Can r/science answer my natural selection question?

I'm taking a class on dinosaurs as a break from engineering, but I don't understand the idea behind natural selection.

Lets take the idea of a species losing a digit on the hand, like I know some dinos did.

First, isn't something this small insignificant? It can't really add a significant advantage, which is the whole idea of natural selection right? What could they possibly do with 1 less digit that wasn't possible before?

Second, now lets assume that losing a finger is significantly beneficial for whatever reason. It's not like some species are born without that finger, it's just that over many generations it gets smaller and smaller until it's gone right? A gradual process. Anyway, as insignificant as losing a digit seems, spreading that loss over many many generations, the change wouldn't impact their life at all right? Each generation they might lose a few mm of length, but is that enough to drive natural selection? As a human analogy, I believe humans are gradually getting taller (if I'm wrong just assume it for a second). That means that taller people must be more successfully reproductive. Sure, if it's a difference between 4 ft and 6 ft maybe, but if you were maybe a millimeter or two taller than you are now, I can't reasonable believe that would benefit your sex life at all.

Third, and finally, in one of the cladograms discussed (i don't have my notes here i forget the specifics) some branch of dinos lost a digit on the hand and a few branches down re-gained it. I understand it's easy to lose soemthing, but how is it so easy to gain it back, unless the genetic information is still stored and just not used (forgive my lack of terminology.) IE: If a species were to lose a digit, it's gone, so if later that trait was to return is it somehow new, or was the lost finger just supressed genetically and later re-activated?

Posted Mar 20, 2010, 8:20 PM UTC

529
Loading comments…