How can a grade 4 textbook be a grade 8 one for another province?
I was recently checking Duval Education's french site and I noticed some huge differences in suggested use between the provinces. Civilisations anciennes was recommended for Ontario grade 4 students (francais) yet it apparently fit the Manitoba grade 8 curriculum. The same book in English only had a grade 5 Ontario to grade 8 Manitoba disparity, but it's still quite large.
Personally I don't see how you can make a textbook that would meet a grade 4er's needs yet also meet a grade 8er's. So, R/Canada- any of you know whether this is simply a cash grab by the publisher or are they actually serious and can this book meet a grade 4 French-as-a-first-language speaker living in Ontario's needs yet also meet a grade 8 Manitoban's?
Posted Mar 20, 2010, 4:34 AM UTC
it's not about the age of the student, it's about what grade the subject is taught.
If these were about different countries (sweden vs australia), the grade difference would make the same sense - some cover sweden in 4th grade, some in 8th. Some cover australia in 7th grade, some in 11th.