What are your overall thoughts on the UI?

The UI is interesting. I am more of a fan of the additions than the actual UI (such as fusion, trade lists, wish lists, set view, filter by parallels, etc). The following are my thoughts and opinions.

​

Positives:

  1. The UI is very fast (for me at least).
  2. You can get to the actual card packs by set. MUCH easier to navigate this way. Also, no pesky refreshing. The details for the odds of the pack also don't have to be clicked to open a pop up. It's all right there. Love it.

​

Negatives:

  1. I am not entirely a fan of the one button on the bottom that spawns 9 more buttons. I feel like the customary 5 buttons was a winner. There are really some unnecessary buttons in there, such as coming soon, claim and home. Home should always be the bottom middle button in my opinion. The essentials, Collection, Home, News, Store and perhaps Trade, should be at the bottom, with the others navigable elsewhere.
  2. Relating to issue #1, the actual "Home" page is kind of bare. "What's New" is a great addition. However, this is probably where many of the links that are in the pop up buttons box could be placed. It looks like the Home page is reserved for notifications, which is good, but it can be resized to be more efficient.
  3. Too much clicking. This might again relate to Issue #1, but I feel as if there is way too much clicking required in order to navigate to your destination.
  4. I go forward a lot, but can I go back? It seems like when I navigate deep into a section, whether it be the collections (sets) or a trade, or anything else, there is no back button and the device's back button does not work. It forces you to have to click the navigation circle and choose something all over again. This partially goes back to #1.
  5. Where's are the dupes and needs tags? Makes it very hard to trade right now. Seeing, at a glance, how many cards you or your trading partner has is a necessity. Clicking each card individually to see how many they have is going to be very very painful. (I'm sure this one is being updated as we speak though)

​

What about you guys? Thoughts on the UI?

Posted Apr 16, 2019, 4:00 PM UTC

210
marvinm00re•

Apologies if this the wrong place for this, but it bugs me that the cards display so much smaller than on the other apps. Even clicking to enlarge, they’re still a good bit smaller than on SWCT.

6
mzrebekah•

Yes. On my iPhone 7+ they are barely 50% of the screen.

2
marvinm00re•

It really makes it less exciting. Like I’m further away from the cards.

2
tmdblya•

Agreed, the app seems much more responsive, the type and layout are much cleaner than the other apps. Less garish. (But still pretty busy, actually. Too many unnecessary lines/outlines)

I agree with all your negatives. It's very easy to get lost once you click a few screens into the app.

Re: Item 1: I mocked up an alternative navigation that combined having the main section icons ever-present with a tray that lifts up to show the rest. TOPPS_ADMIN said the team was considering it.

This and most of your other negatives are, to my mind, the result of no/poor overarching organization and navigation system. There are no visual indicators about where you are, nor consistent navigation elements across all screens. (See your point about no ability to go "back".) Some suggestions:

  • color code sections so you know at-a-glance were you are. would also brighten up a universally gray app.
  • include prominent section labels at the top of the screens.
  • use the section icons found in the pop-up navigation in more places to reinforce location and function
3
tmdblya•

Agreed, the app seems much more responsive,

As others have pointed out elsewhere, this may be the result of low user population and the app will eventually suffer from typical Topps sluggishness and crashes.

2
Dull_blade•

Response:

  1. I actually like the button to bring up more buttons. Since there are so many more options in this game, it makes since to have have 1 spawn to 9(or more). Other apps may have multiple buttons/options that will take you to the other sub-options/pages. With those, I have to remember which of the first main buttons will get me to the option that I want. 1 to 9 seems easier.

​

2.I agree, but maybe this is still just a beta issue, and more will be populated in the final product

​

  1. I agree. LOTS of clicking, but not so much on the navigation piece to me, but just for the interaction within the app to do stuff. Most of the Topps apps have already gone this way, but this one seems way more, especially with Fusing (I will talk about later).

​

  1. N/A - I have an iPhone, so have never had the option for the back as what I understand is available for Android users.

​

  1. This is one of the biggest problems I see, especially when it comes to trading. I think the trading piece is cumbersome, and fraught with some significant shortcomings - one of which is the dupe count visibility. Do I need to look at each card to determine how many I have before I go into the trade interaction? Also, I have not gotten the 'What they need' filter to work for me. It hangs the app every time I enable it during a trade.

​

Other points:

- The wheel option will sometimes disappear for me, and I have to relaunch the game after a force close.

- Fusing - I like the option, since it brings back the time when melding was a SWCT thing. The main problem I see is the limitation of how often I can fuse. 30 seconds for T1 to T2, 5 mins for T2 to T3, 45 mins for T3 to T4, 90 mins for T4 to T5. And I can only do 1 of those each at a time. And it's random. I haven't actually done the first one listed that supposedly gives you a black Captain America, but it looks like that might be the only guarantee option. I'm assuming that it rotates to a different character after you fuse that one, but what if you don't want that - Is there an option to refresh/reroll that top option? Just to get to one black from 16 whites, it will take me just a little over 200 minutes. But I have to be on top of the timers so that I can immediately fuse. And technically, there is some overlap to those, as I could be fusing two reds at the same time as I'm fusing two greens, etc. Overall, fusing is a nice feature that builds into a base trading value of the cards: 4 whites for a red; 8 whites for a blue; 8 greens for a black. Obviously this does not account for special characters, but I still like it. It's just time consuming, and I'm not paying crystals to 'speed up' the process.

Anyway - I'm still in a wait and see.

2
tmdblya•

The trading interface is a complete cluster.

3
ToppsCastOP•

I forgot to mention that the pack reveal is MUCH better. I hated swiping from right to left to see the cards. Sometimes you'd have to attempt to swipe 2 or 3 times before it worked. Especially those that were forced to buy Samsungs stupid "edge" phones =P.

I am not sure how some feel about not being able to flip the card over when pulling though. Personally, I don't care.

2
ParmThePom•

You have to swipe on emulators?

3
ToppsCastOP•

huh?

1