Interesting Thought About the Infamous Debate (serious)
Hey I just watched the Anime Girls vid and the incest question popped up again. I've had this thought for a while on the repercussions of introducing sexual relationships into a familial setting. What I mean is that introducing a sexual relationship into a familial relationship could potentially lead to the degradation of a fundamental support system if the sexual relationship were to potentially fail. In the same way you break up with those not related by blood, a break up with your family member could isolate you from the one tie that seems to be biologically hardwired into us as humans to keep connected to for your own survival/happiness. Could this potentially be an answer to discourage incest (even though it doesn't necessarily attribute moral wrong to it) no matter if there is the absence of other moral wrongs like inbreeding and power imbalances? I really want to hear what y'all (and potentially Steven himself) have to say about this because it's been on my mind for a while bu I don't really have anyone to talk about it due to its admittedly niche content.
Posted Mar 23, 2019, 6:33 AM UTC
I think the main moral counterargument is that if you allow it to happen to consenting sane smart adults the chance is high that this behaviour gets copied by not so sane or smart people thus leading to all the bad stuff that can come from this. The action is immoral because if it is viewed as moral it will eventually lead to negative outcomes.
But even then you could amount it to a slippery slope.