[Bingo Review] If you are struggling with the LitRPG square, try The Luckless by A. M. Sohma!

Review

The Luckless by A. M. Sohma is a Litrpg with an almost classic setup. Kit logs in to the full-body submersion fantasy game Second Age of Retha. Shortly afterwards a computer error breaks the game, disabling the log out button. Kit—and thousands of other gamers—are now trapped in the simulation. The only way to get out is to beat the end game boss and trigger an automatic logout.

There is just one problem with this plan—Kit is stuck in the body of a joke character. Due to prank gone wrong, she is now a Lv 5 Elf Dancer, widely regarded as the worst class in the game. She must find a way to overcome her near useless character, collect a ragtag bunch of misfits, and take on an end game boss no other player has successfully defeated (and if she’s really lucky, find a shirt that covers her stomach).

This book is nothing spectacular or groundbreaking, but where it truly shines is in its humour. This book is pure fun—the author clearly had fun writing this, the characters have fun playing the game, and I found myself giggling every couple of pages at their antics. I can’t remember the last time I read something so laugh-out-loud amusing. This book is the literary equivalent to a really big swing set at the park, with the promise of an ice cream cone before you go home. It’s not a grand adventure or a Shakespearean epic, but it is a fun time. I’m saying ‘fun’ a lot, but honestly, this is just a really fun story.

The world building and characterisation is fairly sparse—the only character who really gets any focus is Kit, and the world is cliche, except when it isn’t (this is actually lampshaded by a character in the third book). But the action is well written. As adventurers, the Kit and her group of misfits are often thrown into combat against a variety of powerful enemies. By utilising her knowledge of video game tactics, Kit must lead (and dance) her party to victory against everything from slimes to dragons, and hopefully not die too many times in the process.

It’s an incredibly fast paced story, with something happening every page. I’m actually reminded of the old pulp fiction novels in how it is structured, only given a fresh coat of paint and the ability to laugh at its own foolishness. The story is very light and easy to read—I burned through all three books in a single afternoon.

The LitRPG elements are also very light—there are no stat blocks or character sheets at all in the story, and common gaming terms and concepts are explained as they crop up, so that no reader is left confused. It’s obvious that the author herself has first hand experience with gaming and gaming culture, and wants to share that experience with others.

There is also a slow burn romance throughout the series—the author writes fantasy romance and fairy tale rewrites under the name K. M. Shea, and it is clear—by the size and popularity of her back catalogue—that she knows what she is doing. I am especially keen to see how this develops over the next few books.

So if you are looking for something fun, light and easy to read, and you want to tick off that pesky LitRPG square, I heartily recommend this book.

Bingo Squares:

  • LitRPG (Hard mode)
  • Self Published

Posted Apr 28, 2019, 9:44 AM UTC · edited

1421
MedusasRockGardenReading Champion 2018•

Looks fun, and it's on Kindle Unlimited. On Goodreads though it is showing as having over 1000 pages..... This is seemingly the page count for the whole trilogy being shown on book one by mistake. Amazon says it is 270 pages. Which means it is also a relatively quick read as well.

6
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

That's right, it's around 270 pages, and very easy to read. The KU is cherry on top—especially since I'm still in my free trial!

4
mhc9210•

Thank you! I have DNFed two other LitRPGs so I hoping I can do this one. It sounds kind of like Spy Kids 3 which I loved lol

5
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

LitRPG is a genre I want to love, but it's so hard to find anything actually readable. When I first started this, I thought I'd only read a few chapters before DNFing it, but I ended up devouring it.

And Spy Kids was a great set of movies.

4
dybsy•

If you love LitRPG, I would absolutely welcome your review of my self-pub—‘Dybsy’. I’ll trade a free copy for an honest review? It’s also on KU so maybe that will accomplish things.

2
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

I'm not comfortable receiving free copies of books from authors, and reviewing is only a hobby for me, so I can't guarantee that I'll actually write one.

Thanks for the offer though.

4
dybsy•

No worries, thanks for the reply!

2
eriophora•

Looks like this is also eligible for hard mode! I just looked up the author to check :)

4
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

I actually stumbled across this book looking for female LitRPG authors.

2
Axeran•

Thanks for the tips! Sounds like a fun LitRPG.

3
CarolinaCMReading Champion 2017-18•

Thanks so much! It's been so hard to find an interesting LitRPG that features a female author and MC. I'm definitely going to read this for my card.

3
xenizondich23•

Have you checked out some of the older webserials like Worm or The Wandering Inn?

2
CarolinaCMReading Champion 2017-18•

Avid reader of both, and many other web serials. It's just the LitRPG ones, like Worth the Candle or Metaworld that I've never been able to get into. TWI might be LitRPG, but a veeeery mild LitRPG so I don't think it really counts.

2
slyphic•

Worm is neither litRPG, nor female authored. It's well worth reading, but kind of a non sequitur recommendation.

1
slyphic•

This book is nothing spectacular or groundbreaking

...

The world building and characterisation is fairly sparse

...

The LitRPG elements are also very light

...

and you want to tick off that pesky LitRPG square

I do not understand why litRPG is on the bingo list. Of all the comments about it in the announcement thread, only one isn't negative. The most recommended litRPG book I see mentioned is Arcane Ascension (read it before hearing it was litRPG, wasn't bad), which has the huge caveat that it wasn't written to be the subgenre, and doesn't even really have any of the elements of the genre.

And now this. "it's funny, maybe you can stand to read it, the bad parts aren't all that bad"

Of all the fantasy subgenre's why the hell does this one keep getting pushed so hard?

I get the bingo is supposed to 'expand your literary horizons', but if the best the genre can produce is 'almost as good as books that aren't litRPG', then it's like bringing hákarl to a potluck.

2
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

It was not my intention to make this look like a bad book. I loved this book. But it is important to acknowledge that this isn't a Martin/Erikson/Hobb quality level book. It is a solid, middle of the road fantasy novel. We've all read a book like that, and we've been able to enjoy them whilst acknowledging they are not perfect.

And it's true that the LitRPG genre is a little swamped with low effort titles at the moment, and I do believe it needs a few more years to fully mature into a fully fledged genre.

But I don't believe that is a inherent fault of the genre itself, but rather a result of its audiences expectations. And if the audience is broadened to include more literary readers, then many of them will go 'I want better' or even 'I can do better' and the market will adjust to the demand.

So I suppose the point of the LitRPG square isn't to highlight current high quality works, but to showcase the unrealised potential of the genre, and inspire people to be better.

2
slyphic•

litRPG is making me feel like a grouchy old man.

Everything is swamped with low effort titles now. Kindle Unlimited is pushing the boundaries of Sturgeon's Law. I don't think litRPG can hide behind that excuse.

litRPG is ill-defined enough that I can't tell if it has good books or not. I heard someone say Reamde by Neal Stephenson was litRPG the other day, which really doesn't sound right. But Ready Player One probably is, not that that's really helping the genre's reputation.

It seems like folks that want to champion it are including lauded books only tangentially related to bolster it's reputation, but at the same time all the articles describing it are pretty clear that it must HEAVILY incorporate RPG mechanics into the narrative.

if the audience is broadened to include more literary readers, then many of them will go 'I want better' or even 'I can do better' and the market will adjust to the demand.

I don't think it works that way. Literary readers explore new genres once they produce worthwhile books. Subgenre's appeal to fans of the parent genre, and as the number of fans grow, so does the potential pool of authors, and eventually something bubbles to the top.

Compare it to the other bingo subgenre Afrofuturism. I see people in the threads excited by that square, not dreading it or already substituting it like litRPG. And folk can point to lists of awarded and literary books that were written for the genre.

So I suppose the point of the LitRPG square isn't to highlight current high quality works, but to showcase the unrealised potential of the genre, and inspire people to be better.

Again, I don't think writing works that way. I haven't known any authors to write a story out of spite. Inspiration typically needs a positive emotion. It really looks like most of the litRPG authors are inspired by money.

Bah, nothing to see here but an old man shouting at clouds. Once litRPG produces it's Neuromancer I'll give it a read, but at the moment, it's just for folks that are already fans of the genre.

2
zmichalo•

Kit logs in to the full-body submersion fantasy game

Yeah, this is my problem with LitRPG. You've already lost me.

1
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

It's just a more advanced type of the VR sets we have now, and is part of the 'buy in'—the suspension of disbelief—that the book asks you to accept in order to enjoy it.

It's not that different from accepting that Jedi or orcs or dragons exist. It doesn't have to make complete sense, just enough sense to make you care about the characters and their journey.

Hell, it's virtually the same as the magic wardrobe that takes you to Narnia. Or even the magic painting of a boat, which somehow makes less sense than the wardrobe? I blame Cat-Jesus, myself.

3
zmichalo•

It's not the suspension of disbelief that I have an issue with, I just don't like the premise.

2
JCGilbasaurusOPReading Champion 2018•

That's fair enough.

2