Changes Needed To Trading

I had this in the Bugle, but pulled it and made its own topic for visilibity:

Pertaining to trading only, going to assemble (see what I did there?) a list here of improvements/updates that should be implemented. Will update as other suggestions roll in if they carry weight. Also let me know if I'm just outright wrong on these, as I don't do a lot of trading.

  • "poker setup:" cards you're receiving should be up top, cards you're giving away should be at the bottom ("your hand").

  • MUST have quantities you own, and "Need it" tag displaying on the full screen of the trade

  • How about ability to just scroll through all the cards they offer or you're giving up. Currently I have to click on a card, then x/back out, then click next one. Other apps I can swipe through all the cards on one side of the trade (and in the "old" days I could swipe through every single card on either side in the trade).

  • settings should save on how you want to display trades (pending, all, ignored, completed, etc). This should also apply to when you're viewing your collection, but that's another battle.

  • the "accepted" order or maybe it's "all" displays the oldest first? I'd think accepted/completed trades should display in the latest you accepted first (top).

  • "Cancel" a trade. Very weird wording if I am in the middle of a trade and want to cancel it and back out. When I hit the back arrows to back out it says "CONFIRM, You're about to cancel this trade" and then I'm presented with CANCEL or CONFIRM. The correct choice is of course confirm, but for whatever reason my brain keeps seeing cancel and hitting it because I'm cancelling a trade after all. Why not simplify this menu with "Cancel trade?" and "No/Yes," or "Stay and Yes/Confirm Cancel."

  • Not aware of a way to tell me on my home page that there is a trade waiting for me, believe this is well known and being worked on.

  • Once hitting Trade in the menu, I get FEED, TRADE, TRADE LIST. Why not a tab for our friends/who we follow. Why not an add follower selection there, because that way if I have set up a trade with someone here, I can just go find them easily and put the trade together (preferably without having to add them as a friend, but that's how it has always been).

  • currently no way to blind trade with more than one partner. Other apps you can select I believe up to 5 others. Sending one blind trade out at a time is limiting and just not worth it.

  • locked cards show as a need to other players.

  • ability to click avatar (on "TRADE" screen and while viewing a pending trade) to be taken to new trade screen or profile page.

  • ability to see offers all at once as they are currently in other apps... main trade screen should show the trades instead of having to click through as an extra step.

updated 4/29/19 5:26pm et

Posted Apr 29, 2019, 3:08 PM UTC · edited

417
JDamon88•

Definitely agree about having quantities on cards you own in a trade. The number of times i've had to double-check to make sure they're taking a dupe and not a single...it should just be in the corner of each card on the trade screen!

6
zodalx•

+1 on all points, especially #2 and #3. Clicking in and out of every card to figure out if I'm giving away dupes / getting back needs / etc is way too much work.

4
KaoticRyit•

YES TO ALL OF THIS.

There are so many quality of life improvement this app needs. This list for the trade section is just the start but just having all of these done would do wonders.

I actually like this new Topps app interface but there’s so many things that NEED to be better implemented for it to have mass appeal. Fixing the trading area with the above should be number 1 considering this is literally a collect and trade card app.

2
mzrebekah•

-I like the poker layout idea. My cards in front of me and their cards on the top.

  • I also get confused when trying to cancel a trade because Cancel button cancels the cancel?! *****This is very important because in SWCT once i trade card002 for card011, the app automatically deletes all other pending trades for those cards. However in Marvel, 2 trades went thru simultaneously and i lost both my dupe and my original! Which i then had to go back out and trade for again. I’m using my locks now.

Segue to a BIG BUG of trading on Marvel: any card i have locked shows as a Need to other players. I keep having to decline these trades and it’s rude.

2
ParmThePomOP•

i have added the locked cards issue to the list. thanks for the input.

1
danielcullinan•

In the actual trade window, there is no way to see the comments conversation; only the last comment is displayed.

Again in the trade window, it would be great to click on the other player's avatar and be taken to their profile page (as in news or trade feeds) so you can initiate a new blank trade.

Personally I think the trades feed in the other current apps is so much better – I can see all my offers upfront without having to click through to a different screen, be notified if there are any comments, and can click through to other user's profile. If a trade is only between 1–3 cards then it only takes up one row of space as opposed to a bunch of empty grey boxes. If I want to find that guy I traded with 3 days ago I just scroll and visually scan.

2
ParmThePomOP•

boy that's a lot to take in. so how about:

  • only last comment is displayed in a conversation. Hard to follow.

  • ability to click avatar (on "TRADE" screen and while viewing a pending trade) to be taken to new trade screen or profile page (I added the last part, an extra step but similar to what happens when you're just on the "FEED" screen)

  • ability to see offers all at once as they are currently in other apps... main trade screen should show the trades instead of having to click through as an extra step.

That seem to be the gist of it?

Seems like everything we have all listed is "make it like the old way" :)

1
danielcullinan•

Sorry for the length, probably only the first one is an actual bug!

It’s hard not to make a disfavourable comparison when the trade interface works pretty well already on the current apps - but that being said, on the other hand I think the home button/menu and store layout are much better and more concise in Marvel, and I love that they’re engaging with us on the development.

1
KaoticRyit•

When in the trade window, there’s a small button that says “VIEW” right under your avatar in the middle of the screen. If you click that, it will bring up the entire conversation.

2
danielcullinan•

Ah, interesting - great spot. Seems that ‘view’ button disappears once the trade is completed.

2
ParmThePomOP•

good eye. Since the function indeed exists, I took it off the list above. I'm sure several others learned about the "view" button because of your post. I sure didn't know about it.

2
ParmThePomOP•

nah you're good and all good points, I didn't even realize some of them were issues since I don't use them that much. Just trying to get them concise to add to the list. I wasn't looking for bugs, I was looking for things to make trading not a chore.

I do agree that navigating around is fairly simple and fast once you're used to it in marvel. No complaints there.

I'll add the above to my list in the format I had them if that sums them up correctly.

1
Tobin_Topps•

Thanks for taking the time to put together all the great ideas and feedback. We are discussing internally; many of your ideas already in the works.

2
ParmThePomOP•

good to hear, and welcome to reddit.

2
Tobin_Topps•

Thanks

1
thoroakenfelder•

When I tried to do a new trade with a previous trade partner, I removed all the prior cards and chose some new cards, however I kept getting an error about some of those cards being unavailable.

1