“The one you should not have killed.” Is Sammy

This just hit me but i want to shoot for it anyway. Apologies on format i am on mobile. My apologies as this all isnt as orderly as i wish, it’s at current my flow of thought, and how i justify it. So please bare in mind what i mean, not what i am coming accross as.

In the beginning of the series of the fnaf timeline there was 1 murder specifically shared by both the games and the books; the murder of Henry’s daughter, Charlie. Though in the games she is never called charlie that is what i will call her.

In the book however it is an ongoing problem with Charlie that Her twin Brother Sammy is dead. Theres photos of him and herself together as infants, charlie has memory of herself and Sammy beingn taught about spring locks. Just enough evidence to solidify the fact he exists.

In the games Charlie exists, and was killed, she was put into the body of the puppet, and she will haunt it till the puppet is gone.

What i think is that Sammy exists in the games aswell, and not as just a person in the timeline, i think he is “The one you should not have killed.” Yes the one that is causing all the torment in UCN, that guy (referred to as HE by accounts mentioning him) its the only thing that makes sense to me.

Now i understand that’s a huge leap to drag a book character into the game so hear me out. Something that has always been irritating to me that exists in the games is one character; Golden Freddy.

He is supposedly the one who should not have been killed as he is one of the few characters in the games to have control over the view of his surroundings(i.e poster changing), the ability to change his looks(looking like classic freddy in fnaf 1, but looking beat up and ragged in fnaf2 and so on including UCN), aswell as the ability to move his suit without animatronics inside. Which all shows he is very special, and haunts whoever takes on the role as security guard.

Wouldnt it make sense that if Afton got into the habit of stuffing people in suits, he would likely have started that at the beginning of his murders? Which he supposedly started with Charlie.

I think that in the games afton didnt only kill Charlie, i think he also killed Sammy, but Afton (having not gotten the habit of putting children into animatronics until after the death of charlie, given the puppet was given new life after it went out in the rain and collapsed on her dead body) could only stuff Sammy into the closest hiding place; a springlock suit. A golden freddy, springlock suit.

Afton never himself denied killing Sammy, he only ever said “-I took you” to Charlie, when in reference to when he appeared and took charlie while she was hiding in the costume closet.

I am unsure what Afton wouldve done to Sammy in the books, but im sure that this is what he did to Sammy in the games.

The main animatronics in the games to show powers beyond beingn able to move a suit only include Golden Freddy and the Marionette, the twins.

The marionette gives gifts, gives life. Golden freddy only takes it, from the security guard.

I’ll be blunt with the supporting facts.

The books and the games have alot in common. (Yes two different canons but Scott has often put questions in the games that have been answered by the books, and vice versa. So please dont comment saying anything along the lines of “blah blah-Two different universes and canons so they shouldnt be connected-blah blah”)

Thus far we have heard about someone in fnaf UCN dubbed “The one you should not have killed.”

In the timeline supposedly Withered Chica was the “first” to die, and she has also seen “TOYSNHK.”

Withered Chica’s lines about that are as follows; “I was the first, i have seen everything.” (Which she cant mean the very first because she wouldnt have been alive if not brought to life by the puppet) “I have seen him, the one you should not have killed”

In the books Charlie finds photos of herself, her father, and Sammy, her supposed brother that was murdered. The book has evidence of his existence, a photo, which cant be played off as Charlie’s memory being wrong.