FreakinWolfy•

No! The suffix -gate WILL NOT be used for this. I swear to you on my life.

39
[deleted]•

[deleted]

32
mindbleach•

The Saydrah Problem.

9
[deleted]•

The Saydilly of a pickle.

4
[deleted]•

[deleted]

8
zem•

The Saydrah Incident

1
BraveSirRobin•

Saydramela.

0
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
memsisthefuture•

The Saydrah Code.

0
DirtyHerring•

Saydraq?

0
Sentinell•

And so the gate-gate begins.

11
gleapsite•

Can you Saydrama?

2
zem•

fight the good fight!

0
Augzodia•

I prefer:

hurf durf durf internet drama

27
THE_PUN_STOPS_HERE•

And you know no one will remember it in two weeks...

5
squidboots•

Well...he summarizes some of it, but not all of it. He sidesteps one huge issue: conflict of interest. I am definitely not crazy about all the Saydrah hate around here lately (no one deserves to be called those nasty things, regardless of what they have done), but all of this coming to a head has brought up this issue and it needs to be addressed.

I accept that some moderators are prolific submitters. However, I draw the line when a moderator submits content for profit, especially when the person is as "high profile" as qgyh2, Saydrah, even kleinbl00. People like that have people who love them and people who hate them, and like it or not, this does affect voting.

This problem of being high-profile, a moderator, and submitting content for profit defeats two things that I believe for the most part work on reddit: the checks-and-balances between moderators & spammers, and voting on a submission based the merit of its content and not the reputation of the submitter. What really rubs me the wrong way about this whole ordeal is that Saydrah clearly violated both of those things, and even worse, she was not transparent about some of her motives for being on reddit and lied when confronted with hard evidence.

The solution IMO? She should relinquish all of her moderator privileges and carry on like nothing happened. She has a right to be here, no matter what transgressed. She has a right to submit content for profit (many people here do). She has a right to be hated and a right to be loved. However, she currently oversteps herself by being in a position where she can bypass the filters and suppress the submissions of others when she has a vested financial interest for doing so.

That's my two cents on the whole thing.

12
kermityfrog•

I'm meh on the whole ordeal, but am annoyed in that she banned someone else for "spamming" - when all he did was post a link to a pic on his blog (and all the blog had was a single google adsense ad). To me that's just dirty and especially hypocritical.

Otherwise, she could have just modded and commented as Saydrah, and posted all her moneymaking links with another profile and no one would have been the wiser.

7
squidboots•

She could have, but the thing is - that wouldn't have gotten her what she wanted. Part of her whole scheme was to build trusting relationships with users and become recognizable so that she could garner upvotes based on her reputation. It's this deception and manipulation which I find so troubling.

3
OlympicPirate•

I've been warning reddit about power users for years. But I usually get downvoted. Or worse, some idiot says "Oh why don't you submit more then", which would actually be hypocritical since I think people should be submitting less.

With all the people on reddit, the chance of being the first person to find a great link in a year is probably one in a thousand. Anyone who submits more than one thing a day should therefore be considered a spammer. But users like Saydrah, kleinbl00 and qgyh2 seem to submit dozens of links a day. Obviously, the quality of their links must be low. And a short glance at their submission history confirms this.

Just looking at kleinbl00's most recent posts, I can see they are ALL doubles postings, and I can find one worth reading. Despite this, I can't downvote all of his posts except that one, because if you downvote too many of someone's posts, the downvotes don't count!

The reddit designers have put up with these spammers for a long time, because more spam means we have to spend more time on reddit to find the same amount of quality links, and during that time we see more ads. Hopefully, we're reaching the point where the general user opposes this, and it might get fixed soon.

6
kleinbl00•

Saydrah, kleinbl00 and qgyh2 seem to submit dozens of links a day.

I can only speak for myself when I say that I'm probably good for a dozen links on a good day. This is due primarily to the fact that I've finally figured out how RSS feeds work. I've been particularly prolific lately because I've got a new toy and had several weeks' worth of backlog saved up while I was waiting for the admins to unfuck the subreddit (it's a year old, but up until Thursday was a banned subreddit dedicated to real estate in South Florida; I asked the Admins nicely if I could annex it and attempt to renovate it).

Just looking at kleinbl00's most recent posts, I can see they are ALL doubles postings, and I can find one worth reading.

This would be a useful discussion to have. I've felt similarly to you in the past - if you've got one link, post it in one place, for fuck's sake, and let it live or die there. But with the diaspora of old users from the frontpage subreddits (pics, wtf, askreddit) and the proliferation of new and specialized subreddits (favors, offbeat, geek) I've changed my tune. Stuff gets lost too easily. The audience of any particular bit of news may not be one subreddit, it may be a venn diagram. It would be nice if there were a clean way to deal with this.

What I would like, ideally, is to have one submission that can be "tagged" with multiple subreddits. The system we have now diverges too much discussion (for example, I didn't even know this submission existed until someone pointed it out - and I think there are discussions in here I should participate in) and is too prone to spamming.

Despite this, I can't downvote all of his posts except that one, because if you downvote too many of someone's posts, the downvotes don't count!

I'm sorry you don't like any of my posts. By all means, downvote them. My understanding - which may be flawed - is that you can't mass-downvote from the user's page, but you can mass-downvote from the subreddit. Which, frankly, would suit me just fine - it would mean you're visiting that subreddit which is really all I want out of it. I created it because I follow a crapload of RSS feeds related to the real estate bubble that don't really fit in r/economics or r/business, but they should get read... and I couldn't find a decent forum for them so I asked to annex r/realestate. Frankly, I'd love it if someone were moderating it besides me. Hell, I'd love it if someone were reading it besides me...

And I'll admit it - I post to multiple subreddits for experimentation. What I've found is that the smaller the subreddit, the more upvotes something gets... but then, you always hope that a whole bunch of people will see it in the main reddits, so you try anyway (another issue that tagging would resolve). I've also hoped that by posting stuff to r/business and r/economics and cross-posting it to r/realestate would bring people in... but what it seems to do is encourage people to downvote both. Again, I'm learning. The dynamic of Reddit today is different from the dynamic of Reddit six months or a year ago.

The reddit designers have put up with these spammers for a long time, because more spam means we have to spend more time on reddit to find the same amount of quality links, and during that time we see more ads. Hopefully, we're reaching the point where the general user opposes this, and it might get fixed soon.

Several months ago, I whined like a little bitch to the admins about any number of ills. They eventually started listening, and I started speaking in a much more civil tone of voice. I now get responses back when I PM them, which is awesome, and one of the things we discuss a lot is spam. I've suggested several things, and some of them are, as far as I understand it, under consideration. Things would probably be different if site stability weren't sucking down much of the admins' time. If they're doing what I think they're doing (and can't discuss in any more than a speculative way) it's going to be cool.

6
roll-fizzlebeef•

I hate nothing on this earth more than the use of -gate as a suffix to imply controversy. Goddamn, that shit is idiotic.

3
nix0n•

Yeah!

12
Cybermg•

-gate-gate!

7
Mr_A•

Really? You hate it? Were you around Australia last year for the media shitstorm that was Utegate?

1
stilesjp•

Roll-fizzlebeef-gate just... it just doesn't have a good ring to it.

1
doogleduck•

I like the way this is a bestof post from a bestof post.

3
kleinbl00•

r/bestof now has about 50,000 subscribers. It's a meta-eventuality.

2
sakebomb69•

I've been bitching about georgewashingtonsblog and IAmPerfectlyCalm for years but did anyone chime in? Noooooooooooooo

3
[deleted]•

I think a point he misses is that there were people who thought they had a genuine connection with Saydrah, maybe even a genuine friendship. Maybe the talked to them during a hard time in their life, maybe she gave them advice on what kind of jeans to buy. I don't know. The point is those connections weren't actually genuine at all, she was just "build[ing] authentic relationships" to "multiply [her] promotional potential".

It's llike finding out a friend you used to hang out with wasn't doing it because that's what they wanted to do, but rather because they were paid to do it.

Frankly I don't really care about the moderator contoversy, it's that deception that pisses me off, and if I was one of those "genuine connections" she had built, I'd be feeling pretty fucking bitter about the whole thing.

2
dawnvivant•

It's llike finding out a friend you used to hang out with wasn't doing it because that's what they wanted to do, but rather because they were paid to do it.

It makes me wonder though, what came first. Did she come to reddit JUST to "build authentic relationships" and "multiply promotional potential" in order to get the job(s) she has in the first place? Or did she join the community, love it and make friends and build relationships and give helpful advice and then think, "damn, I could be making some money while I do this"? If it's the latter then I kind of feel bad...wouldn't we all like to make money doing the things that we love? (Not that I'm defending her, just that I can see where she might be coming from) Also, at what point did she become a mod -- before she became an SEO or after?

5
kleinbl00•

I think a point he misses is that there were people who thought they had a genuine connection with Saydrah, maybe even a genuine friendship.

I think you're right. In my defense, Saydrah has long rubbed me the wrong way so the thought simply didn't occur to me. I am not the universe, however, and you're absolutely correct.

In reading the responses here and in the original thread (which was buried in the negative numbers for much of yesterday, thereby generating little discussion until last night) I'm coming to the conclusion that the core issue of this whole brouhaha is trust. And I don't think that anyone can restore that trust other than Saydrah.

5
ebayblows•

Saydrah's biggest crime is putting that no-talent hack Oatmeal into a sympathetic light. Damn you for making me feel conflicted.

1
Jinno•

This isn't a summarization. It's a Sayrdrah-sided rebuttal.

-1
kleinbl00•

I didn't intend it to be. I've had my run-ins with her in the past. However, if I were to indict Saydrah, it would be for felony irritation and misdemeanor spamming. I think the community at large would swap the two.

9
[deleted]•

The post title should be: kleinbl00, siding with Saydrah and ignoring that whole uncomfortable conflict-of-interest issue

-1
kleinbl00•

It was not a conscious omission. Others have summed it up in a way that I agree with. The conflict-of-interest issue is indeed uncomfortable and, were I Saydrah, I'd resolve it by stepping down as moderator. If she doesn't, I'd say it says a lot.

7
[deleted]•

I eat my words. Yum.

3
Suppy•

Kleinbl00 is smart.

-1