Comparing Tropico 6 to Tropicos 5 and 4
I hit the character limit in my review of Tropico 6 on steam so here I’ll compare it more directly to the last two.
https://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198107068805/recommended/492720/
Compared to Tropico 5, this game is almost certainly superior in almost every way. Besides some very specific edicts, UI elements in the almanac, or building effects, this game simply includes nearly every feature and building from Tropico 5 and its expansions and adds in a much better simulation. The same era system is here but improved, research is more interesting and less restricting, the trade system is much better (although you can’t import as freely as in 4) letting you choose how much to import and export and having more deals available, there are more resources and factories, using multiple islands is fun and satisfying. The elements of 5 that are absent is a single self contained mission at a time campaign instead of the long dual island campaigns of 5, a one use police blimp building that only acts as a moving police station, an inferior loan/debt system, a less satisfying rebel system, and while the tourist types still exist they feel much less important. The dynasty system is absent but that isn’t a bad thing, although the traits and customization options available for Presidente feel even fewer. Foreign powers have lost some flavor compared to the past, as they don’t really care about your policies or factions, just how you praise or trade with them. There are more characters than in past games, one for each of the ten factions (two for the first era that go away, four for the second, and two each for the third and fourth eras), although I wish they had more lines and appeared on the radio. The Jolly Roger and Lulu are gone, replaced with a nameless relatively generic announcer and the radio dialogue is an exception to the generally good writing. Not all edicts carried over unfortunately, although there are new interesting ones introduced. All that being said, you would be hard pressed not to say that Tropico 6 is much better than Tropico 5, which rarely felt as deep or satisfying and seemed to cut so many corners in comparison, few of which were substantively improved after release.
Comparing this to Tropico 4 is a little hard. It can feel like this game is based on Tropico 5, stripping out the things fans disliked and improving it in every way, but not capturing all the good parts of Tropico 4. Right off the bat is the fact that Tropico 6 does not let you set wages, rents, and prices the way it did in Tropico 4 where you set the exact dollar price or wage. That alone probably makes Tropico 4 unreplaceable so far and it’s worth trying for anyone interested in simulation or city building games. 6 uses the system found in Tropico 5, but tweaks it by a) making wages a number value that is still changed changing a budget, and b) citizens wealth level is calculated by the wages of each whole family, reduced for any kids (this is why there is a child benefits edict). This system technically is a step up from 5, but it can sometimes feel like it is more complex without giving you the satisfying level of control in 4. Citizens also have fewer traits than in 4, no intelligence or courage or job skill. There are however more factions (no loyalists), although it inherits the very tight system where the factions are divided into pairs by era and each citizen is a member of one or the other. But while factions now have a way to threaten you with a strike or financial crisis, it feels harder to have an island distinctly build around one faction like was possible in the past. The lack of traits is a step back in a number of ways, they feel tacked on and backgrounds technically are in the game but are completely locked into the Cold War era research for the childhood museum (workmodes let you change your background for relations benefits) and aren’t as consequential. The ability to build across multiple islands feels great, much better than I expected and it lets goods and people move by water. Transportation options otherwise are a mixed bag and you can start to miss the old system with garages giving every citizen a car to move around (there is an edict to allow this but it doesn’t work as well and the game isn’t made for it). This game also doesn’t have the issue of exports not being sent because there are no teamsters at the dock, it automatically exports when the ship arrives. The era system is both a blessing and a curse. It adds more flavor and in theory allows the game to simulate more aspects of an island nation/dystopia. However the pacing of the game feels less refined because much of that work is offloaded onto the era system, but the colonial era feels like it takes way too long, causing you to have already built your island in before you get independence. It can feel like you’ve solved your economy before the world wars are over, which makes the late game less satisfying. This did exist to a lesser extent in 4, but here it can render the whole modern era superfluous, which is a bigger problem. The feel of just booting up a sandbox map and playing feels a little weaker than 4, although that may come from me starting with a bigger budget and tourism does feel better in this Tropico especially in the modern era. For the Tropico 4 player I would still recommend picking the game up, making suggestions on the forums as the devs have said they’re going to keep supporting the game and adding features post release, and hope/ask for mod support so the game can grow and deepen over time.
Edit: The coup system has been replaced with something that is much worse. I didn't think about it but coups were always an important part of Tropico and the game feels a lot less tense and the politics don't feel as realistic or dynamic without it.
Posted Mar 30, 2019, 12:48 AM UTC · edited
Personally this game - for me - feels more like Tropico 3 and Tropico 5 had a baby
We've got Tropico 3's scenarios rather than 'a campaign' - and less of Tropico 5's problems while refining what few strengths it had.
I understand not allowing us to set EXACT wages, prices and rent as we did in 4 because that systems was INFINITELY abusable - unfortunately, with how many abusable systems there ARE in 5 and 6 - it almost feels like they're trying to balance something without really taking a look at the overall picture or implementing a replacement option that still feels rewarding.
The era system is a problem and will always be a problem because the 'hard' parts, accurately speaking, are in the Colonial and World War eras. By the time you get to Modern the only REAL way they've got to hinder your development is to throw random events at your head. The only way I can see this really becoming fixable is to add needs and wants to our citizens that can spiral into a problem once we reach modern times if we don't fulfill them - and also add more requirements for building things that can only be satisfied by certain resources and buildings that you unlock in the modern age.
Unfortunately, though, while this might 'fix' the ease - it would also expand the amount of tedious busy work and would likely ANNOY more than anything else.
[deleted]