Since the ideas of dedicated server and proper host migration are both dead, what's the word on checkpoints?

A checkpoint system that records the status of the players and the world at certain points and in the case of a host DC the remaining players get put back at that checkpoint in the state they were when they passed it in the first place seems like a better idea than losing all progress. Losing 3-5 minutes of the game and waiting for a loading screen would be irritating, but defensible. That's the kind of issue that you can easily forget as you finish the round. But losing everything and getting booted back to the start is why my friends and I all quit.

So checkpoints. Thoughts?

Posted Apr 21, 2019, 2:35 AM UTC

2829
msdeEmmes•

wait, when were dedicated servers declared dead? I know they're not coming in april 2018.

13
Oxydo89•

They haven't been declared dead by anyone from Fatshark as far as I am aware.

And people claiming so based on that there has been no news for quite a while doesn't make it so, including said clickbait title above.

2†
dnrvsraindish•

CEO said on stream that it turned out to be way more work than they expected and now it's at the bottom of the priority list. Not officially dead but not being actively worked on.

8
Freeform_•

Isn't that exactly the same thing it was with Vermintide 1?
Not to mention that they haven't even tried to add the server support before the game's release and now are surprised that adding a core element to their engine is difficult and costly? Jesus christ Fatshark is sometimes painful to think about, even worse with the lingering memory of roadmaps and sock giveaways. I guess at least they learned to stop bullshiting by now. Great games, but made by shit people, at least at the company's helm.

3
dnrvsraindish•

VT2 is largely based on VT1 so the limitations were already in place. Not to mention there is a bunch of code in the game relating to dedicated servers so assuming they haven't tried is just ignorance.

Things turn out to be harder than anyone though in software development all the time. Games are complex and involve a lot of disciplines, no one can hold all of it in their head at once.

2
IDidItForScienceOP•

I've read a few places that the CEO said they wouldn't be doing dedicated servers in a livestream sometime in the last few months, but I don't have the time to sift through all of the livestreams to find it. If someone has a link to the stream that people are talking about I'd love to see it for myself to make sure I'm not misleading people.

2
VeryWeaponizedJerkSlayer•

If you don't even know for sure then please don't spread false rumors.

2
IDidItForScienceOP•

I don't have 40 hours to go through all the dev streams and I've read in multiple places that fatshark has admitted that they don't plan to do dedicated servers and that they have apologized for lying about it. That's why I asked if any of the 200-700 people that have seen the dev steams remember hearing anything along those lines or if people have been feeding off misinformation from each other.

1
Yerome- Reikland Pest Control•

Checkpoint system is something I have thought about. I do think Fatshark would have been better off investing development time into proper host migration instead of dedicated servers. But that's mostly just hindsight I suppose.

The biggest problem with checkpoints is they are open to abuse. If your team is about to wipe, the host can leave and even possibly join back if he was playing with friends.

From what I gather Vermintide currently does not support reloading unfinished maps, so the whole checkpoint system is something Fatshark would have to build from scratch. Basic checkpoint system would probably be easy enough to code, but such new system is bound to be riddled with bugs, which probably are not a trivial thing to fix.

8
IDidItForScienceOP•

Host migration would have been the way to go but according to a recent dev response in this thread it is incredibly unlikely that they will rewrite the game to make it possible.

As for abuse of the checkpoint system, make it so the host can't rejoin that game. If they were trying to screw with the system they shouldn't get back in and if their game is unstable it would be better for matchmaking to drop a new person in.

And yes this would be a pretty big undertaking, but it is a system that would be closer to fulfilling the promises Fatshark made in order to sell the game, and it would bring back tons of people.

3
VeryWeaponizedJerkSlayer•

As for abuse of the checkpoint system, make it so the host can't rejoin that game. If they were trying to screw with the system they shouldn't get back in and if their game is unstable it would be better for matchmaking to drop a new person in.

What if it's a random disconnect though? Are you going to punish someone that lost connection despite them?

1
IDidItForScienceOP•

It's not a perfect system but it's a lot better than the complete lack of a system we have now.

1
MysteriousSalp•

Something would be nice, checkpoints would make sense, though I have no idea how difficult that would be. I haven't heard the devs mention it, and right now I think they've got all hands on deck for Winds of Magic.

2
supattsu•

Hey, as a workaround to this if you are on PC you can just host all your games, even when you're solo. People will still join your games and you won't ever run in to this issue.

I also disagree with people saying this would bring players back. I think it would only have that impact if it had been done earlier in the game's life near launch.

1
redaxemranger•

Checkpoints would be very nice. I personally hate how grind oriented the game is (play missions to get chests to get gear to play missions) but if they are going to go that route they should at least respect players' time.

1
Nidhoeggr89The Door Slayer of Karak Azgaraz•

How many dc's did you have overall? I barely had half a dozen actual DC's in over 1k hours.

-2
IDidItForScienceOP•

Personally I had about 1 DC every 4-6 hours, but it was extremely rare to go more than an hour without at least one person DCing from a game. It ended up being that the host would ragequit or DC about one game every hour which is why my friends and I stopped playing.

3
Nidhoeggr89The Door Slayer of Karak Azgaraz•

It ended up being that the host would ragequit or DC about one game every hour which is why my friends and I stopped playing.

So play together and host your own games? Reduces the ragequits to 0%. Playing with bad pubs who ragequit is one of the big disadvantages of QP imho, if you are two people you should ALWAYS host.

0
IDidItForScienceOP•

And when we would host the game would still crash and we'd lose hosts. Also we don't always have times when we can get 4 people together to play because we all work.

1
kweassa•

I don't see the point, seems like too much developer effort into a minor inconvenience/frustration.

-8
-Maethendias-Unchained•

minor? peer to peer and the horrible gameplay implications that come with it make the game unplayable for me

8
Al-13Anvil•

peer to peer

It's listen server. Not p2p.

1
-Maethendias-Unchained•

never trust an ai >:O

1
IDidItForScienceOP•

This "inconvenience/frustration" is why thousands of people stopped playing the game. It's the reason that the game isn't putting up numbers like L4D2.

2
Dollar249Skaven Skank•

But losing everything and getting booted back to the start is why my friends and I all quit.

Not trying to sound rude but you sound like the type that would do all the missions once and quit anyway.

I dont think it will happen, its not like it happens that often. Like not even 1 in 20 runs i loose connection to host.

-10
mayumerEmpire Soldier•

Like not even 1 in 20 runs i loose connection to host.

Lucky you! Was way more frequent for me and 140 hrs in I had an entire evening of disconnections/crashes/ragequits and dropped the game, staying here hoping one day I see patch notes fixing this.

5
IDidItForScienceOP•

Same boat I'm in.

3
venndiggory•

Nearing 300 hours here. I can remember maybe 3 times I've had connection problems.

4
IDidItForScienceOP•

I stopped playing around 160 hour having played all the maps and I was working my way through Legend with the intent to get reds on my mage while learning new builds on all the other heroes.

And as for the incredibly dogshit attitude that you put forward with your comment, EVERYONE DESERVES A GOOD GAME YOU COCKGOBLIN. Whether they are the most hardcore of people who just play a bit, WE SHOULD ALL BE ABLE TO PLAY THE GAME WITHOUT A RANDOM CHANCE OF LOSING EVERYTHING THAT IS COMPLETELY OUTSIDE OUR CONTROL.

2