BioE grad program vibe/student atmosphere?

Hi Berkeleyers,

I'm choosing between Berkeley/UCSF and another graduate program for a PhD in Bioengineering.

Berkeley has really advertised how much of a student emphasis their program has and how good of people they have. To be honest, during the visit weekend, I felt the opposite. People seemed uptight and arrogant/superior moreso than friendly, lots of grad students acted like they were better than the prospectives for no reason, the vibe felt cliquish, and it came across as if the people heavily involved with BEAST have a giant stick up their ass.

Can anyone here reflect how the atmosphere of the program actually is and if this perspective is an accurate assessment of the students of the program? I'm having trouble sorting out how much this was due to interactions with 1-2 especially bad students and how much is just the atmosphere of the program.

(1) Are the people actually friendly?

(2) how cliquey and political is BEAST? It kinda felt like it could be a giant headache of self-importance, or actually pretty cool, and I'm having a hard time getting a read. Is 8t a headache that's easy to just ignore?

Thanks! Go Bears!

Posted Apr 12, 2019, 9:14 PM UTC

11
SneakyTrilobite•

I'm not a grad student, but if there's one thing I've learned, it's too follow your gut. You were so discontent with the type of people that you saw on your grad program visit day that it prompted you to go on an online form for the school and ask "This can't be what it's really like, right?!"

I'm not saying people won't give helpful advice here, like how it might be different on a normal, non-visit day, but remember that what other people may consider friendly and normal can seem very clique-y and off to you. Other people's experiences can't change yours, so just remember not to discount your own real-life experience based on how other people feel. If you didn't like the people there, then a lot of themt are probably gonna be in your program. Just saying. I hope you can make a good evaluation of this, and make the right choice for you.

***ALSO! I just wanted to add that the environment for grad school is very important, at least from what I have heard. You don't want to be starting at a place where you know that going in, you're going to have to smash your way through some barriers just to be comfortable. You want to feel that way from the start. If it feels like a bad environment now, remember that you're about to immerse yourself into it.

2