[Spoilers] What Bran said to Jon Snow

SpoilerSpoilers

During the Stark family meeting when Jon looks at Bran for approval to reveal his family secret, Bran says 'It's your choice'

Maybe I'm reading too much into it, but doesn't this imply that whatever happens it will lead to the same 'end'?

All of this meaning, that whatever revealing the secret will cause, the final event is not influenced by it directly?

Posted May 6, 2019, 3:55 AM UTC

218
UnwellHiC•

Maybe I'm reading too much into it

yes

If Bran's role is to be a neutral observer, he don't care which path history goes

7
diasasis•

Bran doesn't do shit. Nothing Bran does has any effect on anything anymore.

5
Coconutfanatic:Gendry: Gendry•

To my knowledge, Bran cant see the future in the show right? If thats the case then he was just giving Jon the option, not making him feel obligated to tell others that info.

2
Runningman0301:Targaryen: Fire And Blood•

he can. jojen reed who also had the greensight, saw his own death.

1
Trueslyforaniceguy:Sansa_Stark: Sansa Stark•

This pivot to the Mad Queen of Ashes is where I feared we would end up. The three headed dragon is Jon, Sansa, Arya. The lone wolf dies, Dany, sorry.

Cersei is killed by Jamie while unleashing wildfire, he took too long this time round.

Sandor kills the Mountain after the Mountain takes out another spearman, Grey Worm.

What’s the final twist? His choice to kill Dany

2
TheCrowRunsFastOP:Targaryen: Daenerys Targaryen•

I think that’s a reason why people hate it. It’s basically a subtle spoiler for what will happen.

Some minor changes or surprises may happen but overall, the way you wrote it is the most likely way it will end.

It’s a shitty ending for an otherwise great show.

Meh

1
AutoModeratorMODNow My Watch Begins•

Spoiler Warning: All officially-released show and book content allowed, including trailers and pre-released chapters. No leaked information or paparazzi photos of the set. For more info please check the spoiler guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
jenkag•

I took it to mean more that Bran isn't going to reveal it. It's Jon's choice where he takes his future, and Bran won't intervene either way.

1
yagirlisweak:Tyrion_Lannister: Tyrion Lannister•

It’s his choice whether he’ll reveal it to them or not since he maybe saw in his vision that dany doesnt want anyone to known it

1
angermngment•

Destiny is real. Whatever he decides won't change the fact that he's the rightful king. Bran maybe was saying, either you betray the family or you betray Dany. He chose to betray Dany by telling them.

1

the final event

It could mean that none of the final events that Bran cares about would be affected.

Perhaps Bran knows that he has already set plans in motion that will make Jon king. Whether Jon has Dany as his queen or anyone else is irrelevant in 3ER's opinion.

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
jlynn00:Mormont: House Mormont•

I think this is Bran knowing that Jon had a choice between selling out a part of his position within his Stark family by keeping a part of himself secret, and placing Dany's claim over every single thing. It was literally choosing Stark versus Dany.

1
Chao_Zu_Kang•

If Bran isn't active, that means there is no reason for hin to be. The TEF won't actively meddle unless he aims for something (e.g. Arya's dagger).

1
Runningman0301:Targaryen: Fire And Blood•

why was he there at a private stark family meeting then. if hes not bran

1
Chao_Zu_Kang•

Why not? They still consider him family and he also has no reason to refuse being there. He became the 3ER, not the 3ER taking over his mind and deleting Bran's identity (though he arguably is a different Bran now).

1
Runningman0301:Targaryen: Fire And Blood•

He’s said repeatedly though “ I’m not Bran anymore”

1
Chao_Zu_Kang•

Anymore. Meaning at some point he actually was Bran and also has memories of being Bran - because he is Bran, a different Bran, a 3ER Bran. But that's also just him, not them. If 3ER Bran would say "sorry, I am not your family, so I will just leave and totally not know what you are talking about" then he might not be included anymore, but that would be so out of character, I can't even imagine.

1