r/classicwow•
swe93

We still don't know how sharding will be handled

Discussion

This is not a anti-sharding thread or a for-sharding thread. I simply want to hear more from Blizzard on the matter before I make up my mind.

​

I'm happy Blizzard are communicating with us more frequently about Classic, it's mostly good news all around. I'm a bit let down by the recent AV announcement but perhaps that will change with the response they got.

​

What I want to remind you guys about is Blizzards statements about Sharding.

We’re still looking at how we can best deliver an authentic Classic experience at launch, and in the weeks and months that follow - both in terms of gameplay and community. You won’t see phasing (which is tied to specific quests that don't exist in Classic) or cross-realm zones (which combine multiple realms together) in Classic. However, realm sharding is one of the best tools we have to keep realms stable when hundreds of players are swarming the same initial few zones and killing the same few mobs (like they will be at the launch of Classic). To that end, we do believe that some form of sharding may be helpful, especially in those early days. But we recognize that a cohesive world is critical to WoW Classic and are committed to bringing that to you.

​

Why should we bring up this tired topic once again?

Well, because we have a release timeframe, summer. That is moving towards us quickly now.

The statements made by Blizzard on this topic has been vague, initial zones could in theory be any zones Blizzard see fit for sharding and those early days could be a longer time frame than days. I know many of us in this community doesn't want that, and the time frame for weighing in our opinions on Blizzards decision in this matter is growing smaller each day.

​

There is of course a chance that Blizzard has not yet decided on this matter but I would like to see this community coming together and putting some pressure on Blizzard to make a decision and present it to us. That gives us a healthy portion of time to voice our opinions on the matter and the Classic team some time to reflect over what is best suited and what the majority of our community is in favor of.

​

Posted Mar 19, 2019, 10:32 PM UTC

08
Mylifeisaquatic•

I vote for sharding for the first day in the starting area and that’s it.

6
gardenheadd•

I agree, maybe 3 at max and only for the first few starter zones.

4
Minkelz•

Of course they haven't decided. Respawn rates, quest items, max zone population, max realm population, sharding rules and implementation will all be very much up in the air until they get a few good beta stress tests under the belt, and probably into a few patches in the weeks post release. You can do all the theorycrafting you want but until it's tested out in game with the actual client/server setup it's all pretty pointless. What matters is how it plays, just creating arbitrary rules would be stupid.

No it won't be like vanilla, because vanilla was a complete shit show for 6 months at release and a simultaneous online release with 4 million players is completely different to selling boxed copies of a new game in 2004.

2
swe93OP•

Blizzard has run wow for 14 years. I actually do believe they have all the statistics they need to make a decision without a “beta stress test”, something I highly doubt Blizzard would do. They could just emulate it, wasn’t the last beta stress test in 2004?

Thanks for your input, strange last paragraph that has nothing to do with my post though.

1
Minkelz•

The hardware/server/client side of it is only a small part of it, and yes they should have a good idea of how to handle that before launch. The problem is the gameplay, all the npcs/drops/quests that were dramatically altered or revamped throughout the xpacs. How many people can quest at once in Elwyn Forest or Westfall or Redridge or Duskwood? If the quests are overloaded how many people can grind mobs in those zones and still get some sort of progress? How slow is so slow you just feel frustrated and quit?

These are the sort of things you might want to think about before investing millions of company dollars in a game launch.

1
swe93OP•

I see what you’re saying, I agree. However I do believe they will have to make a decision in advance and when it might impact gameplay a great deal I hope they will share their decision with us sometime before launch.

1
Zaru666Lord•

I'd be okay with Sharding in areas like Valley of Trials, you know, the very begginning zones. But as soon as we leave the area it should be gone.

2
Karmond•

So sharding for the first 30 minutes, then for the next several hours, struggle to get anything done?

1