r/thedivision•
Shvay

Does The Division 2 feel dumbed down?

Discussion

Basically just the title. Coming from the division 1, the sequel just feels like it’s missing so many little things that made the first game good. The main thing for me is the amount of cosmetics you got in the first one, there was just an insane amount different styles of coats, scarves, hats etc. now in this game I have like 3 jackets with no visual appeal.

I can’t really give any other examples besides the cosmetics, but something feels off. Anyone else feeling this way or is it just me?

Edit: The cosmetics was a bad example. It’s more of something along the lines of changing stuff that didn’t need to be changed from the first game, but it’s hard because I can’t quite put my finger on it.

Posted Mar 30, 2019, 5:39 AM UTC · edited

024
dmania1611611•

Div 1 has been out 3 years with numerous updates.

Div 2 has been out 2 weeks.

Of course it will feel lacking by comparison. Compared to div 1 at launch div 2 is lightyears ahead.

8
madilililow :Rogue: •

But there was honestly not that many memorable things that came after release with the updates. Most things people like me miss from the first game were things that were in the game from day 1.

-3
dmania1611611•

You’ve got to be kidding 😂. Div 1 was a dumpster fire at launch. Lost a huge portion of its playerbase before the updates that made it a great game.

3
madilililow :Rogue: •

Some of us never left. Its things like the environment, like recalibration, like weapon mods, sound effects, stats, talents, The Dark Zone etc that I miss from the first game. It has nothing to do with the content taht was on day one or came later. The game had problems in the beginning with loot and difficulty scaling, but that was it. Some people like you jumped in the bandwagon because I guess people are afraid of enjoying things other people make fun of or something.

-2
dmania1611611•

Who said I jumped in the bandwagon. Played div 1 for years 😂 It was terrible at launch but got incredibly good after it started getting updates. Div 2 has started off much better and will finish much better than div 1 ever was.

1
RedmanabirdsSHD :SHD:•

I did not think your major takeaway would be apparel, so I got nothing.

4
Bloodaxe007•

I think dumbed down is the wrong word. How can something that does not effect gameplay, be an example of the game being dumbed down?

Sure the cosmetic system is flat out worse, but that’s got nothing to do with playing the game. And i cant think of any other examples either so, no.

If you have a bad feeling, but you cant explain it think it might just be you.

3
ShvayOP•

I guess another thing I can think of is the movement. Yeah sure they took out chicken dancing but it’s just clunky as can be now. I feel like a fat ass running around...

And yeah maybe dumbed down isn’t the right word, but it’s like they changed all this stuff that didn’t need to be changed.

-1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
Arsenic_Touch(PC) Valar Morghulis•

No, aside from the change in gun mod attachments, which I prefered the old system to the new(I'd also prefer more variation in the mods). The cosmetic thing isn't an issue for me because they added quite a few cosmetics to the game over the course of the first game and they can easily do the same here, especially if people keep letting them know about it.

And the change to skill power, I like the new system (if the requirement wasn't so bloody much, I wish there was more variation to the mods) and that skill power did help some with scaling the power of skills, not to the extent that it was in the previous game, but enough that you can feel a difference.

I think they did us a solid with the ability to dye equipment now, I just hope they provide better dye channels for the items, or even multiple dye channels to add more customization. Some equipment doesn't dye right, so I think they need to go back and look at some of them. Same goes for guns, multiple dye channels and better overall colour schemes.

2
ttayl•

Not sure I understand what you mean. However I do agree the cosmetic system absolutely sucks. I think though they put most of it behind the loot crates which you have to pay money. I loved in TD1 the cosmetic vendor, I wish they had one in TD2.

2
Stillburgh•

You don't have to spend money lol. I got 10 keys the last 2 days just off opening the proficiency caches. Ive probably opened close to 15 since launch without dumping a cent into mtx.

1
ttayl•

Very true. Good point. I forgot about the keys you get from with caches.

2
Stillburgh•

Yeah i wasnt trying to come off as a dick like 'you idiot'. If it came off that way i apologize.

2
ttayl•

All good. Not at all.

2
dh625y•

I think I understand and agree..

Whilst the core game play is better even than TD1 1.8 let alone the TD1 first release, and the 1:1 modelling of DC is beautifully realised, the points you raise are worse and that really is head-scratchingly hard to understand why.

The NPCs are weaker (Benitez, I mean the guy was a legend), the story is weaker, the base upgrades were underwhelming. the factions are less diverse and less distinct, the lack of normal people on the streets (understandable and consistent with the story but sadly lacking for me) takes away atmosphere. And DC is just not iconic to someone like me who is not American in the way that New York is as the defacto capital of the world.

I’m less concerned with the other points you make, and in fact I am very happy with how weapon attachments now work, but am equally frustrated with how gear and skill mods work. Otherwise I accept it is a new game and am willing to adjust. Having said that, if they had kept it the same as TD1 I would have been more than happy.

Will I go back to TD1? Have done once already but I much preferred the TD2 core gameplay feel. So overall TD2 is a triumph in its core mechanics and that’s really what matters. But I can’t shake the feeling that it something is missing in the soul of the game that was present in TD1.

1
sickboy76•

The rocket science required to recalibrate and positive/negative weapon stats. Actually having to manually operated skills rather than just throwing and leaving. Having to plan builds rather than just get the meta classified set, seems a lot dumber to me.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
ShvayOP•

You obviously only read the title, didn’t mention any of these points you made. Seems like you’re having a bad day.

1
sickboy76•

Hardly my friend I read it as painful as it was to hear you whine because cosmetics being different somehow dumbed the game down. Making a click bait title helps huh?

1
ShvayOP•

Yeah because I care so much about karma

1
MrLeviJeans•

The cosmetics really weren’t that good at launch, it was just hundreds of recolors. The cosmetics were added over time just like they will in this game.

1
madilililow :Rogue: •

I honestly just wish this game would have just been a $60 expansion for the first game where they added the new map and all the new things but didnt change none of the working-well things from TD1. The more I play this game the more I miss how things were in TD1 but I just cannot go back to TD1 anymore. After 2000 hrs I have completely exhausted anything and everything that there is to do there.

Im talking about things like the environment, player movement, recalibration, weapon mods, skills, the DZ, having main stats, Characters like Faye, Benitez or even Larae, the way stats worked on gear, a lot of sound effects like the seeker mine sound, headshot sounds, pulse, or the sound of bullets hitting weakspots, having ISAC saying transmissions jammed and all that and the tense sound effect afterwards that really set the mood for the DZ, civilians in the streets or screaming from their apartments, populated safehouses, Rick Valassi, the Cleaners etc.

​

TD2 got alot of things right and improved in a lot of ways but it also ruined a lot of things that worked well in the first game and had no reason to be changed.

0