[Spoilers] Theory About The OA and Dante's Divine Comedy
I was struck during my first watch of part 2 Ep 5 by the similarities between the part of the house Karim walks through with the dirt floor, where the players who didn't make it live in the ground, and some of the images of Hell from medieval paintings. As I researched them to add to my recap, I discovered that those images are from Dante's Inferno. Since I'd read here that Virgil, who's on Karim's T-shirt, is a guide in the Inferno, I decided that was a connection worth checking out. My mind was blown when I realized how many images and ideas from The OA seem related. it's going to take a long time to get a theory to coalesce properly, maybe until the end of the series, and the Inferno doesn't explain everything. But Dante took from multiple ancient sources, so that's actually appropriate for a theory about Dante.
This is some of what I'm working on so far:
The tree imagery has to do with the 7th Circle of Hell, Ring 2- The Woods of the Suicides- suicides and attempted suicides are turned into gnarled trees which bleed when broken and are fed upon by harpies, birds with the faces of old women. The OA has turned these images, and I suspect all of Dante's images, into something more positive, but suicide and attempted suicide have been a running theme since the first moments of the series. Homer's dream connects an old woman, wood and skin.
Evelyn, the old woman, who's also the Sheriff's wife from P1,is a potential suicide and so is Homer. Both have considered dying while they were living with great pain. Evelyn seems to live on the edge of the Wood of the Suicides, and I think Homer has just come from there in his dream. OA, who's actually attempted suicide, is in a wooden box, potentially actually a tree-human. Dr Rhodes and Evelyn are both Harpies, with their reputation restored from the misogynist views of the male writers of antiquity.
Inside the green puzzle house, OA finds a tree which cradles her and gives her advice, telling her she needs to live like a tree, while, as I said earlier, Karim finds another part of Hell, I think Ring 3 of the 7th Circle, but it could be the 8th Circle.
(I have a feeling that all three rings of the 7th Circle show up in Part 2 somewhere. ETA: Oops, I forgot that Ring 1, Violence Against Others, puts the murderers and tyrants in a river of blood and fire. The name of Nina's thesis about the precog Nazi dreams of the 1920s was called "They Dreamed of Blood Rivers". In the dreams, "the rivers of Berlin were running red with blood." P2Ep2.)
This post by leO-A shows a tree that was struck by one of the shooter's bullet's in P1Ep8, and is bleeding, like the trees in the Wood of the Suicides. OA has just effectively committed suicide by putting herself in the path of the bullet, but, also, how many suicide trees are there? All of them?
The puzzle in the house is a crosscut slice of a tree, making trees the centerpiece of the house's mission, then, when someone finishes the entire house puzzle, the seed inside them grows into a plant. We don't know the true nature of that growth, because Hap corrupted it every time we saw it, other than in Fola. But Dante's Divine Comedy is an allegory for the soul recognizing sin, then turning toward and understanding God, until he's finally fully aligned with God's love.
Fola spoke of the levels one had to go through to finish the game, similar to the levels Dante goes through. After the Inferno, Dante goes through Purgatory and Paradise before reaching God. Before The Inferno/Hell he goes through Limbo. I haven't thought this through yet, but I think Hap's basement could be Limbo, with the stream as the River Acheron. When OA is ascending at the end, I think she's ascending into Paradise/Heaven, which uses space imagery- each level is a celestial body. That would explain the Space and planetary imagery we've seen since the beginning.
That green growth may represent spiritual growth through Dante's levels. Each dimension could be a Circle of Hell or a Celestial Sphere of Heaven. Hap is making a map of them by forcing the spiritual growth to occur outside the body, robbing the individual of their soul. Hap is Lucifer/Satan, obviously. And we already know we're dealing with angels, but this season starts to differentiate them into different types of angels.
I'm doing my 2nd and 3rd rewatches at the same time as I write recaps on my blog, and I'm only up to episode 5. Sorry the post is so long. There are a lot more connections, but I'll stop here. My brain exploded when I started looking at this.
The one nagging motif I'm still trying to explain is all of the glass and mirrors, and the way breaking them equals freedom/escape.
Thoughts?
Posted Apr 6, 2019, 10:15 PM UTC · edited