r/dndnext•
Slivius

Calculations on the CR of the PHB Ranger's Companions

Analysis

Introduction

The Beastmaster subclass for the PHB Ranger is infamous for how terribly it measures up against the other classes and subclasses released for 5e so far. In particular, many people are concerned about the stats of the Beastmaster's 3rd level feature: Ranger's Companion.

​

The Ranger's Companion feature gives you a beast of CR 1/4 or lower, that becomes your loyal companion, and can be used in combat.

​

Since the Ranger's Companion scales with Ranger level in terms of HP (4x) and with the Ranger's proficiency bonus in terms of AC, Atk rolls, Damage rolls, proficiencies and saving throws, I have calculated the adjusted CR of a few of the possible companions for each of the 20 levels a Ranger can have. For these calculations, I used the rules presented in the DMG starting at page 274.

​

Data

This table shows the CR of six semi-popular Ranger's Companions from the Beastmaster subclass of the PHB Ranger:

Ranger LevelWolf CRGiant Crab CRBlood Hawk CRStirge CRGiant Poisonous Snake CRDolphin CRKruthik Scaling
11/41/81/81/81/41/8Young
21/41/81/81/81/41/8Young
3211131/4Adult
4211131Adult
5211131Adult
6211131Adult
7211131Adult
8211131Adult
9322342Adult
10322342Adult
11333352Adult
12333352Adult
13444464Adult
14444464Adult
15444464Adult
16444464Adult
17554464Hive Lord
18555575Hive Lord
19555575Hive Lord
20555575Hive Lord

​

The Kruthik is a monstrosity from Mordenkainen's Tome of Foes that becomes stronger as it ages. It was added to the table for comparison against the Wolf companion. The Young Kruthik has a CR of 1/8, the Adult Kruthik has a CR of 2, and the Hive Lord Kruthik has a Cr of 5.

​

It was unclear to me whether the Ranger's proficiency bonus is also added to the poison damage the Giant Poisonous Snake deals. To err on the side of caution, I left that damage out. If the Ranger's proficiency is also added to the poison damage, according to the rules as written, then the final CR of the Giant Poisonous Snake becomes 8 instead of 7.

​

For comparison, here is a table of creatures from the MM and MToF sorted by CR:

CRExample Creatures
1Brown bear, Dire Wolf, Tiger, Brass Dragon Wyrmling, Giant vulture, Bronze Scout
2Ankheg, Awakened Tree, Giant Boar, Giant Elk, Green Dragon Wyrmling, Pegasus, Polar Bear, Saber-Toothed Tiger, Adult Kruthik
3Basilisk, Blue Dragon Wyrmling, Giant Scorpion, Owlbear, Phase Spider, Winter Wolf
4Chuul, Couatl, Elephant, Red Dragon Wyrmling
5Bulette, Giant Crocodile, Otyugh, Unicorn, Kruthik Hive Lord
6Chimera, Mammoth, Wyvern, Young Brass or White Dragon
7Giant Ape, Young Black or Copper Dragon

​

Findings

Rangers' Companions are never as weak as their regular counterparts. As soon as you hit 3rd level and get your companion, it is no longer its original CR. A Wolf instantly shoots up to CR2, which is a deadly encounter for a single level 3 character.

​

The Giant Poisonous Snake is the clear winner in this table in terms of CR. It has high AC, and it has a substantial amount of extra damage over its competitors. Having a CR5 companion at level 20 seems to be the intended outcome of the Beastmaster's 3rd level feature, no matter which beast you start with. The Giant Poisonous Snake goes above and beyond that.

​

A single CR7 Giant Poisonous Snake is a medium encounter for a single level 20 Ranger.

​

Interesting to note is that in terms of the companion's scaling stats, the 3rd level feature "Ranger's Companion", has significant increases at levels 9, 13 and 17/18, that are 'hidden' to the player. They are never explicitly mentioned in the 3rd level feature.

​

The 11th level feature that allows the companion to attack twice, instead of once, has a smaller impact in terms of CR. In regards to the beasts picked for this table, it only increases the CR of the Giant Poisonous Snake.

​

Conclusions

Help me draw conclusions from this.

​

If you turn off the scaling with the Ranger's Proficiency bonus, would it be unreasonable to allow a Ranger to attune with an Owlbear at level 9? Would it be unreasonable to have a Unicorn companion at level 17? A Ranger's Wolf would be comparable to them both at those respective Ranger levels. Possibly stronger.

A CR3 Owlbear hits harder and has more hp, but a CR3 Wolf is much harder to hit and hits easier, and it has pack tactics.

​

Ranger's Companion is a stronger feature than I thought.

Posted May 3, 2019, 12:41 PM UTC

3820
WinterFFBE•

Help me draw conclusions from this.

​

The CR of creatures goes up when you give them more HP, AC, and damage? That's the only conclusion I draw here.

I definitely don't think that letting the Ranger bond with monstrosities and celestials is a good idea.

31
SliviusOPVampirate•

The CR of creatures definitely goes up with HP, AC, attack and damage rolls. Those four values are what CR is based on and calculated with. There are minor adjustments after that calculation, but in none of the provided cases were those adjustments large enough to influence the CR of the creature in question in a significant way.

​

I also provided examples of Beasts with similar CR to the CR's achieved by the provided companions in the table, not just celestials, dragons, monstrosities and constructs.

​

I am curious why you think letting the Ranger bond with a monstrosity is definitely a bad idea, though!

4
WinterFFBE•

I am curious why you think letting the Ranger bond with a monstrosity is definitely a bad idea, though!

There is no unifying attribute that unites monstrosities, thematic or otherwise; it is literally a catch-all for any creature that does not fit in another category. It features some creatures that are at least somewhat beast-like, but also features sentient beings that have no place being a ranger's companion.

I mean, seriously. Do doppelgangers, lamias, medusas, or sphinxes fit as ranger companions at all?

16
SliviusOPVampirate•

Ah, that makes a lot of sense, yes! Thank you. I thought you were talking from a mechanical perspective at first.

6
i_tyrant•

Mechanical issues abound as well, when you open Ranger to a creature type besides Beast - this is because one of beast's primary limitations is "no magical stuff", whereas just about every other creature type includes at least a few examples of monsters with at-will abilities that could be broken/abused in PC's hands.

Even just grabbing a rust monster as a companion could lead to insane shenanigans. Fight your way into the fire giant citadel? Why? Let's just have our little guy eat out the wall foundations. Carrion crawler mucus is listed as a poison in the DMG - if a ranger grabs one as a companion can they harvest basically infinite amounts of this? Paralysis is quite a bit more useful than the beast analogue (snake poison, which just does a bit of damage with a low DC). And so on.

5
CactusMeat•

dont rangers have to forgo one of their attacks for their beast to get an attack in?

shouldn't you compare ranger+beast to fighter or something? it's kind of hard to draw conclusions on your math when in reality nobody plays as a companion to a ranger and not also play the ranger.

10
SliviusOPVampirate•

That would be a Damage per Round calculation, which has been done plenty of times before.

​

I wanted to know how terrible these companions really are and how they measure up to other beasts and beast-like monstrosities, that are commonly seen as superior. As it turns out the companion's CR scales more than I thought it did, and the Giant Poisonous Snake in particular packs a punch.

My goal isn't to compare the Beastmaster to other classes, but instead to compare the companions to other monsters.

7
t0beyeusBard•

I think this is misleading. It ignores the damage that a CR5 creature does, the utility certain creatures features and it ignores the sheer number of enemies with immunity to Poison.

A Wolf Bites twice for 2d4+8 (13) + 2d4+8 (13) for 26 damage whereas a CR5 Giant Crocodile Multiattacks 3d10+5 (21) + 2d8+5 (14) for 35 damage.

Their HP is also slightly lower than the average of CR5 creatures with less utility and a lack of scaling to the DC of their utility. The Wolf's DC is 11 even at level 20. The Giant Crocodile's DC is 16.

10
SliviusOPVampirate•

I think they scale better than you think, at least in terms of stats. In terms of Utility, agree with you.

A Giant Crocodile has 85 hp and 14 AC. A Giant Crocodile has a +8 to hit.

A Wolf has 80 hp and 19 AC, and pack tactics. A Wolf has a +10 to hit, excluding pack tactics.

​

Sure, CR5 Wolves deal less damage and have a lower DC, but they hit easier and are harder to hit. Their difference in HP is only 5.

​

CR is calculated by taking the average of the Offensive CR and the Defensive CR of a creature. Offensive CR is a combination of a creature's to hit bonus and their average damage. Defensive CR is a combination of a creature's HP and AC.

​

They are both CR5 creatures, just with slightly different stats and specialisations.

​

I do think it would be nice if the ranger's proficiency would be added to the Wolf's DC.

I hadn't considered creatures that are immune to poison.

9
t0beyeusBard•

Giant Crocodile Restraining any enemy increases their AC due to the Disadvantage.

I am sure someone more "mathy" can compare effective damage of a Companion Wolf and Giant Crocodile. Since the higher to-hit does increase effective damage. But when your damage is based on the Companion since Extra Attack is not interchangeable it is important.

I am more curious to see a comparison of UA Ranger Companions to PHB Companions. Are they higher CR with ASIs and varying scaling HP? They also get scaling DC and better Saves.

6
albrecd•

"Someone more mathy" here: I have to agree with u/Slivius on this. I fiddled around with some numbers in Excel (viewable in my drive here if you're interested) and their damage output and defense seem to be pretty comparable.

​

Simulated for a combat of 5 rounds, I would expect the crocodile to deal about 12 damage more per round against an enemy with AC 10 -15, and the two output almost the same damage against enemies AC 16 - 20. Overall, the Croc deals an average of 6% more damage than the Wolf.

​

Advantage gives an average die roll bonus of 3.3, so imposing that on attacks gives the Croc an effective AC of 17 (vs the wolf's 19). This works out to the wolf having about a 10% higher AC.

​

Pretty similar, and definitely well within the range of two creatures of the same CR.

​

​

I had to make some assumptions to simplify this down - here are the big ones:

- I assumed that this would be a one on one fight between the croc/wolf and one other creature (adding allies / extra enemies scales the complexity super quickly). This still does assume that other creatures are around fighting each other for the purposes of things like pack tactics.

- I assumed that the wolf would have advantage right away (since you should generally be able to use pack tactics every turn), and the Croc has advantage after its first attack (due to the target becoming restrained by the first attack).

​

Edit: Clarified Assumptions

6
MissWhite11•

The game isn't balanced around damage types so the fact that poison is commonly resisted is irrelevant.

4
t0beyeusBard•

It most certainly is, look at HP and Resistances, look at HP and AC, look at spells damage types and average damage.

0
MissWhite11•

It certainly isn't as per the mouth of the creators of the game.

This is smoke and mirror analysis

4
default_entry•

No, no. It IS balanced around tiered damage types. The creators just won't admit it.

1
solidfang•

(As a foreword, anything can be reasonable provided the context of one's particular game and the DM that they run with. Trying to justify something to the DM via calculation is just rules lawyering.)

In any case, I suppose my concerns center around the owlbear being a large monster and that the unicorn having innate spellcasting and legendary actions. You are not necessarily incorrect in terms of DPS, but there are certain advantages like size that are hard to quantify. It may even be a disadvantage every time a ranger would have to describe how an owlbear moves in and out of structures with 5 ft. doors.

The unicorn having spellcasting and legendary actions are both unwieldy and never meant for a player to have power over. Spellcasting given to any minion of sorts is rather troublesome. For an example of that, see Conjure Woodland Beings as an abuse case where summoning pixies gives you way more utility than you probably ought to have.

6
FallenJkiller•

> Rangers' Companions are never as weak as their regular counterparts. As soon as you hit 3rd level and get your companion, it is no longer its original CR. A Wolf instantly shoots up to CR2, which is a deadly encounter for a single level 3 character.

Yes, however, it cant deal its full damage, unless you lose your attack. This is the main drawback.

> would it be unreasonable to allow a Ranger to attune with an Owlbear at level 9?

Yes. Id let him attune to some other beast though, but not monstrosities or celestials.

4
Jofman•

I think it would be cool to allow other creatures with an equal CR as you described. It's probably easiest to limit these upgrades to the Beastmaster class features at levels 3, 7, 11, and 15. I think looking at these numbers the companion CR should be around 2, 3, 4, and 5 respectively.

Important to note however that the companion upgrades like added proficiency bonus to AC, attacks, etc. are what makes these creatures a higher CR, so if you're allowing a new creature like an adult Kruthik that is already CR2, it should not receive these extra bonuses. I've always been a fan of allowing monstrosities as companions though, it gives that real 'beast tamer' feel and makes the ranger stand out (anyone can have a beast pet).

Alternatively, I think another way to give the beast companions an extra boost is to allow the normal beast creatures an extra feature at these levels, similar to how it already gets the extra attack or bonus action dash etc. You could allow the ranger to choose from a list of features that also appear in creatures of a similar CR. For example, after the beast reaches CR3 at roughly ranger level 7, you could allow it to gain the breath weapon feature from the CR3 Winter Wolf. I don't think this will be a major power boost since it replaces the normal attack action, it just gives the beast & ranger more options to work with.

I think these more stepwise upgrades to your beast (as opposed to increasing HP and attack each level) will give a sense of raising and evolving your pet, making the ranger more invested in the bond between them.

3