A whole lot of actual science. Official rebuttal of anti vegan misinformation PART ONE
I saw an interesting post on a a particular sub that peaked my curiosity. As an open minded person, I don't like to think that I would shy away from the truth, or just an honest, objective debate. Since their sub doesn't exactly scream those characteristics, I wanted to offer a rebuttal here and who would care to judge my criticism and the data they are willing to put forth.
An article that talks about health, written by someone with a PhD in Psychiatry. Article starts off with his daughter's anecdotal relapse from vegetarianism all because the cool factor wore off, then proceeds to list reasons why vegetarians and vegans go back to eating meat. He keeps mentioning figures from a study, but never cites the specific study.
Vegans are less like to backslide than vegetarians. While 86% of vegetarians returned to meat, only 70% of vegans did.
These finding are generally consistent with other studies.
Here is a study result from one of the "other studies"
The vast majority of vegans and vegetarians stayed at least vegetarian.
There was much more movement between vegetarian and vegan than we expected.
We also theorized that vegans were more likely to stay vegetarian or vegan than vegetarians who weren't vegan in 2006 (FUCK YEAH VEGOONS)
This is the only time the word healthy is mentioned, and there's no citation
Only 29% of ex-vegetarians/vegans indicated that they experienced specific health-related symptoms while on a no-meat diet.
Source 1
Conclusions Although complementation studies have not been conducted, it is most likely these patients had cobalamin C disease. This study emphasizes the possibility of late-onset disease with purely neurological manifestations.
TISSUE VITAMIN B12 deficiency can be due to inadequate intake (as seen in vegans), acquired malabsorption
Source 2
German study of vegans who had similar lifestyles to the Adventist 2 study. Sample size of 154 German vegans.
Results:
Although TC and LDL concentrations were favorable, low HDL and elevated homocysteine and Lp(a) concentrations were unfavorable. Overall, these results confirm the notion that a vegan diet is deficient in vitamin B(12)
Based on this study, patients with peripheral arterial occlusive disease showed a significantly higher mean concentration of homocysteine than control subjects (p<0.001). There was a negative correlation between the levels of homocysteine and vitamin B12
From Dr. Michael Gregor's Website:
A regular, reliable source of vitamin B12 is critical for anyone eating a plant-based diet. Though deficiency for those starting out with adequate stores may take years to develop, the results of B12 deficiency can be devastating
Abstract:
This finding suggests that a high-fibre diet leads to enhanced elimination of 25(OH)D3 by an action within the intestinal lumen. This may involve interference with an enterohepatic circulation of the metabolite, perhaps by binding of 25(OH)D3 to dietary fibre. 4. The reduced plasma half-life of 3H-labelled 25(OH)D3 associated with a high-fibre diet may explain the development of vitamin D deficiency in Asian immigrants with normal exposure to u.v. light.
No sample size, no study parameters, no controls listed. No details. That quote was literally half the "study?".
cross-sectional study on 18 volunteers RF(raw food) vegetarian diet for a mean of 3.6 years
A RF vegetarian diet is associated with low bone mass at clinically important skeletal regions but is without evidence of increased bone turnover or impaired vitamin D status.
Body mass index was significantly lower in the RF group than in the control group
They are using vegetarian and vegan interchangeably as it seems, because they don't mention the word vegan anywhere
Nutrient intakes differed significantly between the groups. The RF vegetarians ate a variety of raw vegetables, fruits, nuts, seeds, sprouted grains, and cereals, dressed with olive oil
Take that for what you will.
Abstract
the levels of muscle creatine are known to be lower in vegetarians.
However, in vegetarians rather than in those who consume meat, creatine supplementation resulted in better memory. Irrespective of dietary style, the supplementation of creatine decreased the variability in the responses to a choice reaction-time task.
They fail to mention that people who eat an omnivorous diet also benefited from the creatine supplements
- Vegans have less gains compared to non vegans (Notice they have a mobile link, you'll have to make this work for yourself to see the actual article, as their link is broken)
Nineteen sedentary men who were overweight to moderately obese
The 13-wk study consisted of a 1-wk sedentary period
The second set of men recruited into the study (n = 11) underwent the same RT program and were counseled to self-select a LOV diet starting at week 1
The men in the LOV-diet group participated in individual and group dietary counseling sessions with the research investigators and dietary staff, with consultation from the research dietitian, to assist with adherence to the vegetarian diet.
They put obese people on a calorie rich vegetarian diet, made them work out, then compared the results to an omnivorous group. The omnis won. There it is folks. Wrap it up. I should just stop here.
- Vegans are deficient in omega threes, Source 1 Source 2
The present cross-sectional study included 196 meat-eating, 231 vegetarian, and 232 vegan men in the United Kingdom
The proportions of plasma EPA and DHA were lower in the vegetarians and in the vegans than in the meat-eaters, whereas only small differences were seen for DPA
The conclusion of the study is:
The proportions of plasma long-chain n-3 fatty acids were not significantly affected by the duration of adherence to a vegetarian or vegan diet.
Comparison with previous studies suggests that women may possess a greater capacity for ALNA conversion than men. Such metabolic capacity may be important for meeting the demands of the fetus and neonate for DHA during pregnancy and lactation
The word "deficient" is never used in either study. The latter study doesn't even look at deficiency levels, but conversion rates and the concentration amount during different stages of life of WOMEN.
Source 1
Ninety-five percent of the body carnitine pool resides in skeletal muscle where it plays a vital role in fuel metabolism.
Forty-one young (aged ≈22 y) vegetarian and nonvegetarian volunteers participated in 2 studies
Vegetarians have a lower muscle TC and reduced capacity to transport carnitine into muscle than do nonvegetarians
CARNITINE HOMEOSTASIS, MITOCHONDRIAL FUNCTION, AND CARDIOVASCULAR DISEASE
The main dietary sources of carnitine are red meat, fish, and dairy products which can supply 2 to 12 μmols/day/kg of body weight, whereas 1–2 μmols of carnitine is endogenously synthesized
It is well established that carnitines play an important role as carriers of activated fatty acids across the inner mitochondrial membrane and are essential for energy production through fatty acid metabolism.
Other factors such as enzymatic alterations in carnitine metabolism can also result in higher levels of acylated carnitines and hence an elevated AC/FC ratio.
Source 2
A 12-year old boy suffered episodes of vomiting, lethargy, and hypoglycaemia from the age of 1 year. Adhering to a vegetarian diet caused an increase in frequency and severity of the attacks. It was found that he was suffering from systemic carnitine deficiency that responded promptly to treatment with L-carnitine.
Plasma taurine levels and urinary taurine excretion were measured in 12 strict vegetarian (vegan) males who had maintained a vegan diet for 53 +/- 26 mo (SD) and in 14 male nonvegetarian control subjects.
Urinary taurine excretion was lower
urinary N tau-methylhistidine was significantly reduced
Elevation of taurine in human congestive heart failure
The concentration of taurine in the left ventricle of the heart was doubled in patients who had died of chronic congestive heart failure compared to patients who had died of other causes and had no cardiac pathology.
Taurine: a conditionally essential amino acid in humans? An overview in health and disease
While taurine is excreted through urine and bile, it is the kidney that regulates the total body pool
The amount of taurine excreted daily varies from indivi-dual to individual, and in the same individual from day to day
During periods ofinadequate dietary intake or reduced availability ofprecursor amino acids, taurine renal reabsorption isincreased favouring the maintenance of tissue stores
Urinary iodine excretion was assessed in 15 vegans, 31 lacto- and lacto-ovovegetarians and 35 adults on a mixed diet.
Iodine excretion was significantly lower in alternative nutrition groups
One fourth of the vegetarians and 80% of the vegans suffer from iodine deficiency (iodine excretion value below 100 microg/l) compared to 9% in the persons on a mixed nutrition.
History of U.S. Iodine Fortification and Supplementation
Adequate levels of iodine, a trace element variably distributed on the earth and found mostly in the soil and water of coastal areas, are required for the synthesis of the thyroid hormones,
In the U.S., iodine is present in dairy foods
Seafood is another excellent source of dietary iodine
The iodine content of plant foods depends on the iodine levels in soil and in groundwater used in irrigation
Salt iodization is a useful approach toward decreasing iodine deficiency in populations.
Iodine is required for normal brain myelination in utero and during the early post-partum period.
A Paleolithic-type diet (PD) has beneficial metabolic effects, but two of the largest iodine sources, table salt and dairy products, are excluded.
A 2-year prospective randomized trial in a tertiary referral center where healthy postmenopausal overweight or obese women were randomized... rinary iodine excretion (24-UIE), free thyroxin (FT4), free triiodothyronine (FT3) and thyrotropin (TSH) were measured at baseline, 6 and 24 months.
A PD results in a higher risk of developing ID
In a randomized, double blind, placebo controlled trial 60 healthy men supplemented with various dosages and dose strategies of coenzyme Q(10) soft oil capsules
All supplementations increased serum levels of Q(10)
You're probably wondering where there is anything written about vegans and ther CQ10 levels in this study. I am wondering that as well.
Here is Dr Michael Greger on the topic
- Vegans are deficient in iron because of bioavalability. Actual source and not government recommendations Source 1
Official Reference Material Citations:
Iron bioavailability and dietary reference values (4) (The NIH citation didn't even include the full study)
Nonheme iron is usually much less well absorbed than heme iron.
In plant-based diets, phytate (myo-inositol hexakisphosphate) is the main inhibitor of iron absorption
Calcium has been shown to have negative effects on nonheme and heme iron absorption, which makes it different from other inhibitors that affect nonheme iron absorption
The 2 major bovine milk protein fractions, casein and whey, and egg white were shown to inhibit iron absorption in humans
Phytate was shown to be the major inhibitor in soy protein isolates, but even after complete phytate degradation iron absorption from soy protein isolates was only half that of the egg-white control
Vitamin A and riboflavin deficiencies have been shown to influence iron metabolism and absorption.
In the absence of bleeding (including menstruation) or pregnancy, only a small (iron) quantity is lost each day
The average requirement (iron) for menstruating women is somewhat higher
Nonheme iron absorption depends on the solubilization of predominately ferric food iron in the acid milieu of the stomach
Both of these are more meta analysis papers than actual studies. They summarize a lot of data from a lot of studies. The word deficient, wasn't used that much through the paper or reference studies.
- Vegans are deficient in vitamin A. Where do I start with this one. They have this un-formatted garbage pinned?!
Two common single nucleotide polymorphisms ...alter beta-carotene metabolism in female volunteers
Our data show that there is genetic variability in beta-carotene metabolism and may provide an explanation for the molecular basis of the poor converter phenotype within the population
This is the only sentence I can fucking read from that article. Idk wtf it means. Idk wtf it has to do with diet. I don't think they know wtf it means either.
Loss-of-Function Mutation in Carotenoid 15,15′-Monooxygenase Identified in a Patient with Hypercarotenemia and Hypovitaminosis A. They provided a mobile link that doesn't work? Very thorough of them. I'm sure that means they read the actual literature.
Plant carotenoids are an important dietary source of vitamin A (retinol and its esters) and the sole source of vitamin A for vegetarians.
In conclusion, haploinsufficiency of the CMO1 enzyme may cause symptoms of hypercarotenemia and hypovitaminosis A in individuals consuming a carotenoid-containing and retinol-inadequate diet. Especially susceptible would be individuals on a pure vegetarian diet lacking preformed vitamin A, a situation common in developing countries where the major source of vitamin A is dietary provitamin A carotenoids
So if you take a step back and just think on those two statements for a second, you'll realize that what they are saying is: Vegetarians who don't get enough carotenoids AND have enzyme issues are prone to Vitamin A deficiency more so than someone on an omnivorous diet. Based on other research, there is a chance that more people could have that enzyme problem than previously estimated.
Here is another snippet:
These subjects had orange-yellowish skin and variable degrees of mild vitamin A deficiency and in all cases, the biochemical hallmark was high levels of circulating carotenoids .... These reports all relate to nonvegetarian individuals and the effects of reduced vitamin A
UK women at risk from vitamin A deficiency
From a volunteer group of 62 women, the team found that 29 of them -- 47 per cent -- carried the genetic variation which prevented them from being able to effectively convert beta-carotene into vitamin A.
The study also showed that all volunteers consumed only about a third of their recommended intake from 'preformed' vitamin A
This isn't a study like they claimed it to be. This is an article summary. The study it talks about is the "idk wtf is going on with female volunteers study". This isn't evidence worth referencing. I'm sure they actually took time to read the literature
Eleven healthy women were housed at the US Department of Agriculture Western Human Nutrition Research Center metabolic unit for 44 d
the women were given 30 μmol D6 retinyl acetate orally
Variable absorption and conversion of β-carotene to vitamin A both contribute to the variable response to consumption of β-carotene
So this study that only looked at 11 females, and their absorption test included consuming lab synthesized vitamin A. It wasn't a study with a plant based diet control variable.
This is the 3rd time this same study has been referenced lol. Do you think they know that?
Busting the Beta Carotene Vitamin A Myth (sounds scientific right? Prepare to be disappointed)
Given the importance of true Vitamin A in the diet, it is best to get this nutrient in a form that is readily usable by the body with no conversion required.
Uncited claim
Periods of stress, rigorous exercise and fevers deplete this critical nutrient even more making a daily dose of fermented cod liver oil, arguably the best and most easily obtained whole food which supplies Vitamin A in adequate amounts (sources), extremely important.
Uncited Claim. The "sources" is a link to a supplement seller LOLOLOL!
Other excellent sources are pastured butter, egg yolks, grassfed cream and milk, liver and shellfish. Note that supermarket butter would contain little Vitamin A as cows are only be able to produce this nutrient if grazing on green grass.
Uncited claim.
Why You Won’t Get Vitamin A From Carrots (sounds scientific right? Prepare to be disappointed)
First, when we are in pristine health, it requires at least six units of carotenes to convert into 1 unit of retinol
Their source is a Weston A Price article.
Second, the carotene-to-retinol conversion is HIGHLY compromised
Uncited claim
Without a doubt, regular consumption of pasture-rasied liver is the most effective way to consume optimal levels of this vitamin
Uncited claim
This is a paragraph from the Weston A Price article
This is the ACTUAL Weston A Price article that's been referenced multiple times.
Vitamin A and the Beta-Carotene Myth
Nothing in this article is cited.
The body weight gain of the calcium-deficient rats for 8 days receiving a calcium-deficient diet supplemented with raw-powdered spinach (R-sp), boiled-powdered spinach (B-sp), or calcium-oxalate (Ca-ox), and a control diet supplemented with oxalic acid (OX-C)
The calcium content in the left tibiae of the rats receiving Ca-ox and OX-C diets was higher than that of the rats receiving R-sp and B-sp diets.
An 8 day study on rats. The peak of the scientific method.
Nine healthy adults participated in the study.
The results from the present study demonstrated that apparent Mg absorption was significantly lower from the meal served with spinach than the meal served with kale
However, the lower fractional apparent Mg absorption from the test meal served with spinach can be assumed to be, at least partly, counterbalanced by the higher native Mg content of spinach as compared with kale.
Does this mean we all need to buy Kale University shirts?
Source 1
Semen analysis of 66 unmarried medical students in the age group of 17-21 years was carried out
Liquefaction time, pH and sperm count was found significantly different in non-vegetarians and vegetarians, perhaps due to difference in their dietary proteins.
Apparently different means lower? That's a new one for me.
Source 2
Given the large populations in many soyfood-consuming countries, it is ironic that concerns have been voiced that the estrogen-like effects of isoflavones could exert feminizing effects on men and impair fertility. Studies that lend credence to these concerns include rodent research showing isoflavone exposure lowers circulating testosterone levels and sperm concentration
Finally, in contrast to the pilot epidemiologic study cited previously, none of the three clinical studies conducted found adverse effects of soy or isoflavones on sperm or semen parameters [227,228,229]. In fact, as described in a case report published in 2004, a man with low sperm count who was unable to father a child experienced an improvement in sperm concentration and motility resulting in a successful pregnancy after being given isoflavones for six months
I hate to bring it up, but do you think they might be compensating for something? I might be a sexist assuming they're all dudes. I'll take it.
- Vegans have lower testosterone than non vegans
The effect of a lacto-ovo vegetarian (V) and a mixed, meat-rich (M) diet on the level of serum sex hormones, gonadotropins, and endurance performance of eight male endurance athletes was investigated in a 2 x 6 wk cross-over study.
Endurance performance time was higher for six and lower for two after the mixed diet compared with the vegetarian diet. This was not significant, however.
In conclusion, 6 wk on a lacto-ovo vegetarian diet caused a minor decrease in total testosterone and no significant changes in physical performance in male endurance athletes compared with 6 wk on a mixed, meatrich diet.
Source 2 why are all their links mobile?
The relationship between dietary nutrients and plasma testosterone ...and prolactin levels was investigated in 12 Seventh-Day Adventist (SDA) vegetarian (SV), 10 SDA nonvegetarian (SNV), and 8 non-SDA nonvegetarian (NV) men and 3-day dietary intake information were obtained from each subject.
Plasma levels of testosterone and estradiol-17β were significantly lower in the SV than in the omnivores.
A lower nocturnal release of prolactin and testosterone occurred in men fed a vegetarian diet, while in women, dexamethasone administration decreased the nocturnal release of prolactin and caused a greater decrease of plasma dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA)
Source 4 (actually a great source. kudos to them for linking it)
Twelve healthy men with at least 1 yr of resistance training experience volunteered to participate in this investigation.
Our results demonstrated that dietary protein, fat, SFA, MUFA, PUFA/SFA ratio, and protein-to-carbohydrate ratio were all significantly correlated with preexercise T concentrations.
The significant negative correlation between protein and resting T concentrations is consistent with the findings of Anderson et al. (2), who demonstrated that a low-protein diet (10% of total energy) was associated with higher levels of T compared with a diet higher in protein (44% of total energy).
the present investigation, dietary fat, SFA, and MUFA were the best predictors of resting T concentrations.
dietary lipids appear to have a significant influence on resting T concentrations
This is another snippet from source 4. It disqualifies the study findings in Source 2
2–3 wk of diet information appears to be required to obtain reliable data (21). Most other studies have used much shorter time periods to obtain individual food intake information; thus their reliability and accuracy may be questionable
Posted Mar 28, 2019, 7:44 PM UTC
[deleted]
[deleted]
[deleted]