r/fatlogic•
BreakingAM

I was thinking about this, I'd love to hear your thoughts.

REMOVED
I was thinking about this, I'd love to hear your thoughts.

Posted May 10, 2019, 7:01 PM UTC

2225
NaiveScientist0•

For a lot of children I imagine it's a huge problem as they're always being fed lazy low nutrient food by parents, and when growing up, you wamt easy food that's often high carb like frozen pizza, ready meals. But personally, I love to cook, and I spent a while at home cooking stupidly unhealthy stuff because thats exactly what I wanted to eat. I now cook healthier, lower calories stuff, but my gosh I'd love to copy some of those Buzzfeed Tasty videos where every layer of food has a stack of american slice cheese and is deep fried at the end.

16
Neurotica_XOXO•

A sandwich or baked beans and toast is just as easy as frozen pizza.

5
[deleted]•

[deleted]

5
notnotaginger•

Yuuummm...bag bread.

2
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
river-running•

Inability, absolutely. Especially for urban, low income people. Let's say you live in a food desert and don't have a car. Then say you work two jobs and have a couple kids. Maybe you're a single parent. Not an uncommon situation by any means. Your ability to leave your neighborhood and go to where the grocery stores are is limited (you have to take the bus and only buy what you can carry back on the bus. Maybe get a ride from a friend with a car, but that's hardly reliable), your time to do so is limited (especially if you work odd shifts), and your funds are limited. Then you actually have to cook what you bought, and maybe no one ever taught you how to cook in a healthy way. Maybe your parents grew up in the same circumstances in the same neighborhood and no one taught them, so they didn't pass it on to you. And if you've only got a few hours between shift #1 and shift #2, do you want to spend that precious time cooking or sleeping? Speaking as someone who grew up low income with a single parent, being in that strata of society for a few decades makes you incredibly tired.

But what is in your neighborhood is McDonald's, KFC, convenience stores, etc. You can walk to those, some of them are open 24 hours, you can feed yourself and your kids quickly and relatively cheaply. The allure, and in some ways the short term logic, in undeniable. A lot of the rhetoric spouted by people in the clean eating movement is coming from white middle class people with the time, money, and ability to get their hands on healthy food. They're not wrong, but they need to realize how much of their advice is not relevant to large segments of society.

On the other side of the scale (pun not intended, but I'm leaving it there), most of the "famous" fat people we see here all the time (the Instagram folks, the fat activists, etc) are also middle class or higher. Their pride in being fat doesn't represent the much larger segment of the population that would love to be healthy, were multiple crushing forces not working against them.

For some people, obesity is absolutely a choice, but for others, it's a tragic consequence of the society we live in. These people often spend their entire lives between a rock and a hard place, with no wiggle room. If you want to eliminate or just reduce the health effects of poverty, changes need to be made in economics, education, job training, city planning, transportation, etc. It's not as easy as telling people what they should or shouldn't be doing.

14
Neurotica_XOXO•

I travel for work on the weekends. Finding healthier options is hard but not impossible. Like choosing subway or Tim Hortons over Mcdonalds. Lots of convenience stores, drug stores, and cafes have sections with premade sandwiches, fruit cups and salads.

1
quirkyknitgirlF 5'2" SW 162 CW 145 GW 115•

That really varies a lot on where you lived. When I lived in Oakland, CA (one of the nicer parts, but not like, the rich people hills part) the convenience stores definitely had a much poorer selection of food than they did when I lived in wealthier (and generally whiter) places.

3
Neurotica_XOXO•

That's true, but not all cheap prepackaged food is equally unhealthy. Like canned soups and whatnot.

1
river-running•

True, options are usually there in some form, although fewer of them and often higher prices. The problem here is that you need to be in the right frame of mind to make the choice between the McDonald's and the prepackaged salad. And that mindset is not universal.

On the simple end of that argument, I draw your attention back to the hypothetical overworked single parent I mentioned. Again, I speak from experience as the now grown child of just such a person. As my father later told me, the pressure when you're in that situation to just give your child whatever will make them shut up and let you get some sleep or some quiet time is phenomenal. A lot of parents who don't see their kids much also think that food = love, and so give in to demands out of guilt. In both these situations, kids aren't going to want salad.

I used to live in a very impoverished urban area and noticed how common it was for parents to send their older kids (12 or 13) out with cash, and often with their younger siblings in tow, to get dinner. Again, the parent(s) wants a few minutes alone and the kids have free reign and cash in hand. Healthy food is probably not happening.

On the more complex end, there's a lot of psychological and neurological work coming out now about how poverty (especially intergenerational poverty) and chronic stress literally changes the brain. Add to that the fact that a lot of these folks have never had a single lesson about nutrition, lack of time, money, and mobility, and all the other factors working against them, and you have people who are often not equipped to step back, view their situation reasonably, and work out the pros and cons of what they're doing.

Someone once floated the argument to me that poor people often have a lot of kids because being poor sucks and sex is fun (and free). Add in a lack of access to or education about birth control, and you end up with a lot of kids. Sociologists might take issue with that argument, but a similar one can be made with food. Being poor sucks and french fries are really good (and pretty cheap). Again, you're not in a mindset to think critically about nutrition when the bills are piling up, your job(s) sucks, maybe your SO is being an asshole this week, your kids won't stop bugging you for stuff you can't afford, and you just want a few minutes of happiness. Pop down to the golden arches, the kids are happy (and quiet), and for a little while, so are you. It gets addictive (and thus normal) pretty fast.

At the end of the day, I'm not a psychologist, sociologist, neurologist, or dietician. I'm just someone trying to get into the healthcare field who, because of my own background, is passionate about the public health issues surrounding low income communities.

1
ScarletHarley*I'm gonna make you some logic you can't refute*•

I would imagine that those things play a big part in it! But also I'd suggest the additional factor that a LOT of people just really don't want to stop eating the things they do, at the volume and frequency they do; thus any excuse is up for grabs.

For example:

"It's too expensive! Organic goji berries are SOOOO pricey compared to french fries!"

Or-

"It's not HEALTHY to spend such an amount of time looking for recipes and comparing prices [😏🤔 massive eyeroll], that's AS OBSESSIVE AS ANOREXIA!"

Or-

"It's akin to genocide [wish I was kidding] to deny your body anything it craves, IT KNOWS WHAT YOU NEED!"

"LOVE YOURSELF!"

...

It's obvious that these people have access to the internet, and how much time they spend writing angry manifestoes and finding search results to echo what they already have decided to go with...

There are hundreds of millions of cooking tutorials, recipes for literally ANY criteria you want, and proper medical journals/verified research on the internet.

13
sarajane82•

Yeah, with all the premade food items around these days and pretty reasonable prices, especially when compared to eating out, there really are no excuses left. You can have convenience and health at a decent price if you are just willing to change what you eat and stop over eating.

1
Kelly_reads_too_much•

I didn’t do formal research on this, but I remember hearing that the fast food industry blew up when more and more women started going to work and didn’t have time to make those elaborately home-cooked meals anymore. I think the claim was based on only correlation, but it makes sense.

9
chocolateoatcakeMaintaining: 156cm/48kg•

That's also when a lot of people got richer and we able to buy more decadent food and eat out more often.

5
dogus829•

Well, I know a lot of people who cook somehow even worse foods (in terms of health, not taste) than mcdonalds . They make frries, burgers with shit ton of oil and bake everything with exccesive amount of sugar. Cooking itself is not the solution in my opinion, Cooking in a healthy way (with not to much oil and sugar) and buying healthy foods in the first place is the solution but most people who cook dont do. It is still all about choices people make on daily basis that keep them from getting to healthy body weight.

9
thrownawayforsureeesoon-to-be Skinny Bitch™ (SW: 195 | CW: 150 | GW: 120)•

A fair amount, for sure! But I also think unwillingness or inability to vary your palate plays a huge role, or unwillingness or inability to portion control. I think all those 3 are rolled into it, because surely we wouldn't be seeing this boom of obesity if hyper-palatable foods weren't available both in restaurants and in grocery stores.

Between people liking "simple, good tasting food" (ie: carbs and fats and sugars) and not knowing how to control portions at the dinner table or at a restaurant table (where, admittedly, portions are stupidly big), I feel like there are a LOT of factors conspiring against the general population having healthy weights :(

edit: spelling

6
Neurotica_XOXO•

When I was 15 my mom worked late and I decided to become a vegetarian.

I lived on microwaved alphagetti and cola.

Didn't get fat but I almost died of malnutrition.

​

I still don't cook, but manage to eat healthy. There's lots of healthy foods that are simple to make.

4
AnonymocosoStart blood glucose 100 current blood glucose 90 goal BG ??•
3
sarajane82•

That is so interesting! I was just thinking about this the other day (like could I lose weight eating only fast food places....??) when I got a chicken sandwich at a fast food place. I chose it because it had a much lower calorie content than the other options on the menu. I opt for small fries and water or diet soda. This is what I do when I want to fit in a fast food meal and not go over my calories for the day.On the flip side, if I want to make say beef fajitas for my family's dinner I have to be super careful to or I can easily end up with an 800 calorie meal because of the tortillas, beef, cheese and other toppings. So my home made meal with healthy options like avocado can easily make me go over my calories for the day.It really boils down to math! Stay in your calorie range, exercise, get sleep, drink water. Those are the basics and they are working well for me.
I don't plan on ever doing an all fast food diet as it doesn't make me feel nice, and really that is expensive. But it just fascinates me how it really does boil down to our choices and just paying attention to how much we are really eating.

3
brute111338M 5'10" SW: 230 / CW: 220 / GW: 190•

Absolutely, CICO can easily work with fast food, especially now that most major chains have nutrition information posted on the menu or at least available.

The problem still remains that the food is not particularly filling per calorie. I can put away way too much Taco Bell for the same fullness as a healthy meal i make myself, and if you're not counting calories you don't realize it, and even if you are, you might just say "screw it I'm hungry" anyway. My self-control is inversely proportional to my hunger and exhaustion levels.

5
sarajane82•

For sure, I used to just eat whatever and not pay attention to what was in it. It was shocking at first when I began looking at the calorie counts but now that I do I make better choices.

1
sarajane82•

I do not think that is the issue really. You can cook everything and still get fat. In fact I first began gaining my first year of marriage. I had lost my job and cooked everything from scratch as we didnt have much money. Before that I ate out nearly every meal and was fit and thin. A lack of movement and more time in my hands to eat from sheer boredom. That was what got me.

3
Kaleandra•

Convenience is a big factor, for sure. Also, fast food is designed to keep us craving more and more of it.

Getting healthy required me to learn how to make healthy food myself. I'm still learning, but at least I can make basic stuff like steak now.

3
[deleted]•

[deleted]

2
rialed•

Part of the problem is that people have gotten used to the taste of low quality, highly processed foods with all the additives. They don’t actually know what good food tastes like anymore.

McDonalds has crappy hamburgers and disgusting fries. I enjoy it but it doesn’t taste like a real burger or decent fries.

1
TheRealDNewmHigh: 250 CW: 196 Goal: 190•

Not as much as education.

I can get a bowl from Chipotle with 870 calories and 83 grams of protein. That's a lot in one sitting, don't get me wrong. But if I eat that three times a day, that's 2610 calories. Not enough to make someone my size obese with even moderate exercise.

If I split it up so that one bowl-equivalent is two meals, I'm below 2000. But that's only if I try to make a healthy choice even with fast food. If I start adding queso, guac, coke, etc., those numbers could quickly double.

Even when people cook, they don't always cook the healthiest and often drink coke or mountain dew with it. Or have some ice cream for dessert

1
SomethingIWontRegretMODThin Hell Demon•

We're sorry but your post or comment has been removed for the following reason:

  • End-run around the "text post" rule

  • Text posts should be submitted as comments in the appropriate thread. Please see automod's comment for more information.

  • There is no fatlogic here.

See the full rules in the /r/fatlogic wiki for more information. Message the mods if you have any questions. Include a link to your post or comment, please.

1