Lights or a light meter?

Lighting

I’ve been out of the game for quite a long time and in the interim I lost/sold most of my gear to keep myself afloat. I never owned a light meter since most of my work was between myself and friends’ short films but now that I’m getting settled again I’d like to up my game a bit. I’ve hit a bit of a snag in my decision making process in that after getting most of my gear (Camera, Steadicam, monitors and follow focus...etc) I have only so much left to spend. I’d love to learn to properly use a meter (especially ratios using spot) but at the same time I’m not sure if I should invest in a small light kit instead. The driving confusion for me is that a lot of big time cinematographers that I know admit to not using light meters anymore, even on 50 million + movies.

Should I get the meter and practice so I can up my game or should I continue to rely on Waveform and False Color while buying a few lights?

Posted Apr 25, 2019, 6:48 PM UTC

314
Gbvisual•

I love my meter ! I'm looking to grab a spot meter sometime soon! It really depends what type of work you do ! I shoot a little bit of film and I am really into dialing in ratios when I work ! I'm also in a position that I am able to to rent a lighting package appose to bringing my own gear so I can justify a meter ! If your getting started and you feel you want to shoot your own work and a light meter may not be something you need I'd say go for some decent lights grab a light meter app on your phone and that'll at least get you in the ball park :) my first meter I found on a website we have in Canada which is just like Craigslist called Kijiji! And I paid 50 dollars ! Still works fantastic for an analog meter :) hope I was somewhat of a help!

3
SandstoneDOP•

Absolutely and thank you for your time.

1
rib9985Camera Assistant•

Absolutely! Many here may say light meters are not essential, but they actually are the best tool for exposure, lighting ratios, and data collection. They also help with maintaining the continuity of your lighting set-ups.

1
MrWilliamus•

I would get both. I know you are on a budget, so spend a couple hundreds on an old Minolta spotmeter from eBay ($100) and an analog incident meter from Gossen or Sekonic (who work without batteries). And then buy some lights, because that's the smarter investment (although everything gets obsolete now). Your lights will nicely complement the minimal rental package you will get on the many jobs where the budget wouldn't allow LED, They'll allow you to work faster and will make you look more skilled, and they will keep your rate decent.

2
SandstoneDOP•

Thanks for that information. I really appreciate it.

1
SquishTheWhaleDirector of Photography•

I shoot without a light meter all the time, I never shoot without lights.

Get the lights.

2
Rex_Lee•

You don't need a light meter if you can read histograms/false colors/waveforms

2
Zaku41k•

So here’s an odd question , how smart do you want to appear ?

I have a light meter but only used it for 2 of the last 50 projects. Both of those were green screens. Honestly I didn’t use my light meter because I needed it, but because I wanted the DP to stop second guessing me.

That’s my 2 cents. Cheers.

1
SandstoneDOP•

I guess I’m just concerned that I won’t get great consistent ratios and my eyes might deceive me. I’m guessing false color and waveforms are really all that are truly needed?

2
Zaku41k•

I’ve always relied on that. Then again , I’m in California Bar Area so I’m super spoiled.

2
SandstoneDOP•

I don’t care if I appear smart as long as my work looks professional.

2
DurtyKurty•

I'd argue that a light meter is pretty damn essential every time you're lighting a scene without a camera present. Especially if you need to work at a stop that isn't totally analogous to what your eye sees naturally. Or if you need to match key exposures within a scene, or if you need your key to extend over a large area and want it to be consistent.

1
Gbvisual•

I mean a light meter isn't something you carry on yourself to look smarter, there are plenty of uses for a light meter and they can really improve your understanding lighting!

1
dillydally109•

Pm

1