r/canada•
sidekun

How can a grade 4 textbook be a grade 8 one for another province?

I was recently checking Duval Education's french site and I noticed some huge differences in suggested use between the provinces. Civilisations anciennes was recommended for Ontario grade 4 students (francais) yet it apparently fit the Manitoba grade 8 curriculum. The same book in English only had a grade 5 Ontario to grade 8 Manitoba disparity, but it's still quite large.

Personally I don't see how you can make a textbook that would meet a grade 4er's needs yet also meet a grade 8er's. So, R/Canada- any of you know whether this is simply a cash grab by the publisher or are they actually serious and can this book meet a grade 4 French-as-a-first-language speaker living in Ontario's needs yet also meet a grade 8 Manitoban's?

Posted Mar 20, 2010, 4:34 AM UTC

922
AmandaKerik•

it's not about the age of the student, it's about what grade the subject is taught.

If these were about different countries (sweden vs australia), the grade difference would make the same sense - some cover sweden in 4th grade, some in 8th. Some cover australia in 7th grade, some in 11th.

5
mamid•

I was smarter in school in Ontario. I was easily three grades ahead and doing all that remedial work made me bored at school - I had already covered it. Moving to BC destroyed my desire to go to school

Worse yet, one school district in BC covered a subject two years before the next one did and a third three years after that one. I never did learn what happened after the last spike and know almost nothing of history up to 1980s when it wasn't history to me, but part of my life and times.

4
[deleted]•

Yes, this is quite true. When I moved to BC, in grade four, my fellow students were amazed that I had learned to write in cursive previously in Ontario. Mathematics? French? Yeah, the gap was even worse.

1
rainman_104British Columbia•

. When I moved to BC, in grade four, my fellow students were amazed that I had learned to write in cursive previously in Ontario

Because we've have an obscenely stupid amount of ESL students here in BC who have parents who refuse to worry about english.

Kinda sad really. You have to go to school in the suburbs now to get a school that has english speaking kids. There's small pockets scattered around town, but in places like Shaughnessey, you'll get 28 asian kids and 2 caucasian ones. And half the asian kids can't communicated due to ESL skills.

2
mamid•

I had the same problem. I was doing cursive and multiplications in Ontario up to 12 and my classes in BC were barely doing "1X5". I easily forgot everything I had learned. In French, I was writing poetry and more in grade 3 and in grade 4, was going over stuff I had gone over in grade 2 and repeated it again in grade 6/7. No teacher believed me because my grades were "too low" and my mother hadn't brought my work from Ontario with me.

1
phirate•

I learned cursive in the 2nd/3rd grade going to school on Vancouver Island but when I moved back to the mainland I found out that my previous schools were apparently wasting a lot of time.

0
notcaptainkirk•

I learned to write cursive in grade 2. I was educated in the lower mainland. You likely moved from a good school to a shitty one. The location has no bearing.

Also, I think education as a whole is failing our children, so I am by no means defending the system.

3
phirate•

Very true. I went from a brand new school that was very high tech for the time to an inner city school that used photocopies of textbooks stolen from another local school. Though the school that taught me cursive was not actually the high tech school. I was pretty appalled to find out that the computer lab at my 'new school' was filled with way outdated Macintosh computers and that our textbooks were not actual textbooks but rather photocopies of textbooks we had somehow acquired from another school in the district. They even photocopied in the page that said " Property of (Not My School) Elementary ". On the plus side I scored REALLY high on tests compared to most of my classmates.

It bothers me that the standards aren't the same for all schools. Why do we allow the children of poor people to get shittier educations? Kids don't choose to be poor or live in shitty neighbourhoods. The education system is absolutely screwed. I am not looking forward to the day my son enters kindergarten.

1
phirate•

I only went to school in BC but I went to 6 different elementary schools. I have so many gaps in my knowledge it's sick. I somehow managed to miss any and all 'sex talks' in school because every school I went to did it at a different grade. Let's not even talk about history or anything that actually matters.

Then again, there were many areas where I was ahead of the kids at my final school but that had more to do with my final school being inner city and full of morons.

1
mamid•

I went to schools in BC in three different school districts - 4 schools in total. I first learned about the last spike in grade 4, again in grade 6, again in grade 8, and lastly, in grade 10 and 11 in the same school! I even brought in the work from previous years to try to convince them that I had already covered the subject. Oh no... we were older now and could go further in depth. :P So I just rewrote everything I did and submitted it. Got the same mark which shows either the teachers hated me or didn't care to actually read what I wrote.

1
phirate•

Apparently we really needed to know about the last spike. Pretty sure I too had to learn about it a few times. I still don't see why it is so very important that we learned about it.

2
mamid•

I learned more about it watching the CBC documentary than I did reading about it in school for the fourth time. It drove me nuts.

but one thing I always wondered - did they leave the golden spike or did they pull it and put in a normal one instead?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0
mamid•

I wanted to spend my last two years in school back in Ontario but no one from my mother's family wanted me to move in with them. I could have used the grade 13 too!

1
[deleted]•

I'm guessing it's grade 8 in Newfoundland?

4
Captain_Vasectomy•

No, you graduate from high school in Newfoundland when you stop peeing in the sandbox.

6
manualD•

I thought you graduated when you get your first un-employment cheque?

1
bellestreet•

I had huge difficulties after moving from Ontario to Alberta just before grade 10. The biggest difference was in math - I won a math award in Ontario in grade 9; failed math in grade 10.

I went from all As, some Bs, to some Bs and mostly Cs finishing up high school. There was huge disparity between what was taught when, and it totally screwed me over.

3
martincles•

Couldn't adjust to the red in the neck, eh? I only did school in Alberta, so I can't even speak for those kind of adjustments.

1
bretticon•

Civilasation Anciennes has a grade 4 only for the fully french communities while the English curriculum puts it a year later I wouldn't consider it a huge jump. Putting the topic at a later date lets you go a bit more in detail. As for the Grade 8 label, my guess is it's probably an attempt to sell more copies. The reading level will likely be too easy for grade 8 Manitobans but I'd guess they don't look at Ancient Civilizations until that Grade so they have to list it for grade 8

1
joelwilliamson•

Ontarians are just smarter than Manitobans

-2
hardran3•

In Ontario most kids in grade 4 are 14 years old.

8
MrFlaggOntario•

In Keswick your dad walks you to school because he is in the same grade.

1