I've had five interviews now, but I was not offered any of the positions. What number of interviews is a normal number, and when should I worry?

I've made it to the final round of interviews for several positions now, none of them particularly advanced or technical, and yet I've been turned down by each and every one of them. Is this normal? Is it normal to, first of all, only get a handful of interviews out of almost 100 applications, and, second of all, to get zero job offers out of those interviews? I honestly don't understand what I'm doing wrong. I have zero work experience, but I have a strong academic background, solid professional (academic) references, and I communicate well, both in writing and in person, which means I interview well, too. Yet I've gotten nothing.

Is this typical? Is it normal to be rejected from so many jobs that are, or should essentially be, entry-level? How can someone with a relevant degree not be qualified for an entry-level position? Sorry to vent, I just wish I knew what I was doing wrong. I'm very smart, very capable, if I were just given the chance to, you know, actually do the work. I feel like my resume and cover letter convey my capabilities well, so I really don't know what else it is that they don't like about me.

Posted Apr 9, 2019, 5:15 PM UTC

431
chs9•

I personally got 2 interviews out of 60+ apps out of school, so getting 5 it off 100 isn't bad.

11
GeolosopherOP•

Well, that's good to know, I guess. At least my numbers aren't that out-of-whack. They're still depressing numbers, but at least they're roughly as depressing as most other people's...

2
Atomicbob11Environmental Geology•

Yeah... Maybe depressing numbers, but that's the nature of the entry-level market. Many industries are even worse.

5
standingpretty•

Where are you located?

2
GeolosopherOP•

Sorry, I haven't checked this account in a few days. I'm in the southeastern United States, so I'll almost certainly have to move to find something.

1
standingpretty•

Ah I see, I know that could make all the difference.

1
PhilDick3•

It's really hard to say.

I would make a habit of asking for feedback after they let you know you didn't get the job. Seeking it directly from the interviewer (who you hopefully got contact info from) as soon as you know you didn't get the job is ideal. Frame it as "I want to understand if there are any shortcomings or concerns I can address in the future". Don't frame it as you want another shot at the job.

You can decide if it's worth reaching out to these past 5 interviews.

Often we have blindspots, especially when we're starting out.

7
GeolosopherOP•

I had been told not to question interviewers about their decision-making processes, but that was from someone quite a bit older and in an entirely different professional field (I doubt he even knows the difference between geology and geography), so if that's something that's not frowned-upon currently, then I'll definitely follow up with the most recent one. It's not their job to help me out, but all the people I've interviewed with seemed nice and would probably give me some tips for free.

3
Atomicbob11Environmental Geology•

I think such opinions vary widely. Some care, some don't.

I think a better alternative might be too see if you know anyone who works in HR or in the industry and ask them to interview you as if it were for a real job. While people hate doing this sort of stuff, it can sometimes help one discover something that might be hurting them. Do you have any close industry relationships? Or maybe your parents or friends know someone in their company that would be willing to help?

There's always a chance, of course, that you just didn't end up being the best candidate post-interview, despite being a good candidate. Sometimes this is just out of your control.

6
GeolosopherOP•

Unfortunately, I don't have any industry contacts (I have only three professional contacts, but all of them are academic), and my parents have been retired for many years now.

I worry about simply not being good enough for any job... That's something that keeps me up at night. What if I'm never the best candidate for a position? Where do people like that fit in? Where can the second-best go to find work? We have to pay bills, too!

1
Atomicbob11Environmental Geology•

Everyone worries about not being good enough. Then they enter the work force and often realize that there are likely people you work with who are much worse.

As entry level, it's expected you'll make mistakes and not know a ton. You're simply expected to do your best and learn.

Edit. Remember, often that first job is the hardest. Just keep applying as much as possible!

3
eta_carinae_311Environmental PM/ The AMA Lady•

Ask. The worst that happens is they say no, or don't reply. You won't burn bridges asking for constructive criticism.

6
manawoka•

I have zero work experience

Out of curiosity, do you mean you have zero work experience in geology or do you mean you've never had any job ever?

4
GeolosopherOP•

I have zero work experience in geology, but I've also only had two years of "real" work experience on top of that. It was laboratory work, so maybe tangentially relevant, but beyond that I've only ever had odd jobs. I've spent the overwhelming majority of my life, including my adult life, in school.

3
manawoka•

That might be a big part of it. I'm a student too but was talking about internships to an alumni who deals with hiring a few weeks ago. They mentioned that while a lack of prior internships isn't a total deal breaker for an entry-level candidate at their company, they want to see evidence that you were keeping busy and doing interesting stuff, not just going to school and nothing else. For me I haven't been able to do an internship because I spend my summers in the field due to the nature of my thesis, but I do paid TA work along with unpaid research assistant work, helping manage a geoscience nonprofit, volunteer work for my state geological survey, etc. I'm also active in local geological associations and take advantage of odd-job resume-builder opportunities. As an undergrad I did geology research assistant work full time in the summer and part time during school. Before that I did the same amount of work but in more typical young person "whatever job you can find" positions. The alumni I talked to said that sometimes they get resumes of entry-level people who have virtually no marketable jobs/experiences besides a degree (which everybody has), and that those were much more likely to be thrown out.

1
GeolosopherOP•

Well that sucks, because I was a full-time caregiver to my two young children while getting my degrees, so I sure as shit didn't do anything else beside school and parenting. I simply don't understand this mindset. I'm smart. I put out strong research. I did exceptional field work. I made a fantastic map. I got good grades. I did everything right, all while raising full time two new human beings. But that's not good enough anymore? It's maddening. Nothing is ever good enough. I'm never good enough. That's what it feels like at the end of the day every day. And, boy, does it get tiring.

4
manawoka•

┐(´-`)┌ I'm just telling you what the dude told me.

2
mel_cachePetroleum geologist way too long•

One thing I learned while recruiting is that if the experience level and interests of several candidates are similar (as they likely would be for entry level) then you look at other factors to fit a particular job. Personality and how an individual will fit into a specific work team is key, and there's not much you can do to change that. For that matter, you really don't want to work somewhere where your personalities don't mesh--it's miserable.

But the real kicker is job fit, which has little to do with personality. For any specific job, there are peculiarities-- experience with a particular software (sometimes vintage) or with hobbies or volunteerism that is related in some way to the job. For instance, for a field position, an ability to work on mechanicals or wild lands hunting, geocaching, or orienteering could come in handy. If you rebuilt a vintage car in high school, even, it demonstrates you are adept at fixing things.

There are all kinds of things that go into the decision-making process that the candidate is not generally aware of, and most of them come from one person having a different (note I didn't say better, just different) set of experiences than another.

What that means is that you not getting those jobs does not mean you aren't good enough, it just means you haven't found the company for which you are the right fit yet. Hang in there. And don't be afraid to ask the interviewer for feedback.

4

I only received two calls after sending out at least 50+ applications, and only one of those made an offer.

2
GeolosopherOP•

Concerning the one that didn't make an offer, why do you think that was? What was it about you or that position that didn't result in an offer? Was there something you learned from the first interview that helped you ace the second one? Or was the process roughly the same for both, and one was just "better luck" (sorry, I know it's hard work, not luck, that gets the position, but I'm not sure how to phrase it better)?

1

For the one that yielded no offer, it was because I didn’t graduate for another two months and they needed someone to immediately start working.

1
troyunrauGeophysics | R&D•

I don't have current estimates. I entered the labour market in 2011 during peak suckage. But I had a bunch of geoscience things on my resumes from summers prior to the 2008 crash. So it wasn't a zero experience situation. Also, I'm a geophysicist, so there are fewer people competing for positions.

With this in mind, in summer 2011, I sent out 24 resumes (all unsolicited) to contacts I had curated, many of them cold calls. I landed five interviews and two offers. I then played the offers against each other to boost my initial salary offer.

2
GeolosopherOP•

When sending out unsolicited resumes, how do you "market" yourself to them without having a specific position in mind? Those numbers are impressive, and that method, at least in your case, seems to have a much, much higher feedback rate, so it sounds infinitely preferable to drudging through Indeed all day... I'm just not sure how to do it. I don't have any contacts, so it would be me randomly e-mailing companies based on whatever information I could find on their websites. But I'm definitely open to more suggestions about how to do this.

3
troyunrauGeophysics | R&D•

What I did was curate a list of geophysical companies using sources like PDAC, infomine, and professional registration organizations. If you're professionally registered as a geophysicist, you probably have an online footprint of sorts.

Then I punched their names into Google scholar. This gives me information on what they do, what their background is, etc. This greatly helps with the cold call.

Then my cold call email was very informal. Let me see if I can find and example to copy paste from one of them to give you an idea - the experience I talked about was cherry picked to be relevant to what I researched about them and their company:

Hi Firstname,

Just poking around trying to find a decent geophysics position. Stumbled across your website and figured I'd drop a note to see if you're looking for people. If you aren't hiring, please feel free to pass my details along if you know anyone who is.

To introduce myself a little: I am an exploration geophysicist with a strong background in geology and experience principally in metals.

I received my B.Sc. (Hons) Geophysics from the University in 2009. While still in undergrad, I worked for Company out of Place, Canada doing mostly EM and potential field work for nickel deposits. My undergraduate thesis was on the use of satellite synthetic aperture radar for mapping geological contacts in the arctic.

Since 2009, I’ve been studying part time – I've also been working part time for Company doing field operations at copper porphyry deposits in Chile. While I really enjoy the work at Company, the deployments are too few and far between, so I'm looking for a hat with a new logo on it which can provide full time experience. In the meantime, my M.Sc. thesis is nearly completed. Data collection and analysis is complete, and what remains is to publish the results. I anticipate that writing these papers while working full time will not be a problem.

I am looking for a position that combines field work, geology and geophysics, data processing, multiple techniques, and the opportunity to learn new things. Additionally, I am highly interested in obtaining my professional designation in a respectable jurisdiction. I meet most global education requirements and have two to three years of applicable work experience that will be useful when filing the paperwork. My current professional goal is to gain the remaining experience I require to get this certification. I am willing to move to any location as needed.

Please contact me if you have any questions - I'd be happy to answer them.

Thanks for your time.

The job I ended up taking was because one of these people wasn't hiring, but knew a colleague at another company that was.

2
GeolosopherOP•

This is very helpful, thank you.

1
HWY15•

Most entry level environmental jobs are basically all fieldwork. Are you sure you are giving off the correct impressions in that you will be the best candidate for those positions?

You keep emphasizing your degree. I don’t blame you at all, but you should probably understand that your degree will have very very little to do with what you will be doing at those entry level environmental jobs.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
kittykatinabag•

Five interviews sounds pretty good to me. I'm a recent grad (Bachelors in 2018) and before I got my current position I applied to just shy of 200 positions, only got maybe 5 interviews. Two of those interviews went on to round two and I just got one job offer for what is now my current position. Took me 9 months of serious applying (for example searching every day, applying every couple of days), and I'm not even counting the applications I did before graduation during my last semester.

Not all of my jobs were geology related (environmental science degree here, I split my applications between geology and more ecology related positions), and I had about 6 months experience in a geology lab and about 2 years worth of other experience along the lines of being an RA and leading clubs during university. I'm 100% sure the only way I got my current job was that an alumni from my university referred me for the job when I applied. So maybe follow that route if you still have emails for advisors and professors? I'm personally convinced its the one of the only ways to get a job now a days, either be such an incredible candidate or be nepotismed in.

2
groundbreakingeo•

If it's any help- the resume/interviewing is somewhat bullshit. Basically, I got my first job in mineral exploration (10 years ago!) during a boom time where they'd hire anyone with a pulse- that's how qualified I was! Since then, literally EVERY job I've gotten has been through connections. I don't really bother throwing out resumes anymore, maybe one here or there if something looks interesting. Generally, I wait for my phone to ring.

​

My point is- don't get discouraged, if you're good and good to work with- the hardest part is landing the first gig. It gets easier, generally, to find a job.

1