Subtle Key Changes in Pop Music

Hey guys-

I love in pop/rock songs when there's really subtle key changes- meaning, not the whole-step-up, bombastic thing you'd think of when you think key changes in pop music (think 'Man in the Mirror'). I'm a songwriter with a music degree looking mostly for inspiration, and I really love when a song manipulates you in this way. I'll show you some favorites so you see what I mean:

The Corrs- Breathless

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vzerbXFwGCE

It happens in the chorus, first one's at :58. I really can't get over how clever this is. Pretty standard chord changes in the key of B for the verse, sets up a dominant to go back in to the chorus, but then back down to E, the IV, as the new tonic. And the melody leads in perfectly. Really clever.

​

The Cardigans- Lovefool

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NI6aOFI7hms

Really clever chromatic modulation in the prechorus (we've been in C so far), landing the chorus in A. First one starts around :38. This makes the chorus pop in a really subtle way, and a minor third apart too. Probably also has something to do with the almost talk-y delivery of the vocal in that prechorus as well. The turnaround back down to C for the next verse is probably my favorite part (first one at 1:19). We've been in A major for a while, and it lands us on A minor in the end, feeling really natural. Really really smart songwriting all around.

​

The Smashing Pumpkins - In The Arms of Sleep

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=td3bX6RF0lI

Starting in G minor, two chord progression, chords go from Gminor to Fmajor and down to Eb major, which makes sense, but now Eb major is the tonic! Happens for the first time at :45. You get that 'relief' feeling of going from minor to major but it pops even more than if it had been Bb major.

​

The Cranberries - Dreams

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yam5uK6e-bQ

OK, maybe this one's not as subtle, but that instrumental bridge at 1:33, a minor third up. No modulation here, maybe doesn't totally line up with the rest of my examples, but I feel like you'd never hear something like this in a radio song nowadays and I just love it.

​

The Police - Message in a Bottle

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MbXWrmQW-OE

This is a perfect example of what I'm talking about. Verse is in E major, chord progression ends on F#minor, the ii of E major, and we haven't hit an E (tonic) chord yet, but instead of going there for the chorus ( first one at :33), all of a sudden we're in A major. This really is exactly what I love in pop writing, something you don't even register as a key change but makes the song that much more exciting. This is the "subtle manipulation" I'm talking about.

​

Anyway, would love to hear other examples you guys have. And I'm especially interested to hear any newer pop songs that do this, I can't think of any.

Posted Apr 3, 2019, 11:47 AM UTC · edited

7036
eltrotter•

The Zephyr Song by Red Hot Chill Peppers modulates from Am up to Dmaj as it goes from the verse into the chorus, effectively pushing the main 'centre' of the song up by a whole tone. It has the effect of really brightening up the track, and it also means that the chorus ends on the Amaj before switching to Am into the verse, which is a great way to change the mood of the track in quite a stark way.

18
RadioUnfriendly•

I change the key from C to D. You see to me it's just a minor thing, yo.

9
eltrotter•

You know everything!

1
RadioUnfriendly•

0_o

It's, "He knows everything."

0
SoundShark88•

The verses of Africa by Toto are in B major, subtly modulating to A major for the chorus. Rosanna does a similar thing between G and F

14
VreyIsGrey•

Whaaat? I didn't even notice!

2
SoundShark88•

Toto has some really interesting chord progressions in general.

2
fatcage•

Black by Pearl Jam has some really cool things going on. Verse is just E maj and A maj. The chorus changes keys and comes in with the saddest C major of all time.

13
Drummer4696•

It dabbles in E minor quite a bit too. That G sharp he sings in the chorus is almost immediately followed by a G natural in the verse.

5
fatcage•

I didn't really get how or why that song was so powerful until I started learning it on guitar and piano. There are so many little subtle "cool" things that don't feel like a stretch or a gimmick. I love it. Top 5 songs of all time for me.

​

Also, Happy Cakeday!

4
Drummer4696•

Thanks! I didn’t even realize it was my cakeday until you said something! And yeah, that song is criminally underrated. That video of them performing it live at Pinkpop ‘92 will never fail to give me chills.

5
Indosay•

Pearl Jam's always been really smart with key changes. They do a lot of them, actually haha. They're a much smarter band musically than a lot of people give them credit for. They're known for their anger or loudness or rock-ness or whatever, but they're kinda weird as fuck musically a lot of the time. And really smart musicians, especially Stone IMO. Dude writes some crazy weird songs.

5
Jongtr•

Two of my favourites:

Double, 'Captain of Her Heart': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v9Ohve4zukg - listen out at 1:19, and the return at 1:59. Obviously lots of mode mixture (chord borrowing) going on too in each section, but the key switches are both subtle and surprising. (Details provided on request. :-))

Poco: 'Rose of Cimarron': https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QiDNlCyHp0I 0:49 - Blatant but effective, and eventually returning (via traditional preparation) at 1:29.

The Beatles had lots of examples, of course:

Penny Lane: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z7syIxQCquo Back and forth from B major to A major - but is the A really V of D major? The G naturals in the horn line make D sound like the key, and then the return to B major - "meanwhile back" ;-) - is (of course) the parallel major of the relative minor. The B major section even changes to B minor after just 3 bars - so the whole thing is arguably a traditional "minor verse / relative major chorus" arrangement, just cleverly disguised (by deceptive opening chords in each case). The other clever thing: when they repeat the chorus at the end, it's up a whole step up - because they use the same cadence they used before to return to the (B) verse. Neat! (Of course, when I say "clever", I don't mean theoretically erudite; I mean intuitive.)

Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=naoknj1ebqI Psychedelia meant that all kinds of "weird" key changes were highly valued. In this case, the A major of the first section is strongly coloured with borrowed chords, lines ending on F (or Dm/F) each time via a descending bass. In fact, there are no G#s anywhere, so this is A mixolydian at most, and really just some mixed mode chords on A, keeping the whole tonality appropriately ambiguous and shifting. Eventually that downward direction is resolved by the second section (a long pre-chorus) going up a semitone to Bb major. So a "darkening" effect (borrowings from A minor) is turned around into a "brightening" effect (key hoisted up a semitone). And they don't do it by anything as obvious as sticking a 7th on the final F chord. F#m gives way to Dm (root position), and then a crunchy Dm6/C opens out into the "clean" Bb major. Even then, the Bb is not a clear tonic. It moves to C (so is that V/V, or just V of the actual F key?); then it goes to G major and D to land in a chorus in G major, with a cheesy simple old I-IV-V. The final D is held, making a smooth enough transition back to A. The coda contains yet another trick. They repeat the chorus, but only after leading the final D to A major - as if returning to the verse, to make the G less predictable; or to suggest the chorus is IV-bVII-I in D mixolydian? (The Beatles had no theoretical knowledge of modes, of course, and little enough of keys. Only the vast amount of popular music in their heads, and an instinct for experiment.)

​

11
BooBooJebus•

GOD ONLY KNOWS

9
jord_board•

This. Incredibly natural melody considering the amount of modulations in a short time.

2
NumberOneInHeavenOP•

My absolute #1 favorite song of all time

2
chunter16multi-instrumentalist micromusician•

If you think of the keys of different sections as if they are chords, they make their own kind of macro progression.

8
BooBooJebus•

Can you expound on this

1
chunter16multi-instrumentalist micromusician•

The OP explains that in The Corrs' song, you can think of the verses as B (I) and the choruses as E (IV.)

Lovefool is A minor and then A major, so it's not the best example...

In the Smashing Pumpkins and the Police songs, that's i and VI

In the Cranberries song that's I and bIII

Edit:

Peter Frampton's Do You Feel Like I Do has verses in A (I) and choruses in D (IV.)

1
kisielk•

Message in a Bottle is great because Andy Summers plays 9ths throughout the verse, without 3rds (basically just two stacked 5ths), to avoid implying too strong of a minor or major tonality to the chords. It makes the change to the chorus feel very satisfying.

7
SoundShark88•

Every Breath you take as well

1
kisielk•

Definitely, tonal ambiguity is a big part of his signature sound.

1
SoundShark88•

From a melodic/harmonic perspective, not taking into account vocals, lyrics, production,etc., Every Little Thing She Does Is Magic is one of the greatest songs ever IMO, up with God Only Knows and Hey Jude

1
ievenlifted•

Lovefool is such a good song

6
oggyb•

I share the same obsession. I also love "key changes" that aren't key changes and strive to write them whenever possible.

There are lots of great examples from people already but I thought you might like the drop into final chorus of this thing I made. No self promo just mentioning that all the choruses are in E but the final chorus sounds like it modulated higher. https://youtu.be/k_xrodnwxS4

3
dantehidemark•

The last chorus of How Will I Know by Whitney Houston is a minor third LOWER than the rest of the song. Brilliant!

3
NumberOneInHeavenOP•

Whoa, never really noticed that. I’ve always wondered if you could modulate down without losing impact. I guess you can!

2
destructor_rph•

Not subtle, but Love Story by Taylor Swift has a pretty great key change

3
BooBooJebus•

Isn't it a whole step up at the last chorus? I always preferred the half step up move.

3
SoundShark88•

Yes, whole step. Its good because it fits the lyrical story perfectly. The guy proposes, cue triumphant key change, the girl says yes

2
SoundShark88•

I love step and a half personally. Living on a prayer, Summer of 69, etc.

1
thedude37•

Not pop music, but IMO is qualifies. Most music modulates upward (not always, but as a rule). But "Trilogy" by Emerson, Lake & Palmer modulates down a half step! The opening piano part is in a quasi-B major key, then when it gets fast (5/4 section) it's in B flat where it stays for the rest of the piece.

1
mgbakerco•

Summer Elaine and Drunk Dori by Weezer

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_UiPvIrmAc0

First happens at 0:39

The verse is I V vi iii IV I V in C Major

The chorus is the same progression, but in A Major

1
VreyIsGrey•

Otherside by Red Hot Chili Peppers is in A minor, but changes to E minor in the bridge and you almost can't notice it if you're not paying attention.

1
nrrrrr•

I've always loved Silent Victory by The Living End for this.

Never mind that the verse and chorus are in different keys - the last chorus begins on a key change that's up a whole step, and four measures later it comes back down to the original key (I'd recommend listening to two different choruses to hear the difference - the first prechorus starts at 0:40, and final prechorus starts at 2:29). It's a really neat idea I didn't pick up on at first, and modulating back down makes it a much more powerful resolution for me.

1
Jeux_d_Oh•

Beverley Craven- Promise me
Grease - Hopelessly devoted to you
EW&F - After the love has gone

1
chiggs2121•

Love that the corrs breathless is the first example. I’ve admired the sleight of hand of this key change for years. So unusual because it leads you one way and then takes you another so gracefully. Another couple of great examples:

Leanne Rhimes: can’t fight the moonlight.. bridge to the chorus

Everything Everything: Kemosabe.

Very technical band that playfully toy with common themes/devices in modern pop music. The middle 8th in this song is a great example. The initial key change is a bit jarring.. but the way it leads back into the final chorus is amazing.. not that subtle but it works brilliantly - it’s almost mocking the boombastic key changes of the 80s.

1