[Homebrew][5e] Dynamic Proficiency Gain and Loss.
Dynamic Proficiency Homebrew
The design of this system is allow players to gain proficiencies is a more natural way. It also allows players to change their proficiencies over time. If your party enters a long heist mission, its realistic that they may earn some proficiency with stealth. Or many your player wants to pick up a longbow for the first time. At the same time, the system is designed so players run the risk of forgetting their learned skills. They will get to choose what skills they don't value or haven't used in a long time and choose to not retain that information. The design of this system to prevent as much information tracking, stat counting, and complex math as possible while actually using some awesome math logic to self balance the system and limit the amount of proficiencies a player may have. “So simple, you’re players can do it!” As of posting, the whole rule set without my explanations/defenses is only 372 words. So r/DnD Roast my homebrew!
-
Proficiency bonus is no longer set by a classes proficiency modifier.
-
The proficiency modifier of a class sets the maximum bonus a proficiency may provide.
-
Proficiencies earned on character creation start at the maximum bonus possible.
Basic rules for setting up the system. I feel like there isn’t much need to explain this part. Feel free to ask questions.
- Upon performing a skill check or attack roll utilizing a proficiency, the player may choose to roll a die dependent on the bonus amount of the proficiency used. For no proficiency a d4, +1 proficiency a d6, +2 proficiency a d8, +3 proficiency a d10, +4 proficiency a d12, and +5 proficiency a d20. Upon rolling a 1, that proficiency increases by 1 up to your proficiency modifier.
This is the main meat on how skills will improve their proficiency. I first heard of the d4~d20 difficulty increasing system from a user who had his character lose his main arm, and had to become proficient with his off hand. I instantly fell in love with it. With this system skills will be easy to pick up at low levels (25% success) and harder at high ones (5%). I personally like the use of 1s because you have the same target to look out for regardless of die. The player has a choice on whether they want to attempt to improve a particular proficiency. The reason for this will be explained later.
- You may improve or gain proficiencies a total number of times equal to your proficiency modifier until you perform a long rest.
This is the first reason why a player wouldn’t want to pick up proficiency in the first skill check they roll. Limiting how much you can get a day prevents players from maxing out too many skills too fast, it also prevents characters from making arbitrary skill checks in hopes of grinding their skills. However, a player training a skill they want to improve should be encouraged within reason.
- If a player has improved any of their proficiency bonuses since their last long rest, upon their next long rest, that player performs a d20 skill check without modifiers with a difficulty class equal to the total number of skills and weapons they are proficient in. Upon failure, the player must reduce the proficiency bonus of any of their proficiencies by a total number that the skill check was fail by.
This is the final big piece of the system. Everything else is game rulings. This is a system to prevent players from maxing every skill in the game and keep them specialized. The difficulty increases based on how many different things the player is proficient in to simulate the difficulty to juggle too many skills. It doesn’t penalize you by being really good at a few things. If a player is content where they are at, they can simply choose to not improve their skills. The thought behind this is that they are now internalizing or focused on maintaining their current skill level. This system does have the ability to critically fail and lose a lot of skills, however this is important. If the amount of skills lost in a day was ever lower than the amount a player could earn, they could eventually grind to a point where they had mastered everything. Because a level 20 can improve their proficiencies 6 times per long rest, without a guarantee they will lost at least 6, there needs to be the potential of losing MORE than six, otherwise the players will continue to learn skills indefinitely. This also makes it so that players who push past the limit too much, get equalized easier. This by no means this is tuned correctly. If you add modifiers to this roll, you can live tune this system. A +5 for example on this roll will allow players to have more proficiencies, while a -5 will allow them to have less. A single modifier change will tune the average number of proficiencies your players may have.
- For the purpose of this system, certain classes and feats gain the benefit of unique or restricted proficiencies that reduce the total number they have. E.g. A fighter would have martial weapon proficiency which counts as only one proficiency, rather than counting a proficiency for each weapon as its own. A kensei monk would have kensei weapon proficiency which covers all their selected kensei weapons.
This game ruling is to allow fighters to be fighters in the current system and for other systems to preform as intended. Classes that are naturally proficient in many different aspects are not penalized for it. What is a simplified proficiency would be up to the DM.
- Expertise in a proficiency doubles the current bonus it provides.
Simple enough, ask any questions or please point any loopholes.
- Jack of All Trades functions as normal, and proficiencies whose only bonus is provided by Jack of All Trades does not count toward your total proficiencies. The bonus of these proficiencies cannot fall below the bonus provided by Jack of All Trades. The die used for training these proficiencies is the normal one for the total amount of bonus they provide. E.g. Jack of All Trades is providing a +3 bonus to a proficiency, the die needed to improve it to a +4 would be a d10.
This is to prevent Jack of All Trades to be useless, with this game ruling it should function similar to RAW.
- This system does not affect or recognize skill save proficiencies, or armor proficiencies.
Armor proficiencies do not function like others, and I feel including skill save proficiencies in this system would not be balanced. However, tool proficiencies are included.
Posted Apr 20, 2019, 5:49 PM UTC