Subtle Key Changes in Pop Music
Hey guys-
I love in pop/rock songs when there's really subtle key changes- meaning, not the whole-step-up, bombastic thing you'd think of when you think key changes in pop music (think 'Man in the Mirror'). I'm a songwriter with a music degree looking mostly for inspiration, and I really love when a song manipulates you in this way. I'll show you some favorites so you see what I mean:
The Corrs- Breathless
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vzerbXFwGCE
It happens in the chorus, first one's at :58. I really can't get over how clever this is. Pretty standard chord changes in the key of B for the verse, sets up a dominant to go back in to the chorus, but then back down to E, the IV, as the new tonic. And the melody leads in perfectly. Really clever.
The Cardigans- Lovefool
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NI6aOFI7hms
Really clever chromatic modulation in the prechorus (we've been in C so far), landing the chorus in A. First one starts around :38. This makes the chorus pop in a really subtle way, and a minor third apart too. Probably also has something to do with the almost talk-y delivery of the vocal in that prechorus as well. The turnaround back down to C for the next verse is probably my favorite part (first one at 1:19). We've been in A major for a while, and it lands us on A minor in the end, feeling really natural. Really really smart songwriting all around.
The Smashing Pumpkins - In The Arms of Sleep
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=td3bX6RF0lI
Starting in G minor, two chord progression, chords go from Gminor to Fmajor and down to Eb major, which makes sense, but now Eb major is the tonic! Happens for the first time at :45. You get that 'relief' feeling of going from minor to major but it pops even more than if it had been Bb major.
The Cranberries - Dreams
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yam5uK6e-bQ
OK, maybe this one's not as subtle, but that instrumental bridge at 1:33, a minor third up. No modulation here, maybe doesn't totally line up with the rest of my examples, but I feel like you'd never hear something like this in a radio song nowadays and I just love it.
The Police - Message in a Bottle
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbXWrmQW-OE
This is a perfect example of what I'm talking about. Verse is in E major, chord progression ends on F#minor, the ii of E major, and we haven't hit an E (tonic) chord yet, but instead of going there for the chorus ( first one at :33), all of a sudden we're in A major. This really is exactly what I love in pop writing, something you don't even register as a key change but makes the song that much more exciting. This is the "subtle manipulation" I'm talking about.
Anyway, would love to hear other examples you guys have. And I'm especially interested to hear any newer pop songs that do this, I can't think of any.
Posted Apr 3, 2019, 11:47 AM UTC · edited
The Zephyr Song by Red Hot Chill Peppers modulates from Am up to Dmaj as it goes from the verse into the chorus, effectively pushing the main 'centre' of the song up by a whole tone. It has the effect of really brightening up the track, and it also means that the chorus ends on the Amaj before switching to Am into the verse, which is a great way to change the mood of the track in quite a stark way.
I change the key from C to D. You see to me it's just a minor thing, yo.
You know everything!
0_o
It's, "He knows everything."