, maybe they aren't but who are you to decide?

Finally, I noticed that you're a new account. I have no grounds to think your account is a throwaway and you're hiding behind it (it happens more than you think), so welcome to Reddit and the r/uoft community!

Edit: formatting

34
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
TwoNegative•

I am just hoping suicide in bahen won't become a thing due to copycats. So they definitely do need to put up nets or barriers or whatever the fuck before someone does it again like others suggested. The cherry is broken now. Hence the close duration between these two incidents in the same building. They need to act now because I was there last summer when the first incident happened and had to see the motionless body with yellow tapes surrounding it. Not a good sight to see. Everyone was outraged as well but sort of moved on and this lack of taking preventive measure caused another incident to happen in that same building.

19
communistpeanut•

I think in u of t's history theres been around 7 suicides in bahen. Im not certain however and couldnt find information to support it

1
uoftbeaver•

tw . i have had multiple friends attempt suicide for reasons closely related to UofT. My closest friend attempted suicide after not receiving mental health support and being under immense pressure for cs post.

The protest was not just about the incident on march 17th-- it was a protest to urge admin to give a shit about creating environments where students mental health doesnt suffer so much. this is not as common in the majority of post secondary institutions. policy is a part of this. mandatory leave that targets mentally ill students and particularly intl students is a part of this. systemic isolation and pressure is a part of this. not enough support and funds for student community is a part of this.

And then, uoft avoided dialogue, and even ran from having to face these questions.

That is a part of why people protest. That is why people are angry. uoft has the stats. they have the admissions and drop out info. They have the demographic info. They know how many more students are struggling to get into H&W and accessibility (Accessibility services is literally almost non functional because they get no funding to meet with immensely growing demand-- words straight from them)

It is a crisis. It is a mental health crisis that is constantly ongoing below the waves. and no crisis happens in a vacuum. the fact that so many students suffer so much more at uoft than is necessary, than is reasonable (even judging by other university's standards), is a huge problem that needs opening up about. that is what protesting is about.

16
hippofant•

Are the funding issues UofT issues though, or Ontario government issues?

Remember, a 10% tuition cut is coming. And student community groups are about to take a huge funding cut with opt-out ancillary fees, groups that attempt to build student communities and social groups, as well as advocate for student services.

5
uoftbeaver•

That is true but I didn't mean student societies exactly, but rather the experience a student has with their community here, where the infrastructure is seriously lacking already. part of this is stuff like funneling first years into cs and not giving them adequate idea or support about what they have signed up for.

2
catharsis724•

Burying the news has no correlation to saving their “renowned” reputation – that’s nonsense and just morally wrong. They choose to stay away from mass media as a sign of respect to the fellow student as well as the student’s family; they don’t want the world to talk about their tragic incident, it brings no good.

You're highlighting the issue. There are responsible and proper ways of addressing the university community that don't involve complete silence or a lack of acknowledgement of the possible underlying issues. In the past 2 days, the university chose not to do this. Ultimately the world isn't going to shun the university because someone took their life. That happens at a lot of post-secondary institutions. But the university can take a leadership role in dealing with the bigger issues and communicate that clearly. I think preserving their reputation is something the institution favours over efforts for meaningful change.

It's their functional method and to be fair, they give us a clear heads up to what we’re getting into – they outline everything since day 1 via your syllabus. If you can't handle it, find a place where you can belong.

Not the case for every course and program.

I have witnessed more students abusing the health care system to defer their test and exams in order to receive a better mark – to compensate for their lack of effort and procrastination. It happens way more often than you think.

Alright, fine, maybe we can give some credit to this if it's true, but that doesn't negate that students are disenfranchised and disappointed , to the point that they want to protest and be heard. Why do students feel like they need to get these prescriptions in the first place? Procrastination has been linked to mental distress. A student's willingness to "cheat the system" sprouts from the feeling that everything is so competitive that you cannot get a foothold otherwise. Even if students were seeking a physician/counselor to simply defer an exam, I still think it is out of desperation in the majority of cases.

it is just extremely frustrating when you come across students who are mindlessly condemning the institution to take responsibility for what happened

I think this is simplifying the intent to protest too much. It's essential to explicitly communicate what it important to you, to the institution, so it can do its best job to run itself according to the wishes of the student community. Rage, failed attempts at academic retribution, ignorance on part of faculty members...these are all real things people face. In addition, protest and outcry are also valid ways of mourning and grieving. Some deal with their grief personally, in solitude. Others want to turn the tragedy into something tangible, so that it actually matters, incite change, so that it doesn't happen again.

​

​

Regardless of everything I've said above, I found a lot of what you said useful and I appreciate you taking the time to compose that and share. Good luck with the rest of the term.

​

15
marrlasingerr•

https://thevarsity.ca/2018/06/27/u-of-t-approves-contentious-university-mandated-leave-of-absence-policy/

The policy allows the university to place students on a nonpunitive, but mandatory, leave of absence from U of T if their mental health either poses a risk of harm to themselves or others, or if it negatively impacts their studies.

This sounds like deterrence for seeking mental health help to me.

​

15
SpikedPhish•

Or is it? So many people misunderstand this, it hurts. The policy clearly states multiple times that the mandated leave of absence is absolutely reserved only after all other options have been exhausted. That is, only if therapy isn't working/isn't being used, and if the student themselves refuses a voluntary leave of absence. There are so many things you need to NOT do before they consider this. It isn't a deterrent against getting help!

6
marrlasingerr•

Posing a risk to yourself or other is already covered by law, and psychiatrists are held to this. If you threaten to/harm yourself or others, you will be formed.

Mind you, this policy was cristiczed by psychiatrists, multiple school groups and the Ontario Human Rights board.

​

So many people misunderstand this, it hurts.

Unfortunate.

Also, does it matter if people understand it or not? If it worries them and they dont seek help because of that, there's an issue

​

Edit: Spelling Edit 2: More text

9
DestroyerOfTitans•

" We're given the privilege of free health care and insurance "

​

That's incorect.

​

You pay almost $200 per semester for what little coverage they give you. (vision, dental)

The majority of services students actually use are provided by the Government of Ontario.

15
fruitjuice227•

Agreed. What is so difficult to comprehend about the individuals' families specifically requesting privacy? The university cannot acknowledge that a death has occured without explicit approval from the concerned individual's family. The majority of concerns over the mental health crisis at U of T are superficial & frankly laughable. Diverting your energies towards working with the university towards an actual solution might just avoid another tragedy. I assure you: the university does not want kids dying on their watch.

10
hokageofCanada•

I think you bring up quite a few good points about ownership of actions and becoming a decidedly better community in general. However, there ain’t no such thing as a free lunch. UofT has one of the fattest cash cows in Canada, not to mention that our tuition pays for a lot of these services too. I think labelling them as free is misleading, as a taxpayer my taxes go towards keeping up public institutions(hopefully). As a consumer, my money goes towards funding these services too, I should have a say in the quality of care provided. Furthermore, health insurance at UofT for domestic students is handled by the UTSU, not the uni itself.

IMO, the current outrage towards the admin cannot be viewed independent of the school closing debacle. Students are rightfully pissed at an apathetic admin.

While you present a good perspective, it misses the forest for the trees.

7
uniquenamex2New account•

Very well said. Everyone likes to blame the university for problems that arise because it's easy. However it's ridiculous because what exactly do you want the university to do? Imagine how the family would feel if theyre trying to greive and their son is the subject of massive media attention? Changing your social/academic life is on YOU. It brings no good to blame it on the university and then scaring off incoming students by telling them how terrible of a school this is.

4†
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
jungkooksieNew account•

well said

-1