Ok Reddit, What would you like to see happen with Israel?

My thesis to graduate high school was relating the history of the land of Israel to contemporary Israeli culture. I think that what is happening there now is tragic but what would you all like to happen there.

The expanded settlements are beyond my grasp of understanding but it is very reasonable in my mind for Israel to have a strong defense. Without this, thousands of citizens (mostly Jews) would be killed each year...thus a possible relationship between being anti-Israeli and Antisemitism.

So what would you like to happen in Israel?

Posted Mar 15, 2010, 6:36 PM UTC

164
yiddish_policeman•

Can we please keep the Israel discussions to r/worldnews and r/israel? I get enough of being called a nazi there without it invading askreddit.

9
Bluko•

Nazi!

3
HitlerLogic•

Do you know who else couldn't come up with a rational explanation of where Jews should live?

2
mathquestOP•

Well I wanted opinions from all of Reddit, but I suppose worldnews would have been more appropriate.

3
PersianSean•

I'd like to see this be actually approved by Israel. After that, I'd like to see a similar sized residential development inside of Israel by an Arab development firm, and watch Israel taste a bit of their own medicine....

5
mathquestOP•

I'm having trouble finding any information about that. And can you clarify the "taste...of their own medicine" statement.

1
PersianSean•

Al-Reehan is a residential development in the West Bank by a Qatari development firm, which is going to have around 2,000 single family homes as well as mixed use living. Taste of their own medicine would be Palestinians doing what the Israelis have been since after the Six-Day war: land grabs via residential developments in Israel.

4
Yserbius•

But they are! Look at the northern most point of the West Bank. Draw a line north of there for about 10 miles. Virtually every city and town under that line is exclusively Arab.

1
PersianSean•

The total number of Israeli settlers in the West Bank is 484,862. Many of these "cities" you describe were actually annexed by Israel (e.g., Nazareth which was annexed in Operation Dekel in the 1948 War), and thus were not settlements. Oh and, you forgot the part about the Israel Land Administration, administering 93% of the land in Israel (including the land owned by the Jewish National Fund), which refuses to lease land to non-Jewish foreign nationals, which includes Palestinian residents of Jerusalem who have identity cards but are not citizens of Israel.

2
nunobo•

I would like for the Israeli's and Palestinians to be able to coexist on the same land peacefully. I would like the Palestinians to be able live without fear of being confined in poverty and despair, and I would like the Israelis to be able to live without the fear of being targeted by terrorists and suicide bombers.

4
ZoidbergMD•

Since the fence went up the suicide bombings have stopped.

-1
nunobo•

To be honest, I don't really follow Israeli news, but I do remember reading about the weapons being smuggled into Gaza and the West Bank. So the suicide bombings may have stopped, but I bet the fear is still there. Part of living peacefully together is the elimination of the fear of each other. Ideally Israelis and Palestinians would coexist like the Czechs and the Slovaks did when they were part of Czechoslovakia.

6

Czechs and Slovaks are happy people. The Middle East seems to be a bit more tense

4
nunobo•

Yes, I agree. But the OP of this thread was asking for our ideal scenario.

1
steeple•

don't build a house at the bottom of the sea and then complain about getting wet

4
powertrader•

Think of it this way:

There are a lot of people proclaiming that a lot of the land in the US belongs to the Native Americans who were forcefully removed by "colonizers." Imagine a scenario that, due to some treaties, colonizers are to give back some of the land to Native Americans.

Now imagine that piece of land as Manhattan or some other largely developed land.

3
mathquestOP•

Up until a hundred years ago, the area was largely ignored by pretty much all groups of people. The reason Israel is thriving is because of the wealth and ingenuity that the emigrating Jews brought with them.

Before they were a country, there were riots because the Jews were better situated then their neighboring Palestinians. The establishment of such a strong government has done a lot to stabilized the area

4
powertrader•

Again, using the scenario I presented, what can you actually do? You can't sudden repatriate the land with native americans after it's been developed.

The argument that the area was largely ignored is quite simply, ignorance. There are so many factors as to why the land wasn't developed, but you can't claim it's ignore. And that has no bearing on who is the rightful owner either.

Again, go back to my scenario to draw parallels to what Israel represents to many. There is no win-win situation. The only real solution is to simply stop further "colonization" and hope for the best.

3
mathquestOP•

I believe the land was in drought for many years before and Jerusalem was primarily inhabited by Jews since the 1800's.

I can't seem to find anything to the contrary and was under the impression that little happened in the land for centuries before WWI (other than Jewish emigration) so could you give some parallels to the scenario you presented to Israel's establishment.

-2
powertrader•

Do i actually have to s-p-e-l-l it out for you?

The land of "Manhattan" had no real "development" and were in the hands of savages who still hunted, ate with their hands, and barely wore clothing. Thankfully, Manhattan was taken over by intelligent and civilized people able to develop the land and build an economy from scratch.

The land of "Africa" had no real "development" and were in the hands of savages who still hunted, ate with their hands and barely wore clothing.

Now tell me, is that justification for colonization?

3
Drooperdoo•

You really believe that? "The ingenuity of the Jews" made Israel "thriving" and "wealthy"?

So it wasn't hundreds of billions in foreign aid?

Excellent! Seeing as how Israel is so "wealthy" and so "ingenious," let's see about having them renounce welfare. You can't accept handouts from the international community on one hand, and then brag about how "wealthy" you are on the other—can you?

Let's see how far their "ingenuity" goes toward keeping them afloat without welfare.

2
Yserbius•

So foreign aid made drip irrigation and the Uzi? The aid goes entirely to the purchase of American weapons and it makes up about 5% of Israels total GDP.

3
mathquestOP•

I said that the wealth of the emigrants and their ingenuity made Israel thrive.

For instance, Israeli scientists have made over 200 improvements in the F-15 alone

source

"Israelis have invented much of the technology used today such as instant messaging"...etc

source

You really can't say that Israeli's don't have ingenuity and comparatively, the country is thriving with the median household income being just below Australia's.

edit for formating

1
Drooperdoo•

You said that Israel's median income is just below Australia's. Not to be combative or anything (because I think, on average, Israelis rock). But—

Well—

It's kind of disingenuous for you to compare Israel's "median income" with Australia's when Israel gets billions in aid every year from the U.S., along with additional billions from Germany and the E.U. (as a form of Holocaust reparations). Australia doesn't get a nickel of hand-out money from the international community.

So it seems a little dishonest to compare the two nations: One stands on its own two feet and the other is, let's face it, a welfare queen. Remove the handouts and Israel's economy would collapse. It's already teetering on the brink with many countries in Europe refusing their products as a protest to their behavior.

P.S.--And, yes, I agree that Israel has made many inventions to beef up fighter-planes. And, yes, they invented the UZI sub-machine gun. If only they'd channel their national ingenuity into non-military enterprises, and started some constructive behavior.

1
Prysorra•

The ingenuity of the Jews

It's a self-important way of saying "educated and wealthy with a culture of unrestrained ambition".

Did I mention that's it's ridiculously self-important? Look at us, so clever!

1
Drooperdoo•

You're not the first one to call the Jews self-important and megalomaniacal. While the average rank-and-file Jew is not typically a self-indulgent egomaniac, Judaism as a culture is one that is deeply chauvinistic. They call themselves "The Chosen People," after all. The Talmud makes it explicitly clear that to kill a Jew is murder, while to snuff out the life of a non-Jew is merely "killing, on par with killing an animal".

Gentiles are not quite fully human—and are to be treated as such.

While orthodox Jews are more apt to be influenced by this unenlightened world-view, it occasionally crops up in more mainstream subsets of Jews and amounts to almost a psychosis in certain individuals. I was watching a Canadian show called "Ghostly Encounters" and a Jewish woman went so far as to call a ghost in her house "antisemitic" because it disrupted the Passover ceremony. Her instinctive reaction was to lodge the charge that the ghost "didn't like Jews". As you watched the program, it developed that previous and subsequent non-Jewish owners gave accounts of the same ghost. "It" caused trouble for them, too. So the ghost (if such things exist at all) wasn't bothering the Jewish family because "they were Jewish". So it came off as perfectly psychotic for the woman to call the entity "antisemitic," against all evidence to the contrary.

Is any other group, any other religion so apt to obsess on their perceived identity like this???

An antisemitic ghost??? Come on!

Her self-obsession was such that one imagines her tripping and falling and calling Gravity an "antisemitic law of physics".

1
[deleted]•

Nations rise, nations fall. No nation has continually existed (without civil war, government overthrow, and shifting borders) since people first had an identity of "us".

Modern Isreal is an artificial construction out of the ashes of WWII. Jews worldwide suffered, but that's no excuse to recreate the distant past at the expense of the current nation(s) the land was carved out of. I don't see anything smoothing out for Isreal in the future, just due to the fact it's rebirth was completely artificial.

2
mathquestOP•

I'd say it wasn't completely artificial. The establishment of a Jewish nation in the Middle East was considered for several centuries before WWII. The earliest I can think of is Napoleon.

When the French troops were in Palestine, and besieging the city of Acre, Napoleon had already prepared a Proclamation (See: Appendix 2) making Palestine an independent Jewish state.

source

2
PersianSean•

How is that less artificial? Just replace one Western imperial power with another.

0
Yserbius•

What I would like to see would be a real and viable Palestinian leadership who is more interested in the welfare of their people than the destruction of their enemies. This would lead to economic stability in the areas and allow Israel tear down the security wall and to focus on other things without having to worry about terrorist attacks.

Once that is established, I would like to see the Palestinians take a vote on whether to secede the West Bank and Gaza as independent country or become part of Israel. If they become an independent country, I would like to see them accept the Israeli-built cities in the West Bank as Palestinian cities and give the residents the opportunity to become citizens, or to leave.

What will probably happen is that the Palestinian leadership will continue to blame Israel for everything and antagonize them. Israel will continue to become sick of making peace treaties that the other side refuses to keep and simply pretend that they don't exist. There may be a slight hiccup if the American money will stop, but at the end of the day, Israel will keep building in the West Bank and Fatah and Hamas will keep praising the murderers of children as heroes.

I would also like to see less ignorance of Israeli and Palestinian history on reddit.

2
PersianSean•

Let's be honest here, Palestinians do not have a choice to become part of Israel. The far-right wing in Israel would not allow this, and i'm sure a majority of Israelis would not be comfortable with a Palestinian majority in their Jewish state. I believe their only choice is to become the crumbling cookie that is now the West Bank, and eventually lose a majority of their land to Israeli settlements.

5
Yserbius•

I was talking in a theoretical sense what would be ideal. I'm not the only one to propose so, I get my ideas from all over and I specifically remember an article by Natan Sharansky about a process that would make Palestinians full citizens of Israel.

They do have a third choice: renounce violence against Israel and submit to a full peace process where they actually agree with something. It would be a compromise and nobody will be happy with it, but it's better than what both sides have now.

3
PersianSean•

Right, but what i'm saying is that would never happen, and theories floated around by a couple of far-left Israeli academics won't make it pass the overwhelming influence of the religious right influence in Israeli politics.

Excuse me if i'm totally ignorant and blind, but hasn't the Palestinian Authority renounced violence? What do they get.... hmm, a disintegrating West Bank and frequent commando raids. You wonder why Palestinians democratically elected Hamas to power in the Gaza Strip. If Israel renounced their borderline terror campaign against the Palestinian people, perhaps there would be less radicalized youth due to a more flourishing Palestinian economy with jobs, and Hamas would have never been elected to power.

2
Yserbius•

Did you just call Natan Sharansky a leftist academic? Wow.

The PA (or whatever is left of it) does some PR stuff about renouncing violence, from time to time. Yet we still see Fatah praising the systematic murders of Israeli citizens. All the raids come in response to terror attacks on a civilian population. Israeli did pull out of Gaza, look at what they got in return. And Hamas won Gaza in a series of scare campaigns and coups. They are as democratically elected as the Queen.

0
Armitage1•

less killing

2
The_Duck1•

Whenever I read articles about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict I just get pissed off that there exist people who are big enough assholes that they think it's right to go kill some other people. Somehow, though, humans are so fucked up that it's unreasonable to expect them to just stop killing each other.

Toward a feasible solution, then: my relatively uninformed sense of things is that Israel is slowing encroaching on land occupied by Palestinians and that they should stop doing than and a Palestinian state should be set up to govern those regions. Wasn't there some setup after World War I where the people of a region would vote to decide what nation they wanted to be a part of? I don't see why we can't do that here.

2
HungLikeJesus•

Wasn't there some setup after World War I where the people of a region would vote to decide what nation they wanted to be a part of? I don't see why we can't do that here.

Ignoring ethical, historical and 'rights'-based considerations completely for a minute, it's because there are more Palestinians than there are Israelis, and the gap is widening. Israel has about 5.6 million Jews, according to wikipedia. It also has 1.5 million Arabs, then there are ~3.3 million Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza (numbers vary), plus half of Jordan's population is Palestinian, so there's another 3 million. Then there's the rest of the Palestinian diaspora spread all around, many of whom would like to return.

Israel is founded on the idea of being a Jewish, democratic state. If you have more non-Jews than you have Jews, the 'Jewishness' of the state (whether we're talking about religion, culture or ethnicity/race) kind of goes out the window. The majority Palestinian population would simply vote to have the entirety of the land, and then we'd be stuck in the exact same situation, with the sides reversed.

This is the problem with a one-state solution (besides the high likelihood of more violence) - neither side is willing for their culture/religion to be subsumed under the other, and they're not willing to go completely secular either. The problems with a two-state solution are generally a) where the border gets drawn, b) how to stop them fighting long enough to do it and c) how to keep them from interfering with/attacking each other afterwards.

0
The_Duck1•

What I was imagining (yet perhaps failing to articulate) was this voting scheme on a very small scale and as part of a two-state solution, where the residents of, say, each square mile voted whether to be part of Israel or Palestine. I'm assuming here that the Jews and Palestinians are fairly segregated and so that this would lead to rational boundaries (is this wrong?). I imagine there are probably problems with that as well but I don't know what they would be and it seems like a fair solution.

2
HungLikeJesus•

You'd have a lot of the same problems the PA in the West Bank has now - your territories probably wouldn't end up contiguous, and anywhere that the other country controlled the roads between bits of your country, you'd be fucked. It'd be like West Berlin, back when the Western Allies had to airlift in food, only even more fragmented. Also, you'd still have a crazy hard time dividing up the religious places (is Israel is going to let the Western Wall go just because the Old City has more Arabs? hell no!), the coastline, and the cities.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
mathquestOP•

What umbilical cord?

It is a most reliable partner in the promotion of Western strategic interests and in the stabilization of the Middle East.

Compared to the $2.0 billion yearly military aid to Israel, the U.S. contributes more than $130 billion(!) every year to the defense of Europe and more than $30 billion to the defense of Japan, Korea, and the Far East. Over 300,000 U.S. troops are stationed with NATO and over 30,000 U.S. troops in the Far East. In contrast, not one single U.S. soldier needs to be stationed and put at risk in Israel.

source

-4
3dimka•

I would like them to stop pretending they are fighting terrorists and admit that they in fact just conquer new territories.

1
[deleted]•

I would like for israel to be given back to the people that were there before they were displaced by a guilty american/european government looking for a place for european jews to go. Give the jewish people Germany. want to punish someone for the most recent atrocities against the jews? punish the germans. Yes, I realize punishing a people generations removed from the nazi party is rediculous, just like displacing thousands upon thousands of people and carving out a country to put millions of war refugees in.

1
Ahmadinejadd•

WIPED OFF THE MAP

0
steeple•

well, you would say that!

0
yottskry•

Some sort of plague... locusts, boils... anything apart from death of the first born. I'd enjoy the irony as suddenly they have to consider the idea that they are not God's chosen people and that perhaps the land is not unquestionably theirs.

0
AussiePete•

Simple. The USA stops propping up Israel. If they can survive on their own, all well and good. If they get wiped out, then that's pretty sad, but it's fair.

0
clone_trooper•

Apply genofagia to palestinians and have a gun under israel to force it to behave

-1
Ozwaldo•

I'd like to see the women of these regions cast off their Burqas, rebel against their conservative upbringing, and just go full on slutty. Like, sluttier than any other people in the world. That'd be pretty awesome. /immaturity

-3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-5
mozlum•

Solomon, actually.

5
ArmageddonAardvark•

Good catch, thanks for the correction.

1
toothlesswhores•

We should send all the niggers there.

-10
DirtPile•

I'll have a Coke.

3
toothlesswhores•

Yeah, right. You'll have grape soda, just like the rest of your kind.

-6
PersianSean•

Keep it classy, Digg.

2
toothlesswhores•

lol Digger rhymes with nigger.

-1