I personally always choose diamond because you can use a SCT and Grade Reset on them plus there’s special training and the set deck bonus is better.  

For the card itself with the exception of power all his numbers close enough on the diamond and he isn’t even trained yet plus you always have the option to use SCT if you’re looking for better skills. If you don’t really care about getting to a Diamond S deck the gold offers nice versatility for the bench being able to use him at 2nd or short and would offer some nice pop as a pinch hitter.

I have a 91 Simmons ‘15 at shortstop already, and I have a 91 Murphy ‘17 on my bench I can replace the gold Cabrera with. I currently have a Gold C and Diamond D set deck. Any advice on who to keep would be helpful.

Decisions Decisions