3rd Season and Cancellation

I’m a huge fan of the show, probably it is in my Top 20 shows ever.

But there are some things I noticed in the 3rd season that make me wonder if Netflix was already applying pressure to SCD producers as when the 3rd season was approved.

In the first two seasons the writing was very character-driven. It examined a family in a suburban rut and placed in an extraordinary circumstance. What if a group of people who were slaves to modern decorum suddenly had to deal with someone who would only listen to her Id.

These two seasons investigated how Sheila’s transformation affected Joel as he tried to hold onto normalcy. It investigated family dynamics.

The emphasis was always on the humanistic effect the crazy (and hilarious) events had on the characters.

In the 3rd season I saw a dramatic shift away from this type of writing towards a plot-driven narrative. Plot-driven is so much easier to write because nothing has to sync up with the characters’ beliefs or motives. You simply invent crazy situations and riff comedic actions and responses as a result.

I believe the writing staff had been reduced both in quantity and quality. I believe they did that because Netflix cut the budget going into the 3rd season.

The production values were reduced as well. There have been threads on here discussing the almost comically poor voiceover-dubbing that are present in the third season.

I think this show was forced to proceed in a low-budget environment, and quality suffered.

I wouldn’t be surprised (based on Victor Frescos reaction to the cancellation) that he was perhaps offered a chance to continue at a further reduced budget to ensure profitability for Netflix. I also feel that he would not want to push a show further forward if it meant quantity would be reduced further.

Most people don’t really notice or care whether a show like this investigated deep humanistic thematic issues. But it was the ability to do that for the first two seasons that really made this truly great show.

Posted May 6, 2019, 9:41 PM UTC

237
Dragonite7000•

I agree that the show changed focus in the last season, but what makes you think the writing wasn't as good?

7
CorrectWolverineOP•

Many things, pretty much summed up by my belief the show shifted from character-driven to plot-driven. Or even circumstance-driven.

Anne exits very abruptly because of other acting commitments. There was no believable reason for her character to want to leave. It was slapped in as a plot point so she could go.

Zach Knighton’s whole build up as the knight of Serbia is cut off and replaced by Ethan Supplee because Zach too had other commitments. The nuanced relationship between Zach and his wife as they hunted Sheila is replaced by a very heavy-handed and broad approach by his brother.

Sheila has no reason to be volunteering her time to the old lady shut-in. And it made ZERO sense to turn her.

While strategically it makes some sense for Joel to be a Knight if Serbia, it does not fit with his character. So they had to make his audition tape extremely farcical. It was like watching Benny Hill.

Listen in the background while dialogue is being spoken in Season 3. Oftentimes there is tone-setting background music happening. This is what you do when the writing isn’t clear or strong enough to properly set a tone. It never happens in Seasons one or two.

Speaking of music, there are at least three incredible music-scenes in Season 1:

When Sheila & Joel attack Loki in his apartment.

When Abby tear gasses the pot dealer.

When Sheila starts biting Joel while they are in bed.

Watch them. They are AWESOME scenes. They are also expensive to produce. We lose these types of scenes bySeason 2.

They very rarely shoot on-location scenes in Season 3. This is expensive. They are almost always on set by Season 3. Compare this to how many times they are on location in Season 1.

Money was an issue.

There are literally hundreds of little things that we could go through point-by-point.

3
Dragonite7000•

Totally agree with the amazing music scenes. For sure. I actually @'d Victor Fresco about the reduction of those in s2. I think working an actor's departure into the script is a difficult thing to do and doesn't have so much to do with budget but is circumstantial, and they've done a fine enough job anyway. I did really like the zombie hunting couple, and I was disappointed to not be able to see more of them, but again, not really a quality or budget issue, and I actually came to really like Tommy. The reason Sheila was volunteering to help Joan, the old lady, was for a reason that Joan herself stated, that she helps some old lady a couple times a week and then doesn't have to feel bad about what she does the rest of the time. I thought it was interesting.

Could you go into more detail about why you thought Joel becoming a knight of Serbia was out of character?

Interesting about the music being used to set the tone to make up for worse writing. What about the writing specifically did you feel failed to set the tone properly?

I didn't really notice the on location vs set difference. I'm not denying that they had a lower budget in season 3, however, and I fail to see how a lower budget is the same as worse writing. Having to film more on set isn't a sign of bad writing.

Again, my argument against your post lies not with my disbelief that season 3 had a lower budget, but that it had worse writing. We don't need to go point by point through all the indications of budget cuts.

3
Dragonite7000•

Hm.

1
Skyblacker•

I agree that the plot ran thin in the third season, but disagree that it was due to budget. When I last binged the series, I noticed that Eric and Abby's relationship in season 2 repeated some themes from Joel and Sheila in season on. And Anne's plot arc is simply the inverse of Dan's.

I think the creative well began to go dry. There's only so much you can do with that premise. And as much as I'd enjoy an undead Joel, how could he be significantly different than everyone else who turned? Been there, done that.

1
Dragonite7000•

How different?!!

1
[deleted]•

[removed]

1