New York Times article about 5th edition
nytimes.com/2019/04/06/opinion/sunday/dungeon...Posted Apr 13, 2019, 1:54 PM UTC
Posted Apr 13, 2019, 1:54 PM UTC
When a member of my group makes a bad choice, I can’t look into his face and shout insults the way I would if we were playing online.
Obviously you're not trying hard enough.
Yeah, my response was
"Not with THAT attitude"
Is it even real d&d if at least one person isn't constantly complaining, groaning face-palming, or shouting "What? NO!"
^^^^^/s
I’m sorry but sometimes our warlock player is just...rlly dumb
Don't you mean...
R'lyeh dumb?
Thx for that. An unexpected late night laugh :)
Only if his patron is a Great Old One.
I ran a one-shot for my group to give the DM a break after being 100% fantastic for months and months of leading us. And it was so fun to see him as a player. Totally different dynamic and you could tell it was hard for him to be on the other side of the screen.
He kept rolling 1's, so it's not like *I* screwed him, but when you're a monk trying to fight a sea monster you're gonna need to come at me better than that.
If someone makes a bad choice you double down on that choice as a group. There is nothing more D&D than making terrible choices and some how pulling it off or dying a glorious death
Hear that? That's the sound of a thousand Dungeon Masters trying to suppress their frustration with their players over derailing the campaign for the hundredth time.
If it's fun. It's a Win
Absolutely.
I would rather my players make dumb decisions and force me to come up with consequences on the fly than to sit around and listen to them bicker about whether the door on the right or the door on the left is the safer or more rewarding option.
Me, drunk off my ass: "I jump down the hole."
Everyone else: "Aww shit, guys. We can't just let him go alone!"
And that's how we fought a false hydra.
Just look him in the eyes and say the gamer word
That's why you always memorize Project Image before the game.
Smh, is yes and dead?
Using a few maps spread on the table, we chart our course, explaining to Kate and one another what we want to do next. And when Kate leaves us on a cliffhanger, there’s no “Hey, I’ll text you later and maybe we can meet up.” Of course we’ll meet up again.
Same-time-next-week master race, reporting in!
I envy your D&D schedule.
Ikr, we have like one session a month... I wish my dm didn't have a life so we can do this every week :(
(Jk Shane Ily, pls more sessions tho seriously)
Man I recognize your username from somewhere else recently and have no idea where....
anyway hey from a fellow New Yorker/D&D fan!
Haha, maybe either league, NBA or NFL subs? I post in those a lot.
It's only possible with my discord group, my home group is never able to meet everyweek
Huzzah!
I DM games weekly as well, usually 1-3 years in length. Besides normal stuff like xmas, child birth and weddings I keep everything on a weekly schedule.
It keeps excitement fresh and motivation going strong which is important for long haul games like that. It can be stressful as a DM though, the mental tension required to keep trucking along and inventing like that can wear me down. I toss in some Paranoia, Star Wars and so on to mix it up and that tends to help a bit.
My group is every Wednesday evening, occasional bonus sessions on Mondays and Tuesdays
This is sorta what I’ve thought since 5e started to boom, that in an age where we do most of our socializing through a screen, sitting at a table with people seems quaint and new.
Since when and why did 5e boom? I'm actually a new DM/player and I don't really even know why I started looking into D&D myself...
Not sure about the when, but D&D has been booming for a few reasons:
-YouTube and Twitch brought things like Acquisitions Inc to us in a viral manner
-Celebrities who have openly admitted to playing regularly, such as Vin Diesel
-The rise in popularity of Critical Roll
Also, stranger things!
Critical Role, The Adventure Zone, other D&D shows :)
Does Vin Diesel play? When he was on CelebriD&D he didn't seem familiar imho
There’s been rumors of him playing for years, like him teaching Judy Dench while they were making whatever that movie was called where she’s an earth elemental... Riddick. Joe Manganello who has famously been a D&D freak for decades, says he’s never met anyone who’s played with Diesel. It seems like a weird thing to lie about. I think maybe he likes it, but maybe not as much as it’s been rumored.
5e seemed popular out of the gate, so five years ago? And while I think people turning away from screens in the biggest draw, streaming games have helped tremendously, the response to the recent Critical Role Kickstarter is just overwhelming. Whodathunkit? Also, it was a new Edition that wasn’t, as the article above points out, bogged down by rules, and harkened back to earlier editions a lot of folks grew up with and offer a new jumping in point.
And this is why when people group me into people obsessed with social media, I scoff at them because I am with my friends for hours at a time playing dungeons and dragons on the weekends. Seriously why do people keep on doing that? My screen time average is around 2 hours a day which could be lower but is way better than my peer group's 5 hours a day. Most of that screen time is listening to some new music on Youtube anyway. Back to Dungeons and Dragons though. In my opinion it is one of the best things that has happened to me. It got me social and made my mind endlessly creative in addition of finding other things like the Touhou Project. This article couldn't be more right.
I don't think there's any need to scoff at people for having different interests.
I spent a fair amount of time on Facebook, Instagram and Twitter, mainly Twitter. I use Facebook to keep in contact with family, to see pictures of my wee niece and as a chatting tool with my D&D group. Twitter is what I use for engaging in political discussions and articulating a lot of my thoughts and gripes about my life, something which I find quite soothing.
I love D&D, it's my favourite hobby and it plays a big part in my life. I don't like it when people scoff at me for playing D&D, and I think it's unfair that we scoff at others for how they spend their time.
No, not the people who use social media. I was talking about the group who group me into the extremely unhealthy people obsessed with social media. I hate it because it happens a lot. I can understand your confusion though and I do believe that social media can be very good but it can also be very bad in ways too. Sorry if I was unclear or I offended you or something.
No offence taken! I totally get ya, I definitely misinterpreted ya :'(
Okay, good! I just want to make sure I'm not hurting anyone because that isn't what I'm going for.
99% of what I do on Facebook is organize D&D and disseminate documents related to same. It's just a visually more attractive 'venue' than gmail.
Yeah, I get it. Again, I’m not talking about the people who use social media. I’m talking about the people who group me with the truly obsessed people of social media. I’m not trying to offend anyone or attack people who use it. Just saying that I don’t like people who generalize me. Sorry if I offended you or anyone reading this.
That’s actually what Meetup.com is really good for. I’m helping to coordinate the Boston area RPG Meetups, and even the organizing can be fun.
I just recently got into Dungeons and Dragons, and having the ability to spend quality time with a few people in person has never felt better. My party has only had a few sessions due to our busy schedules, but we're going to start regular sessions soon. I've quickly gotten closer to my group members, some of whom I started to not talk to as much. I'm grateful for being introduced to the world of D&D, and I completely share the same feelings with the article.
DnD is more satisfying than social media
well, no shit, sherlock
better than facebook
thats not exactly a high bar now, is it?
The cool kids have always played dnd....
It's clearly a better way to socialize and it's a great way to teach people, especially younger kids and teens, many social skills, problem solving, teamwork and basic math. I'm trying to get my local library involved in a D&D group for youths in the area.
I think that this article describes playing hoard of the dragon queen.
Indeed it does. (Or Rise of Tiamat, maybe.)
I hope that this isn't an exception, but the beggining of something great!
[removed]
I feel like if the New York Times says D&D is for "cool kids," then that's probably proof that it is in fact not cool at all.
The author never actually addressed the premise of her headline. In no part of the article is it mentioned whether or not D&D is being adopted by a so-called 'in-group' of popular individuals. It merely asserts that 5e is being adopted by more players and that WotC is moving a lot of product.
Yeah, definitely could be a case of a headline writer making a bigger claim that the author herself intended.
Yeah, usually editors write the headlines, not the article authors themselves.
Literally all it says about 5e is that it:
The article's actually about how playing D&D is a better way of socializing than Facebook.
They are not wrong there. Even when I'm doing play by post it feels like I am haveing more of a connection, it feels like shutting down social barriers if that makes any sence.
Where can I do play by post?
r/LFG tell them you are looking for a play-by-post group. Usually people do it through Discord.
Thanks, mate!!
You've gotten some good recs, but in case you're more into forums than discord, there are a lot of established forums/sites as well. I use RPG Crossing.
Thanks!!
r/LFG is a good place to look. There's usually a decent amount of PBP there.
thanks :)
There's tons of sites out there. Just start googling around, try just doing a generic web search for fantasy roleplay or adventure roleplay
RPGGeek.com
I run a lot of games there!
I would like to be a part of them. Let me know how I can join one.
Check out RoleGate. Interesting take on play by post.
Sure. Thanks!!
I really want to get my non_nerdy friends into DND just cuz it's another way to hang out with them instead going out for drinks or going out. Just a chill time telling really bad stories
The stories are only bad when no one is telling them.
That's the best 1-sentence summary of 5e I've heard in a while. Usually NYTimes sounds like someone's conservative technophobic grandma in regard to nerd stuff
Well it's written by Annalee Newitz, which is why it's so good at describing nerd stuff.
Hot damn do I miss io9 when it was run by her and Charlie Jane.
Annalee and Charlie Jane were able to bring me to tears with some of they tv shows reviews. I even cried reading reviews of episodes I had seen and didn’t tear during my watch.
Have you listened to Our Opinions Are Correct? It's their podcast about science fiction tropes and content, and it's a great lens on current genre trends.
I couple weeks ago I was on my way to our session and stopped at the gas station. As I fumbled for my wallet my set of dice fell out and the attendant — kind of a stereotypical “wigger” guy of maybe 20 years old — saw. I don’t think I fit his idea of a tabletop gamer (I’m your basic aging hipster sort, and had been listening to Wu Tang Clan when I drove in — the first thing he commented on). He commented “Oh, you going to go dungeon some dragons? I never got the appeal of that.”
I shrugged and said “It’s a good excuse to get together with my buddies every week so we can tell jokes, drink beer, eat junk food, and dream up new ways to kill enemies in elaborate ways. Think of it as nerd poker.”
He stopped for a second and was like “So it’s just a bunch of dudes sitting around drinking, telling dirty jokes and thinking of creative ways to slay monsters and shit? ... Ok, yeah, that sounds pretty rad, not gonna lie.”
“Nerd poker” is one of the best descriptions of D&D I’ve ever heard.
Nerd poker is Magic: The Gathering tho
You lose way more money playing magic. And everyone loses
I thought that was Yo-Gi-Oh!
Brian Posehn (the comedian) had a DnD podcast called Nerd Poker for a bit, off and on. It was actually pretty ridiculous and amazing.
That’s awesome!
You're right. I could have done a better job of choosing a more precise headline to accompany the link.
While we just had a long discussion about an arcane rule for casting as a bonus action.
96% of my Facebook usage is organizing D&D campaigns.
[deleted]