What happens to active spell effects if a target becomes illegal

1E Quick Question

Say I have haste active, but I'm turned to stone via flesh to stone. The next round, I'm restored to life. Is haste still active on me, or did it go away once I stopped being a legal target for the spell?

Posted Mar 22, 2019, 5:11 PM UTC

18
EdymnionYou can reflavor anything.•

Shillelagh Precedence.

The Shillelagh Spell has a target of a non-magical club or staff. The effect of the spell makes the target into a magical weapon, which should then make it an invalid target for the spell's effect.

So the precedent is that a spell's target validation check is only made at the time the spell is cast. If the target becomes invalid after the spell is cast, the spell continues for it's normal duration.

11
SmartAlec105GNU Terry Pratchett•

Temporary Resurrection is another example.

6
GeoleVyi•

If you look at spells like protection from evil, they say that if you were under a domination effect when you were protected, then the active effects are just suppressed until you become a legal target again. But the duration keeps in effect, so if you run out the clock on a dominate person while protected, then the domination effect just wears off. It doesn't pick back up when you stop being protected.

I would assume it works similarly when petrified.

3
ShadowcatX2000Spheres Enthusiast•

This specific situation isn't called out in the rules. What is called out is that you check legality at time of casting.

Barring special rules to the contrary RAW would have the spells because nothing says they don't.

1
HaniusTheTurtle•

I would assume that, unless specified in the spell itself, that ongoing effects like that would cease when the target is no longer valid.

0
easyroscoeOP•

I would assume the same, but I'd feel better if I could point to something concrete.

2
HaniusTheTurtle•

Yeah, hopefully someone with some quotable sources answers. Right or wrong, we will both learn things.

1
energyscholar•

You won't find an answer in the rules. It's just not covered. This is a GM call although we can all see the common sense in what's been discussed.

​

-1