Issues I've recently had with Petscop. Maybe new Findings/Content?

Discussion

Here it goes:

​

​

Searching for Hidden Content

The "Searching for hidden content" message has been bugging me for some time. If you remember, the text about censored items told us about items that will be censored in the future. But we still haven't seen the "Written on Chalkboard" censor, have we?

​

So in-universe, this wouldn't make much sense, so would this be a continuity error from the creator? There could be 2 solutions I thought about:

​

  1. We're going to see the censored item in the next video.
  2. Petscop is heavily edited (like we knew), but to the point where we can't make up a right timeline.

​

​

​

There has also been another thing that has been bugging me:

​

I re-checked Petscop 6's "It seems like there's a ghost in the game" scene, and it doesn't add up.

​

At this point I'm wondering if anybody has ever mentioned this, bc it's a detail you can easily miss by being concentrated on other things. As soon as Paul talks about the game interacting with him, and the closest ghost-like thing to him being the interaction with the Tool, his description of events does not add up at all. He states that in the "previous video" it interacted with him, only answered 2 of his questions and it didn't even answer his first." This means that there definetely somewhere exists a video that wasn't uploaded to the public Youtube channel.

​

​

Also already in Petscop 6 Paul talks about the "pre-recorded thing", which is OBVIOUSLY a hint to the demo sections we see 5 episodes later.

​

​

​

Posted Apr 7, 2019, 3:54 PM UTC

3011
orchidshow•

Here's my takeaway:

The proprietors/censors/whomever could very well be talking about footage that was already in their possession - I thought this was probable at one point until Petscop 14 made it fairly clear that Paul recorded it in 2018, which would've been well past the period of when it could've been captured if said proprietors were indeed staggering the release of new episodes -, but one of two scenarios seems likelier now.

  1. They're a party familiar with the game and would be aware of what was to come, so they could detail in advance whatever elements that they'd know would have to be redacted for whatever reason (likely, as many in the community believe, to protect Paul's identity by removing anything that could potentially identify him).
  2. Paul says at the end of Petscop 6 that '[t]he game doesn't seem to really care if you see everything'; there are those of us here who think that the entity now (or at least occasionally) responsible for maintaining the channel is an autonomous function of the game itself. By that logic - and your own vis-à-vis correctly concluding that more videos (in the series' universe, at least) exist than are being made available to the general public -, it's entirely possible that Paul has encountered this part of the game and it simply wasn't presented to us.

Given how the implication of a 'chalkboard' being censored is that this event would occur in the school, I am inclined to think the first point is correct and that we simply haven't ventured far enough for this particular censor to be elicited.

As well, one hallmark of Petscop's narrative has been its implicit yet mysterious relationship with time; this essentially gives the creators carte blanche to work around any element of the story that doesn't gel within a linear narrative. While arguably a cop-out, it's nice to know that the creators have established a set of rules that allows their story to be told with the requisite level of belief suspension for their audience to never feel worried about them writing themselves into any corner that can't be rectified.

11
DrivenDustOP•

Holy shit, I think your first argument is it chief, since that makes lot's of sense.

That's probably why in the "we are censoring text" they revealed that not just Paul is working on it. A person close to Paul having ideas of a previous build of the game would also make sense, since that would explain the rumored conversation Paul had with somebody after Marvin tried running through a wall.

5
donnydoom•

After I read this post and the comment above yours, I realized that that wording is important. They state, "Here are some things we are expecting to censor". Expecting implies that they don't know for sure if they will have to censor it or not.

7
DrivenDustOP•

FBI wants to know your location right the F now

6
orchidshow•

I think whatever entity it is has a one-way relationship with Paul, i.e. Paul may not know exactly with whom he is conferring if said entity is in occasional contact with him and/or advising him on what to do next in the game (a lot of his behaviour in Petscop 11 implies this). Whoever Paul is talking to on the phone is likely not the same entity, but someone who had access to an earlier build of the game in the past.

2
reddit_is_cool0•

Interesting I never really thought of that maybe they decided to cut out the scene entirely.

3
JohnStienBec•

they wouldnt skip the censored chalkboard, because they mentioned that theyd censor it and if they skipped it, they wouldnt have to tell us that they censored it

2
DrivenDustOP•

Yeah that's why my confusion is "if they definetely wouldn't skip it, why does Paul have to search for 'hidden content', even though we haven't seen all of the content then?"

2
KurenaiFalconHi I'm Nyx•

That was one of my issues with the description update, especially since Paul said 'it's like the game doesn't care if you see everything.' If the game doesn't care what the person sees, then how does one hunt for hidden content? Especially when he made separate 'test' files where nothing happened.

Another one of my issues: The game is made 'for Marvin,' but it only shows this sort of hidden stuff on the Paul file. Either Paul has some more knowledge of everything that's happening than we know (even though he seems disoriented and confused a lot of the time) or the person playing is not 'Paul,' hence his confusion relating to the events. Even in the demos, Marvin calls the Newmaker, Pall. This implies that Marvin is aware of Paul and who he is.

Long story short, I have a bit of paranoia that the person playing the game isn't 'Paul.' He could be someone related to the family, yeah, but I feel so paranoid there'll be a trick at the end like it's actually Michael playing or something.

2
DrivenDustOP•

Paul is 100% hiding A LOT. He has figured out so much stuff people are still unsure about and he never explains his thought processes. He gives us glimpses, but we can't really put him into context.

​

As example: He knows/assumes to know who Tool is, but we still don't know.

2
kslqlzzz•

Or the family editing this has just seen what’s to come already and knows they’re going to censor things in the future

1