Interesting Thought About the Infamous Debate (serious)

Hey I just watched the Anime Girls vid and the incest question popped up again. I've had this thought for a while on the repercussions of introducing sexual relationships into a familial setting. What I mean is that introducing a sexual relationship into a familial relationship could potentially lead to the degradation of a fundamental support system if the sexual relationship were to potentially fail. In the same way you break up with those not related by blood, a break up with your family member could isolate you from the one tie that seems to be biologically hardwired into us as humans to keep connected to for your own survival/happiness. Could this potentially be an answer to discourage incest (even though it doesn't necessarily attribute moral wrong to it) no matter if there is the absence of other moral wrongs like inbreeding and power imbalances? I really want to hear what y'all (and potentially Steven himself) have to say about this because it's been on my mind for a while bu I don't really have anyone to talk about it due to its admittedly niche content.

Posted Mar 23, 2019, 6:33 AM UTC

310
ShannnnnnnIf you downvote me, you are a Nazi•

I think the main moral counterargument is that if you allow it to happen to consenting sane smart adults the chance is high that this behaviour gets copied by not so sane or smart people thus leading to all the bad stuff that can come from this. The action is immoral because if it is viewed as moral it will eventually lead to negative outcomes.

3
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

But even then you could amount it to a slippery slope.

0
MnemonicFitness•

In the same way you break up with those not related by blood, a break up with your family member could isolate you from the one tie that seems to be biologically hardwired into us as humans to keep connected to for your own survival/happiness.

Isn't that risk that consenting people should be able to take in a free society?

1
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

That’s why I said discourage. I guess my purpose with this post was to illustrate that incest includes a risk of losing people obligated to protect you due to being your blood through risky sexual inclusion. Like, you could end up completely alone due to this. Most people think after this argument there aren’t any real bars from incest after debating this point but I think this is a substantive thing to discourage a lot of people from engaging in incest

0
MnemonicFitness•

But can't the same be said to discourage interracial or homosexual relationships, when the family in question is respectively racist or homophobic?

1
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

Good point. I guess it does. The hope would be to have your partner’s family be your new support and in incest that isn’t the case, but even still your partners family can be hateful as well.

Going back to an earlier point about a free society, I guess I would argue that society is founded upon the essential nature of relationships. This may be an appeal to Confucian ideals, but they’re still very effective. In a society where incest was common, I think according to Confucius the relationships and duties that come with those relationships would crumble, and therefore society would as well. Combining that with a utilitarian perspective on morality, the collapse of society seems like a pretty decent reason to avoid incest.

1
Confucius-Bot•

Confucius say, woman who go camping must beware of evil intent.


^("Just a bot trying to brighten up someone's day with a laugh. | Message me if you have one you want to add.")

0
Shikor806•

This seems to be an aspect of power dynamics to me. In the same way that sex between a boss and their employee is a bad idea because if the employee says no the boss can have a big negative influence on their life, someone might not be able to say no to a relative since they could have a big negative impact on their life.
So in a situation where that doesn't exist like estranged siblings, there still is no real issue. And sidenote, inbreeding is not really an argument against incest. Unless inbreeding has occured through many generations there is no significantly higher risk of genetic diseases. And even if there were, would you also accept that people with hereditary diseases can't have kids? Or what about people that are older than 40 years old, that also drastically increases risks?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
EmphasisIsImportantOP•

Just realized when I mentioned inbreeding. When I specifically asked if this argument was a good answer in situations where it was absent. I’m aware inbreeding isn’t a good argument against the act of incest.

1