r/reddit.com•
one37

New Rule: If you`re over 55 you aren`t allowed to create or influence any lawmaking. Some extensions may be granted.

[removed]

Posted Mar 23, 2010, 10:52 PM UTC

512
[deleted]•

I think everyone should get a say regardless of age or anything else. The problem with your idea is that if we do prevent old people from voting then it becomes as slippery slope, pretty soon it will be blacks, or Mexicans or even redditors.

2
one37OP•

That's why we have an appeals process where the entrant has to order a pizza on the internet.

1
magnasombrero•

If only Mexicans voted, beer & tacos would be free nationwide and mandatory siestas on the workplace!

1
[deleted]•

That wouldn't be too bad, I like beer and tacos. Maybe they'd also vote to allow Tequila production in the US. That would be cool too.

1
notParanoid•

The problem with your argument is that it's a slippery slope fallacy.

The problem with the original poster's argument is that it's stupid.

How about we strive for some degree of balance in terms of who represents us? How about we try not to have people over 55 influence every damn thing disproportionately, but stop short of making a ridiculous blanket ban on a whole group?

1
[deleted]•

The problem with your argument is that it's a slippery slope fallacy.

How is my argument a slippery slope fallacy? I was pointing out the slippery slope, not using one.

1
notParanoid•

Every slippery slope is a fallacy. You said, "if we prevent old people from voting it becomes a slippery slope" to other rights being denied. It doesn't follow automatically that such would be the case - we might have a perfectly good reason to stop old people from voting (people under 18 haven't ever been able to vote and yet the minimum age has decreased, not increased).

I know, I know: when discussing constitutional law it's for some reason permissible and commonplace to say "if one right is taken away it's a slippery slope to others being taken away." Unless you actually give at least a vague idea of the steps through which that might happen, the argument is fallacious. (Pointing out a slippery slope essentially IS using one. Because it implies that regardless of other parameters, one trend will amplify itself to a point of no return - which is exactly the sort of rhetorical exaggeration that constitutes the slippery slope fallacy.)

1
[deleted]•

Well, thank you for explaining that instead of scoffing and calling me an idiot.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
magnasombrero•

I think my rule would be: you CAN'T make any laws if you're under 55.

2
raybeis•

The problems we face as a nation aren't due to the age of the people making the decisions, but rather who they are beholden. Our representatives aren't stupid, rather they just represent the people who fund them. The system is completely broken. Throwing out the old people will only cause the corporations to buy young people.

1
one37OP•

The corporation doing so would have to be staffed exclusively by people under the age of 55. If you haven't got it together enough by the time you're 55 I think it's fair to say that it is time to let someone else have a turn.

1
PDB•

Lets be fair to everyone and make it...if you're a Republican and over 55 you can't.....etc.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

0