r/cars•
MrModZix

Will manual BMW 3 series rise in value?

On the official BMW 3 series engine configurations, all petrol engines miss the manual transmission. They're all either automatic or automatic with paddle shifters.

I've done some searching and found this.

The top range versions, awaiting the arrival of the new generation of the M3, will be the M340iand M340d. Both equipped with a package design from M Performance, the two models will be the only versions of the range that will mount the six cylinders inline block with TwinScroll turbos and 3.0 liters, exclusively with all-wheel drive xDrive, differential M and eight-speed automatic transmission. https://www.bmwblog.com/2018/02/12/engines-2019-bmw-3-series-uncovered/

I was actually planning to buy a second hand manual BMW 335i in the future and I'm kind of worried. Only the new 340i will have an I6 besides the new M3. A new 335i isn't even for sale anymore and besides that, the manual transmission for petrol engines is gone in the latest 3 series.

I'm wondering: would the disappearance of the 335i combined with the fact that all petrol 3 series won't come with a manual transmission mean the value of second hand manual 335i cars would go up like crazy in the future?

Edit: I found this

The 335i is replaced by the 340i name, though displacement doesn’t change. It will get the first application of the company’s new 3.0-liter inline-six. Internally known at the B58, it will deliver 320 hp (20 more than this year’s 335i) and 330 lb-ft of torque (30 more than this year). It still uses BMW’s TwinPower technology, which consists of a twin-scroll turbo, VANOS variable camshaft timing and Valvetronic variable valve lift. https://autoweek.com/article/car-news/take-bmw-335i-your-list-its-now-340i

So the 340i replaces the 335i entirely but the manual being gone still remains. Do you guys think an old car would rise in value only for a manual transmission which isn't available on its newer model?

Posted Mar 25, 2019, 7:08 AM UTC · edited

021
magus-212016 Mazda MX-5 Miata Grand Touring MT•

Unless it's at least an M3, no.

Also: If you need to ask, then you should definitely not buy cars as investments.

27
TheBeaudet2015 Ford Focus 1.0 EcoNoboost, Kenworth semi, 13 speed manual •

The 335i didn't dissappear. BMW just changed the number to 340.

18
I_Ajvanho_I01 BMW M3 (S85 V10 6MT)•

No, of course not.

Cars, all of em, are awful investments.

Not trying to be mean, but you should maybe read a few books if you're planning on investing into something. I know it's boring but it's either that or buying a manual BMW 3 Series and losing your house.

10
MrModZixOP•

There's a lot of second hand manual 335is with 60 to 110km mileage on them going for 60-70% of their original value and I've always wanted an I6 BMW. I was asking because I was afraid the value could go up in a few years considering the death of manuals for non-M cars in the 3 series, which could be bad for me (the buyer).

-6
speedydad2017 ATS-V•

It won't, they make thousands per year. These are not rare or potential collector cars. Don't even think that the prices of any used car will go up because it's very rare outside of exotics.

9
I_Ajvanho_I01 BMW M3 (S85 V10 6MT)•

As an enthusiast I totally understand the love for manual, I can't imagine an open road on a fully automatic.

It's really rare that cars gain in value, and even when they do it's for a really good reason. The McLaren F1 for instance is worth like 20mil today cause it has no rival and it only has like 64 Mk1 road cars built total i believe.

The 3 series on the other hand isn't in any way anything special, more like "special" than anything close to special. They're mass produced daily drivers and are kind of meant to be traded in for a newer model when it comes out (or at least before the dash lights up like a Christmas tree).

Manual cars by nature hold their value a lot better than automatic counterparts, so you're always gonna see them lose their value slower.

1
stretch_muffler'19 Subaru WRX STI•

My guess is no. BMW never hold value and I don’t think losing a stick will save itself.

6
PayphonesareObsolete11 CRZ 6-spd MT•

Seriously doubt it. The M3 will continue to offer the manual. As long as that happens, all the lesser 3 series will just go down in history as regular 3 series with regular depreciation.

3
mrk240N55 335i DCT M-Sport + DRZ400E Sumo•

Maybe a grand or 2 more compared to a comparable auto but its a non-M model so its value will tank.

I purchased mine at ~33% of its original purchase price and I'll probably loose 25-30% when I do get around to selling it.

That's without maintenance and running costs factored in.

2
PwnCall12' Impreza Hatch CVT, Future Dream Car: 91' M5•

They made waaaaay to many of them to become worth much. They will be more than the autos eventually but that will be in like 20 years and will be by like 1000$ difference.

Unless it’s a really rare model than def not. And remember they made over 75k m3’s so even those aren’t that rare in terms of numbers.

2
HarvickAudiFordfan2017 Audi A4 Quattro •

There’s a bazillion of them made. They won’t rise in value one bit.

2
jpMAGA•

If you are trying to lose less money, or make money with cars, BMW is not the answer.

2
MrModZixOP•

I just want a 335i for cheap. I wass worried I might not be able to afford one if they would go up in value. Now others have pointed out that the 335i isn't anything special by any means so I guess I can still afford one in a few years.

1
jpMAGA•

Yeah the longer you wait the cheaper they will be (and the more maintenance / repair they will require). You can get 335xi's for cheap now in the south where AWD is not desirable.

2
rudbri93'91 BMW 325i S52, '99 GMC Yukon•

I think over time they will be the more desirable models compared their auto counterparts, but I also wouldnt be too surprised if people started figuring out manual swaps when that time comes so they wont be appreciating a crazy amount.

1
gsasquatch•

E30's are starting to see a rise.

I imagine a 335 will drop in value until it's 30 years old or so, then start going up from there, but not quite get back to new.

I'm not sure how dependent that will be on the transmission. It might be an oddity, but it might be like a Model T or a 3 on the tree where not many folks know how to drive them any more, limiting the market. Lots of trees are lost to floor shifters and automatic swaps each year. Save the trees!

1
photogthrowaway222•

E36's have not though, and doesn't look like they're going to for a long time (non-M at least). I think the newer generations will take even longer, and may possibly never be worth very much. Part of what makes E30's popular with enthusiasts is they're easy to work on, after E46 I don't think that can really be said of 3 series.

1
h_word2016 BMW 340i•

I would guess they will hold their value more than comparable autos. I get everyone saying that there tons of them out there but frankly the CPO market is less than 10% manual and the enthusiasts buying them are willing to play closer to sticker and willing to travel for or ship the cars (I know cause I did it). So raise in value, no, but I do expect they will be even more desirable than before since the market for them just became finite.

Not everyone with a love for manuals can afford M3s (also me) so the market exists for sure

1
MrModZixOP•

Thanks for your insight. That's exactly what I've been thinking. The manual enthusiasts who can't afford a manual M3 will opt for the 335i or 340i. I don't think the prices will go up but they'll most probably just lose value at a slower rate.

1
h_word2016 BMW 340i•

There’s also a question of how long will it take for the market to feel that effect. Who knows dude. Good luck tho!

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
speedydad2017 ATS-V•

It will on both accounts as already has.

2