Ben Leber just went full antivax on Power Trip this morning
[removed]
Posted May 6, 2019, 2:21 PM UTC · edited · locked
[removed]
Posted May 6, 2019, 2:21 PM UTC · edited · locked
Preventable diseases that are making a comeback because of anti-vaxxers don’t have to be a part of life. Vaccines can eradicate these diseases you fucking dolt. Fuck you Leber you’re what’s wrong with society
[removed]
He's able to voice his opinion and make his own decisions. Forcing injections onto unwilling people sounds like something Germany would do in the WWII era.
Forced vaccination should be mandatory (except medical reasons) as it affects more than the person denying the vaccination. Your personal freedoms end when it inhibits other's freedoms.
Where does he say he's advocating forced vaccinations? All he's doing is calling Ben Leber a fucking idiot, because Ben Leber is a fucking idiot.
Vaccinate yourself and vaccinate your kids. If you don't, you're a steaming pile of shit complicit in the spread of easily preventable deadly diseases.
lol no it doesn’t you moron. Fining people that don’t get potentially life saving vaccines is a little different than systematically exterminating a race of people
And not doing so means innocent kids contract disease and maybe die. Some kids literally can't be vaccinated and depend on herd immunity for their health. The fewer people that are vaccinated, the more risk they face. This is child endangerment at best and, imo, a tort or manslaughter at worst if your kid gives another kid the measles when it was completely preventable on your part.
Just noticed he has a charity event for a children's hospital coming up. Yikes.
The hospital should stop him from coming.
It would be reckless to bring someone who is capable of spreading measles around the most vulnerable.
Especially concerning since as such a visible person in the community, he likely encounters many more people than an average person, in a state where measles are present. Just bad news all around.
Hate to say it, but the government needs to introduce some consequences for people that don't vaccinate. If you don't do it you'll have to pay fines. Every single year until you get them. Want to put other people at risk? Gotta pay for the privilege.
You're 100% right, and as for right now, where it takes time to implement laws and punishments, it is a social responsibility to vaccinate.
I’ll be voicing myself to the show. He absolutely has to be punished.
That’s almost as ridiculous of a decision than becoming an anti-vaxxer
If he influences at least one person to avoid getting a vaccination it's a problem. It's inexcusable that measles outbreaks are on the rise again when there is a vaccine that can prevent it.
Man, what? This is an insane statement. Making someone take back their comments on air is AS BAD as not wanting to vaccinate because you’re a complete moron?
What? Look, it's one thing if its his personal opinion but broadcasting that shit in public is incredibly irresponsible and is quite literally a public health issue. It's entirely legitimate to force him to explain how ignorant what he said was the next time he's on the show, or not have him back if he refuses.
Should treat it like smoking cigarettes for health care plans. Be an idiot an dont vaccinate, pay more for your insurance.
Government forced vaccinations? That sounds scary. Do you really trust the government and big pharma not to abuse their power? My body, my choice.
You know what else sounds scary? Your child is allergic to the measles vaccine and is unable to vaccinate, and there is a recent outbreak of measles in your area.
This is not “my body, my choice”. People die as a result of others around them not vaccinating.
I'm not talking about forcing people though. Not getting vaccinated and paying the fine is a choice anyone could make. They can even scale the fine so it's based on income so poor people don't get screwed. Oh, and the money would go to hospitals and the healthcare industry, nowhere else.
What happens if they don't pay the fine? Should they be locked up in a private prison because they didn't get an injection from a private company (big pharma).
There's plenty to dislike about big pharma, but vaccines is not one of those reasons. And yes, avoid paying the fines long enough and jail time is a possibility. Just like it's a possibility if people don't pay their taxes. As a matter of fact, let's not call it a fine, let's call it a health tax.
Garnish wages or tax returns. I'm a libertarian, but I'm also against the slippery slope argument.
What happens if you don't pay your taxes? Same kind of deal, they could garnish your wages or something else.
Thousands of people dying from preventable diseases sounds scary also. Most of which have been eradicated but are making a comeback because of people like you. How fucking dumb can you be?
It's not as simple as my body, my choice. It's other people's well being you're affecting. And yes we should be able to trust our government to create laws requiring people to do things that effect others to the point of life and death. Whether or not we can trust our government to do that is a separate issue.
I have an honest question: if people choose to get a vaccination for whatever disease why would it matter if someone else decides to not be vaccinated? Wouldn’t those who are vaccinated be protected from the unvaccinated?
Because a lot of young children are unable to get vaccinated at young ages. For example my 2 year old is not old enough to get a number of vaccines and if you choose not to get vaccines and then get sick with something then there is a high risk for a lot of younger children.
This is the right answer.
Source: had measles at 10 months old.
To my knowledge, at 10 months, the only vaccines you may not have yet are things which won’t kill you (aka measles , chicken pocks, etc). Measles doesn’t kill healthy children.
So what, we should just let the children that aren't healthy and can suffer lethal complications from measles die? From other comments in this thread you don't seem to get the concept that there are people that cannot get vaccines for specific medical reasons, and they're the people who get screwed when healthy but ignorant people think their choice about vaccination has no consequence.
Yipee I didn't die. That doesn't mean it was good for me or my parents. I do have lasting effects that will stay with me my entire life (admittedly minor). But there are much worse outcomes than mine, including death.
Why should people have to suffer because others are too stupid to trust scientists and doctors over Facebook and mommy blogs?
We can’t just frame it by “children killed.” That doesn’t do the public health benefits of not having children afflicted with measles. It’s an awful disease, and when children get sick their parents do too.
People with suppressed immune systems need us to get vaccinated. Kids need everyone to get vaccinated. Babies who can’t get shots need everyone to get vaccinated. People who are allergic to vaccine components need everyone to get vaccinated. We shouldn’t trivialize these terrible communicable diseases.
Ok, that makes sense. Thanks!
[deleted]
[deleted]
Herd immunity. It’s pretty simple, having a higher percentage of the population vaccinated provides protection to the immunocompromised population like young children, cancer patients, etc. Not getting vaccinated based off of frankly very misleading and unsubstantiated evidence/assumptions puts those people at far greater risk. Insane how after miraculously keeping so many devastating diseases at bay (which are in no way extinct), we just willingly let our guard down
Because it can spread to other people, and that's people who may die, so that's definitely not good. I'm not a scientist or any type or expert on this stuff but I also think that if there's an epidemic then it can evolve and then the vaccines have to get changed for the new type and then it gets worse and worse, but I don't really know.
Oh and you can still get it if you're vaccinated, it's just rare, this source says that 97% of people who are vaccinated will not get it, so 3% will/can.
Vaccines are not 100% preventative for one. Takd the flu shot, it only covers a certain strand, but you can still get the flu. However, the vaccines do mitigate the disease if you happen to get it.
The other bit is there are plenty of people, particularly infants, who cannot receive vaccines for various reasons, and you risk infecting them
Fuck Ben leber, I don’t want him reporting on the sidelines if he’s gonna be spouting this unmitigated horseshit. Let’s see what greenway or Robison are up to
Atleast he isn’t Matt Birk who is outspoken against gay marriage.
"Real shame, I’ve always really liked Leber."
You can still like him. He seems like a good person.
Aside from the whole, "if my kids die, they die" thing, then sure. Stand up guy.
I just edited the post with the clip. I recommend you listen to it, and see if you still have the same opinion. The dude is okay with spreading measles to others.
Yeah I don’t get the culture of hating someone for this type of thing. Yes, it’s 100% dumb and irresponsible and dangerous but you can still like the guy.
I won’t stop others, but personally I can’t. If you’re antivax, I’m out.
Its the willful disregard for other peoples safety that makes him not respectable.
Understandable. I’m simply trying to illustrate my point of view that he’s not all the sudden worthless despite an unquestionably reckless choice. Much worse people have been liked. The question is where do you draw the line between liking someone and respecting someone? Idk. No one here knows him.
He's willingly and knowingly putting others in danger. Unless he has a legitimate reason not to get one, he's lost some respect
He lost my respect for sure. I’m not trying to defend him whatsoever.
By being anti-vax, he's contributing to the spread of disease. It's ridiculous not to let that sway your opinion of him. Yeah, he seems nice, but he's also advocating for something that is extremely dangerous. That's absolutely not ok. It's not just a stupid opinion. His opinions hurt and kill people.
It definitely sways my opinion of him. I never said that it didn’t. I lost respect for him for sure I alluded to that in my original comment. I just meant to say he’s not all the sudden drained of all value as a human being because of an extremely stupid decision. I’m not defending him.
I understand all of the sentiments expressed here. You lost respect for guy because of his choice to do/not do something that can put others in danger. I wonder what your feelings are towards people who drink alcohol, a substance that literally makes your decision making suspect. Willingly and knowingly drinking alcohol puts yourself and others in danger.
Being stupid is one thing but when your stupidity endangers others, that's unacceptable
It is unacceptable for sure. I’m not on his side whatsoever.
[removed]
Had to lock it. Way too nasty in here. Don't care to police the fighting. But up/down vote away and I'm certainly not taking it down.
Come on. He just said hes not going back to get it again just because hes past the cutoff. Im pretty sure his kids are vaccinated.
I didn't listen. There is a good chance he got the MMR and he's vaccinated. There is a push for revaccinating which is mostly a money grab.
I got the MMR vaccine as a child, I as well would hesitate to vaccinate again for funsizes.
There is a push for revaccinating which is mostly a money grab.
It may be a money grab, but you can definitely lose immunity over time. People react differently to vaccines, and it's good to get a regular blood test during your annual physical to make sure you're still covered.
His reasoning did not at all reflect that opinion, though. He thinks he won’t get measles because he hasn’t gotten it yet and he’s a tough guy.
Right because a person refuses one vaccine makes them antivax. Stupid.
So these companies have shown to be about profit above all, Opioid crisis (https://www.vox.com/future-perfect/2019/1/25/18188542/opioid-epidemic-marketing-overdose-death-purdue), Selling drugs infected with HIV overseas because we told them they cant sell them here (https://www.cbsnews.com/news/bayer-sold-hiv-risky-meds/), and overall shadyness accross the board (https://www.businessinsider.com/pharmaceutical-company-reputation-rankings-2018-6#21-glaxosmithkline-reptrak-points-574-2). But when it comes to vaccines we should shut the fuck up and take them all?
Full disclosure - me and my son are full vaccinated with an extended schedule, but this new MMR and other vaccines are being pushed as they are 100% safe and they most assuredly are not.
Big Pharma is immune to any lawsuit that is filed against it that has anything to do with vaccines, we the taxpayers pay out for anyone who gets injured due to them. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Vaccine_Injury_Compensation_Program
this new MMR and other vaccines are being pushed as they are 100% safe and they most assuredly are not.
Got a source for that? Asking sincerely, I'd like to read it!
I'm not the OP but nothing is 100% safe. Even something as safe as tylenol has a long list of side effects.
Fucking water and oxygen can cause cancer. Just because something can have negative consequences doesn't mean they are 100% bad.
No but when your told there are no long term bad effects and their actually is, thats bullshit.
Yeah, I hear ya. I just wanted to see what the issue(s) is with the new MMR vaccine.
Tylenol would never be approved if it were going through the FDA now. It can be outrageously toxic at doses around 10-20x higher than the recommended dose, where most modern medicines have a much higher threshold for toxicity. 10x the recommended dose is something that's easily achievable by accident or by irresponsible use.
People sometimes confuse "We've been using it forever" for "it's safe", and that couldn't be further from the truth.
From a FOIA request - page 25 is where they start listing adverse affects: https://childrenshealthdefense.org/wp-content/uploads/FDA-Relied-Upon-STUDIES-LICENSING-MMR-VACCINE-FOIA.pdf
Yeah the website is questionable but the FOIA doc is real.
Thank you!!
Nothing is ever 100% safe, but I'd rather risk some side effects than be infected with what should be an eradicated disease which is potentially fatal. Medicine has side effects, but you still take Tylenol when you have a splitting headache.
But tylenol lists out what the adverse effects are with every bottle, same with every other medicine out there, have you ever been offered the vaccine insert so you can be aware of what they are?
I mean yeah, the only side effects is usually swelling and stiffness in the injection site, as well not 100% preventability. In general, vaccines are extremely safe because what's being injected is a dead pathogen, and the solution which contains that is also harmless, unless if you are allergic. And they tell you all of this when you get a shot for the first time, or whenever it is a new type of vaccine
Did you read the list?
62 of 102 suffered from an upper respiratory illness
42 of 102 suffered from gastro intestinal illness
11 of 102 suffered a Measles like rash
This is from the FDA themselves....
I should also state that my first reply is also addressing the supposed side effects that many anti-vaxxers claim exist. So if vaccines really did cause autism, I'd rather have that than be dead
Measles is not a for sure killer, just like the flu is not instant death.
Many people including both my parents caught measles and survived. In fact the latest numbers are showing that is pretty survivable.
Here is the CDC slideshow on it https://www.cdc.gov/measles/downloads/measlesdataandstatsslideset.pdf
So question for you - are you willing to have a 50% chance of upper respiratory illness just to save yourself from something that has a 1 in 1000 chance to kill you?
National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program
The Office of Special Masters of the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, popularly known as "vaccine court", administers a no-fault system for litigating vaccine injury claims. These claims against vaccine manufacturers cannot normally be filed in state or federal civil courts, but instead must be heard in the U.S. Court of Federal Claims, sitting without a jury.
The National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP or NVICP) was established by the 1986 National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act (NCVIA), passed by the United States Congress in response to a threat to the vaccine supply due to a 1980s scare over the DPT vaccine. Despite the belief of most public health officials that claims of side effects were unfounded, large jury awards had been given to some plaintiffs, most DPT vaccine makers had ceased production, and officials feared the loss of herd immunity.No evidence has been found to support a link between autism spectrum disorders and vaccines, and the scientific consensus is that routine childhood vaccines have no link to the development of autism.
^[ ^PM ^| ^Exclude ^me ^| ^Exclude ^from ^subreddit ^| ^FAQ ^/ ^Information ^| ^Source ^] ^Downvote ^to ^remove ^| ^v0.28
who gives a shit, its his life and his choice.
Until he gets people sick
[deleted]
If vaccines work so well why do you need everyone else to get them? Vaccinate yourself abs move on with you business.
[deleted]
You’re acting like vaccinated diseases all kill you with 100% certainty and that’s certainly not the case. You know no more science on the matter than someone on the other side, thus it’s hilarious you paint yourself to be an expert. You’re talking about a small minority of the population. Also, yes people should have a choice what they put in their bodies including vaccines. Death rates for diseases with or without vaccines are extremely low in rich countries like ours. Do you think we should ban peanuts too? People are allergic and can die from those.
Holy shit you are dumb hahaha
Sure, resort to personally attacking.
Because we need to maintain herd immunity in order to protect those who aren't able to get vaccinated, such as infants, those allergic to the vaccine, and the immuno compromised. Right now, more and more dumbasses like Leber aren't vaccinating themselves or their kids, so herd immunity is weaker and therefore easily preventable deadly diseases are making a comeback and spreading.
It's no longer "my body, my choice" when your choice is killing people.
Measles isn’t a deadly disease. https://physiciansforinformedconsent.org/measles/dis/
Some people would really like to but can't due to medical concerns. They depend on herd immunity for their health. Anti-vaxxers destroy herd immunity and endanger these people in addition to themselves and their children who can't make their own health decisions.
Measles doesn’t kill you.
ahhh so you have a problem with private schools too?
[deleted]
Brainlet
Just lost a ton of respect for Leber.
Same.