RE: Canada's changes in the recent patch
Disclaimer: most of this is personal opinion and I'm in no way expecting unanimous agreement on the things I suggest be implemented.
I'm your run-of-the-mill Deity+Standard player. Maybe you've seen some of my CV finishes peppered around this sub from time to time. I've played a LOT of cultural victories since GS was released and my preliminary conclusion is that Canada is in a weak spot right now (yes, even in light of the mine buffs). I wanted to make this thread to highlight some of the reasons why I consider them weak and how they should be improved considering their overall agenda of culture/tourism.
Reasons they're weak
Tundra starts are awful, and you don't need to be knowledgeable about the game to feel this.
-
Tundra tiles have 30-50% worse yields than other terrain types. Right off the bat, any civ bordering on tundra blocs will have a really hard time getting their capital off the ground.
-
In terms of harvests, tundra tiles have comparable hammer yields (deer and wood, mostly) but fall far short of the food potential of grassland/plain blocs. There are no harvestable food resources at all in tundra terrain.
-
Harvesting wood for hammers negatively impacts Canada's appeal-dependent win condition for obvious reasons. This is an issue that doesn't exist for other civs with particular advantages in achieving their preferred win condition. Simply put: Canada has the same infrastructure/wonder requirements as other cultural civs, but must also sacrifice worker charges on top of harvesting to replant trees. In comparison, every other cultural civ have distinct advantages and no associated downsides.
The combination of these issues have made Canada's tundra bias devastating for their early game. Canadian tundra farms are decidedly weaker than farms on other terrain. Furthermore, while other civs have the potential to harvest huge quantities of food from their terrain bias, Canada must settle against their bias and avoid the terrain they're designed for to achieve the same thing. Compared to other civs, Canada's ability to create tundra farms does not offset their natural disadvantage. There are no other options down the tech/civic trees to remedy this inherent disadvantage either.
How Canada should be improved
The mines buff only brings Canadian mines on par with regular mines from other civs. While, yet again, directly impacting their appeal-dependent win condition. Here are some alternative suggestions I've read/formulated that can offset Canada's disadvantage without forcing the player to make difficult trade-offs (these can be implemented individually):
-
Districts placed on tundra receive food/production relevant to their adjacency bonus. Canada's lack of growth and therefore production makes discounted districts very important. Hard-building your first few districts to catch district discounts is an especially painful process and Canada should be rewarded in some way for settling near tundra. Some moderate yields will help normalize Canada's early game tempo.
-
Lumber mills do not block national park placement. Lumber mills can be built earlier.
-
Mines do not negatively impact appeal in Canadian borders.
The idea behind these changes are to give Canada an edge in developing infrastructure in harsh terrain without negatively impacting their conservation-based agenda. I'm interested in hearing what you guys think, or how you might go about balancing Canada in the new expansion.
Posted Apr 2, 2019, 11:18 PM UTC · edited