Change of paradigm in the bee keepers community
I just listened to an interview of a beekeeper mentioning that wild bees are disappearing and that domesticated bees are the only pollinisation insects that can be kept on farms. He’s raising alarm on the bee decline and mentions that bee keepers are the last line of defence right now to help maintain pollinisation. They truly see themselves as the protector of these last bees and are fully aware of the terrible impacts that would occur if all bees disappear. He seemed genuinely distressed that more and more aren’t making it through winter each year. It seems to me that (maybe on a smaller scale) the focus is shifting from honey production to saving/safe keeping of these much needed insects. Would that have an impact on any of you in terms of honey consumption ? What if captivity becomes the only way of protecting our last bees ?
Posted Apr 7, 2019, 3:49 PM UTC · edited
Commercial hives are not the primary pollinators in agriculture, and some modern beekeeping methods can hurt wild populations.
It is a false premise that commercial beekeeping is the only way to help bees. Anytime anyone offers you only 1 or 2 choices
it is usually a kind of
which represents the most extreme narrowing of the Overton Window possible: a reduction to just two (sometimes one) choices. Sometimes this is done unintentionally because a person doesn't know of options beyond their current actions, but in debate it is a controlling tactic often done on purpose, to manipulate you into accepting one of the choices presented, without realizing that you can think up other options or paths to take (sometimes many more of them than just two), on your own.
Now, not all actions are "equally correct" or have equivalent effect in the world (different choices can have drastically beneficial or harmful effects), and I'm not saying that an infinite number of options are equally viable or worth of consideration.
But any time anyone does not acknowledge that multiple options exist in the first place, you should immediately think to yourself of the fact that they are presenting a narrowed selection of what may be possible, and your mind should start looking for other alternatives that could be done.
For example, if people want to help bees, there are many ways to do that (not just "support commercial beekeeping, or don't"):
† It's not terribly important to differentiate which one of these it is, but in this case, supporting or rejecting current commercial beekeeping without modification is a Morton's fork, in which both "choices" could lead to the same outcome of bee population collapse.
Do you have a source that commercial hives aren't the primary pollinators? I started talking to someone about it and they insisted that was incorrect.
Some facts: 87% of fruits and vegetables, but only about 1/3 of all crops might depend on pollination in the first place, so not all depend on pollinators to begin with, but a good number do, and our food supply would be significantly limited without them. Of those pollinators, bees are a major group, but not all are bees, and commercial beekeeping overall hurts (there are many other papers on that topic) native populations in various ways.
But does this matter (for human-centric purposes)? Who cares if native populations survive, what if they don't do anything for us or have any effect on us?
If all you want is one source to give to the person you're talking to, here's one:
However, bee pollination is complex, and making single observations can often lead to misleading conclusions.
If you only measured the first, simple to see, behavior that came to mind, like the number of visits, honey bees will sometimes come out on top for specific crops, by far.
But, there are lots of papers and accumulated evidence on how, even in those cases, wild bee populations can increase the ability of honey bees to pollinate (or produce yields), and therefore are responsible for a greater proportion of pollination than first appears. In sunflowers, for example:
Bee Pollination in Agriculture Ecosystems by James, James, and Pitts-Singer, page 12.
In this particular case, if they double the effectiveness of honey bees, wild bees would responsible for at least half (plus their own pollination) of the total (unless there was a reverse effect coming from honey bees to wild bees as well).
For other crops it varies.
Some, like cherries show more of an effect with wild populations increasing fruit set by 150% (and pumpkins may be able to be completely pollinated by wild populations in some situations), and in other crops, like blueberries with wild populations responsible for only 12% of adjusted pollination, wild populations are less directly responsible (although wild pollinators can increase berry size and fruit yields, which may mean they are indirectly responsible for more of the mass of food that is actually produced in the end).
Anyway, it's a very complex topic, but the simplest measures like "honey bees visit more flowers of X particular crop, and are therefore responsible for most of the pollination" are often used to defend commercial honey bee use, and we can at least say that "this isn't the whole picture".
Thank you so much!
Very interesting. I have indeed seen a lot of "more honey bees visit flowers" but I had always thought this was largely a function of competition. That is, honey bees outcompeting natives because of lack of natural parasites (and to a lesser degree, predators) and being domesticated. Is this the interaction between honey bees and native bees you are referring to, or what specifically is the interaction the study mentions?
Here is the source: https://www.pnas.org/content/103/37/13890
This particular paper focuses on sunflower crops and how wild bee populations increase the effectiveness of honey bee pollination. An explanation of how wild bees interact with honey bees to increase pollination begins in the "Discussion" section:
Here is a source noting in its introduction that the pollination competitive advantage of honey bees due to factors like larger colony size or superior communication through dance language are assumptions, which have not been proven, and competition between the two has not been shown to depress wild populations. (It should however be noted that this should probably only be read as a commentary on behavioral interactions in the wild, as the sources for it come from the 1990's, before the identification of Colony Collapse Disorder, and in more recent years, this may have changed).