Can't seem to get 5th new villager

I got my first 4 new villagers fairly easily, but I'm still needing Gayle (Alligator). For 5 days, I've been sending all Dharmas, or all minimalist lamps, or all Alpine lamps -- sometimes combinations of those -- sometimes leftover junk from opening fortune cookies. I've sent Gulliver in all 4 directions multiple times. Five days, sending 2x-3x per day. No Gayle.

I've always thought it was pretty random, like a 30% chance of getting a villager map, but it's been five days now, and now I'm wondering if I missed an announcement or something.

I am supposed to get all five from Gulliver's maps, right? I mean, it's not like I have to get one new villager from an event or quest or something... right?

I just sent Gulliver off with another 10 Alpine lamps, to the east. I think if he comes back empty-handed again, I'll just give up. I'm tired of binge-crafting.

Posted May 2, 2019, 7:18 AM UTC

52
Hurpy_Durpy01474195911•

It took me 7 days of never missing a rotation to get Marina. I got all the others on the day they came out.

Just keep sending him out, you'll get her eventually. Good luck (*゚▽゚)ノ

3
tsarevna19171689 8719 185 Lychee•

You get them all from gulliver. I had the same struggle with a villager, stopped sending gulliver out for a weekend, stocked up on furniture cookies and then sent him out, got the villager. But honestly, it was just pure luck. Rng can be an ass. Just keep going :)

2