Im a little confused about the timeline. Minor spoilers

SpoilerLore

So when fighting Owl the second time he says "that's an interested prosthetic, it used to belong to...." but didn't that happen 3 years before Wolf lost his arm?

Posted Apr 20, 2019, 5:32 PM UTC

26
RadioDavee:platinum-flair: Platinum Trophy•

It belonged to the sculptor.

Yeah the whole being in a memory as he is now messes it up a little, but it means that Owl knows the sculptor etc etc.

6
KahramanDede•

It is a memory but it has some time travel elements in it. For example you can bring the flame vent from there and use it to upgrade your arm.

2
stretchling•

I like to think of the Hirata memories as a magical reconstruction of events Wolf was involved in built from memories of the owner of the bell that takes you to the memory. Wolf is playing himself in these memories but it is NOT time travel its a sort of dream world to help Wolf fill in the blanks because he no longer has the memories.

The first bell is Kuro's and so the version of Hirata we see is how Kuro remembered it that night, he only knows that Wolf entered the temple and fought lady butterfly, got stabbed and was wounded bad enough to require Kuro to grant him the resurrection power. That's all Wolf can learn from that memory because thats all Kuro knew of that night.

The second bell was Owls and grants access to the same night but a slightly different version of events. these are Owls memories and through them Wolf learns of Owls involvement in the Hirata raid

The difficult part of this is Wolfs ability to bring physical objects out of the memories and use them in the current time. I dont have an explanation for that, unless the entire game is a dream! (starts having bloodborne lore dive flashbacks)

"I NEED MORE EYES!!!!"

1

Yeah, the item part is the strange part. Not only do you get to bring them, but Anayama points you to the flame barrel as well. It's almost as if you are actually going to present day Hirata, but reliving the memory in sync. I could wave the items away with "it's a game" but Anayama makes that a little tougher. It has to be a sort of time travel because you get two physical prosthetic tools that you physically present to the Sculptor in order to get them fitted, which makes 0 sense if it was just remembering memories. Unless Wolf just goes "oh yeah, I forgot I looted these two back then, they should be somewhere in my backpack".

1
slipthroughOP•

Yeah, I'm starting to think it's time travel. Its the only logical conclusion i can come to as to why wolf is able to have the prosthetic, bring back the attachments, and also have Owl talk about the prosthetic. It would also explain why Wolf has no memory of that night.

1

It's probably not time travel because that's like, 98% not what Miyazaki wants it to be, but in headcanon, the most logical conclusion is that it's timetravel

Game wise, it's you reliving a memory the Buddha has decided to show you, in a sort of lucid dream state.

1