Wisp's role and issues with her mechanical design
What is her role and how do her abilities support this? I don't see the direction behind her design and what they were trying to achieve with this frame mechanically, nor why she'd be worth using late game.
- Her 1 is a group support ability. The heal over time and speed buff are nice. Static buff points won't see much use in most game modes though. The choice to make them immobile makes it feel out of place in a game like Warframe and the inclusion of a mobility buff seems at odds with her stationary design. Still this is a useful and good 1 ability compared to most frames.
- Her 3 is tied to her 1 ability and provides AoE damage around her buff points. Again this supports static game play and potentially useful for defence or interception missions, although I doubt they will be powerful enough to make her worth choosing over other Warframe here. Honestly this looks very underwhelming and likely useless against high level enemies. If it can stun enemies as they try to take control points this could be great for soloing interception missions, but this is a very niche role.
- Her 2 seems like a versatile escape / CC / gap closer ability that you could imagine having great combos with other abilities. Sadly none of hers do. This looks like a useful power but feels like a wasted opportunity and, again, isn't a reason to use her by itself.
- Her 4 is then a slow moving single target DPS ability. I'm not sure how this fits in with the rest of her kit. Her mobility powers and passive suggest she needs to be mobile to survive and is focused on buffs with some area control, yet now she has narrow damage beam that slows her down. While visually great, I also cannot see this being effective late game either. Most weapons are likely going to outperform its damage considerably (heat damage will have huge issues with armoured opponents) while also allowing the player to stay mobile. I'm not sure when or why you'd use this skill but it seems at odd with her kit.
I feel DE need to decide on a role for Wisp and then consider how her abilities support this to make a viable Warframe with a cohesive kit. Currently her design seems to lack direction and presents her as a jack of all trades, master of none that has plagued numerous other warframes in the past.
Posted Apr 8, 2019, 8:03 PM UTC
We have too many posts about this already. I disagree with all of them. Players are being way to hard on her kit. I think it will need a little tweaking to make it a little smoother, but its a very solid and versatile kit. I prefer the play style of mobility and support, so she's right up my ally. At this point, nobody really knows how well her DPS is gonna be so why are players saying her DPS is gonna suck? All we got to see was a demo of her kit, A DEMO.
Seriously. Her kit looks fine. My only real complaint is her 2's move speed being too show.
I LOVE the idea of her 1 assuming it scales with strength. It's like a duration based renewal, meaning she can still have energy Regen and heal herself and her party. I imagine the may even pair well with quick thinking and rage. I do kind of wish they looked a little different.
Her 2 seems useful, granted I'd prefer if it went zephyr speed and just stopped at a wall. I'm curious if the blind triggers finishers. Maybe slower will be better for the blind though.
Her 3 seems like it will be really good for defense, excavation, interception, and clearing some breathing room if you start getting overrun or the enemies swarm the pods
Her 4 seems pretty straight forward, it's a mashup of razorwing and regulators and will probably be good for exterminate.
I was worried about her until I saw her kit and now I'm really looking forward to her.
How is it solid? As far as I can see, her support abilities are currently very lacklustre compared to other Warframes. Her 4 deals heat damage which is going to struggle against armour and, even if it did kill enemies quickly, it is a single target damage ability that impedes movement. Any Warframe with a strong weapon will likely clear enemies more quickly. Let's even assume her 3 could instantly kill enemies, she'd still only be good in game modes requiring you to stay stationary and her gameplay would consist of spamming 3.
Indeed it was a demo and players are providing feedback to influence any future changes. This is feedback.
Firstly I want to apologize for my horrible format cause I don't know to use reddit very well. Her 1 is great has great support/mobility. I really like the whole reservoir idea to stack these different abilities. Yea its stationary but I'm sure you can quickly drop it right in front of your path as you're running through a tileset. Her 2 is some more nice mobility, but it is pretty situational. Her 3 could potentionially wreck if it can cover a large range and have nice dps, IIRC it has some nice CC too, but again very stationary. Her 4 looks like it can potentionally do massive dps and drop enemies like flies. It is slow moving but if you're in a spot where its crowded and you use her 4 it could delete enemies as they hit your cross hairs. Heres what my hopes are for her 4 : Imagine Ashes ult, but skipping marking the targets and then skipping the bladestorm animations. Or like mesa but without having to hold down the mouse button. Just press 4 and mouse over and melt enemies. But of course a lot of her kit is situational, but really you can say that about any warframe.
I like her 1, it's easily one of the best in the game. I'm sure it will be useable but it also seemed like a wasted opportunity if you're just going to drop it and forget it. A simple self buff would achieve the same thing. I would rather it was more mobile to fit in the rest of the game but if they want to build a stationary frame that's great for defence, interception missions etc. that's fine too, I just wish her other powers supported that. Having a mobile frame with oddly static buffing mechanics just seems awkward and not well thought out.
I also like her 2, I just think there are bunch of interesting and fun combos they could have done with it. Again, a wasted opportunity imo and at odds with the design of her 1.
Her 3 could be good but it would be the first of its kind to have relevant damage at the higher levels and spamming 3 for damage doesn't sound particular fun imo. If she had a way of grouping enemies to combo with it it might be more fun and interactive but her synergy ends there.
Most weapons drop enemies like flies. I'm not saying it'll be bad damage - although I have concerns when it comes to armoured enemies - just that it won't be better than a mobile warfare with a good weapon so why sit through the casting animation and use it? Similarly, if she had a way of grouping enemies to make use of the potentially higher damage I could see it paying off. At the moment I just see it being too much hassle to use while you run and gun with little upside compared to a normal weapon.
She does lack synergy. Only her 1 and 3 have synergy. But again we can say this about a lot of frames. Synergy doesnt make or break a warframe. I also dont remember her 4 having a long cast time, I guess I'll have to go back and watch that. i see a lot of concern about wisp handling high level enemies, but how high are we talking? I seen players complain about hildryn's dps when I'm thinking its great. Only for me to find out later that these players are talking about level 120+ heavy gunners or doing 2+ hour survivals. Of course theres gonna be struggle at these levels. I myself don't really get into those high of levels. Sortie 3 is about as high as i go. Occasionally I'll do the first rotation of C in arbitration. But these high level enemies make up like 5% of the content of warframe has to offer. Why do players keep putting warframes in that spot to measure their abilities?
Nothing concrete but Pablo mentioned on his twitter that Wisp's 4 ramps up the damage as you continue to hit the same enemy. Without footage, I have no idea how effective that is but at least there's cause for hope.
That should help with scaling, although without the amour ignore of radiation/corrosive damage types or corrosive procs to reduce armour, I still think it's going to struggle. The damage increase would need to be very high and, even then, I doubt it could outperform a well modded weapon in most situations.
My concern is not that it won't be effective, it's that it won't be effective enough to warrant using over a weapon and therefore won't see use.
You have a valid opinion. When I think about it, ults that do direct damage are actually kind of rare, and probably for good reason. Sure, you have the exalted weapons but those scale well because they're moddable, which I'm not sure is the case for Wisp's Sol.
Otherwise, most of the Ults in the game provide some sort of CC. The frame with a 4 most similar to hers currently is Revenant with Danse Macabre which kind of falls to the wayside after a certain point because yes, it does damage, and it may even give you some overshields if you hit your thralls but that's about it. It doesn't heal you, it doesn't give you damage reduction, it doesn't support your other abilities or your team in any way. It just provides damage, and you can already consistently produce that with weapons.