If Big 5 countries had to compete in the semis ...

Okay so i was just wondering if the big 5 had to compete in the semis from 2016 to 2018 ( nice and precise range ) would they have qualified

Just personal opinions based on overall comparison to other songs in that year in finals, share what you think in comments its something i find very interesting to think about

2016 Spain - yes but barely France - yes Germany - no Uk - no but close Italy - yes

2017 Spain - no France - yes Germany - no Uk - yes Italy - yes

2018 Spain - yes but barely France - yes Germany - yes Uk - no Italy - yes

Ik we havent had the staging for the big 5 for this year yet but based on song and singer

Spain - yes France - yes Germany - no Uk - no but close Italy - yes

What do you guys think