Has anybody tried the Shaw's blue curve pods?

Recommendations

I have wifi range issues in my house and have tried several approaches with mediocre success. I've had a lower end mesh system that worked ok and in hindsight I should have stuck with it. Anyway, I ended up switching my shaw modem up and getting their mesh system. I've just installed and its pretty unimpressive but, they say it takes up to a week to work its self out, whatever that means. Anyone use this shaw setup yet? I can't find any reviews online. I'll wait the week out and see if it gets any better.

Posted May 10, 2019, 11:23 PM UTC

115

I find a third party router outperforms ISP provided hardware in most cases. And when you switch providers/move, you don’t have to change anything.

12
_darth_bacon_Aspen Woods•

Totally agree. Have used the "pass through" option for over a decade and will never look back.

Should mention that my Shaw router is in the basement, so running through to a third party router on the main floor is a no brainer to get better whole home coverage.

2
BeefJyrkii•

I mean it’s a “mesh network” but it works about as well as wifi extenders do so I’m not sure I would recommend them over anything else in the market.

Any mesh network you get at Best Buy will be better than the pods.

I had the Pods for about 3 weeks, saw little to no improvement over my regular speeds so I brought them back. Idk what they were talking about waiting for a week for it to work

I ended up going with the google mesh network, they were on sale, they looked nice and I have a partial google eco system so they fit nicely. No complaints so far.

9
eyeballers•

The only good mesh networks are ones that have wired in hotspots for seamless handoff when you move from area to area. Like when you're on a large corporate campus or at a University and you can stream something in 1080P and walk from one end of campus to the other without it buffering once. For home solutions, the eero is really good, but its expensive, and not many people actually need a full mesh network of that quality.

2
BeefJyrkii•

The google ones can be wired as well. I do like that the Eero is tri band.

1
eyeballers•

I have Eero at my place, it's very good, but if your access points are too close together, it will not hand off since it technically doesn't need to. Other than that, it's good, I can be on my front driveway, walk through my main floor, go downstairs, out the walk out and to the back corner of my backyard while streaming 1080P without any stuttering or rebuffering.

I have 4 access points, one on the upstairs loft which is above the main entrance so it hits my garage and front yard. One in the main living room on the main floor, one in the furnace room (modem location) and one in the basement guest bedroom which is near the window for the backyard. Complete overkill and a waste of $800, but my WiFi is probably the best.

2
BeefJyrkii•

Do they have Ethernet out as well? If I wanted to wire something?

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

-1
Pagani5zondaQuadrant: SW•

I don't mean to tell you the expensive route. But I got the Google home mesh and it works well, at home and work.

3
mishan_ctrl•

ISP provided hardware is most likely going to be junk. Better to get your own router and connect to modem in bridge mode or direct to ONT if on fibre

If that’s not good enough then add on a real mesh system

3
Boob_herder•

Works great for me but I live in a condo (only 2 floors / 1100sq ft).

Only issue I've had is my Nintendo switch hates the 2.4 and 5ghz bands being the same name. It always gets the 2.4ghz and causes it to be slow and drop connection. I gave them separate ssid names and got my switch on to 5ghz and no issues since.

2
AllEarsCalgaryWillow Park•

I have the Google mesh network with 3 pucks, works great. Obviously you are not going to maintain 300 all the way at the other end of the house, but it’s sufficient.

2
Zihaela•

I have not, but when we got our Internet hooked up in our new home, we had the Telus guy install these WiFi Boosters. I was skeptical, but so far I have had no problems - we have good internet throughout our whole house.

For reference, our main internet is in our office on the second floor and there is 1 Wifi Boost there. Then in the main floor there is a 2nd Wifi Boost, and that extends all the way to the basement where we have a TV and watch Netflix, etc. We thought we might need a 3rd for the basement but it works fine. (Our house is on the smaller side, though, maybe why this is effective solution for us).

2
FunkyardDoggSpruce Cliff•

This sounds like our setup exactly (smaller 1200 sq ft attached home - 2 storeys and a basement), and with our Shaw wifi modem in the front of the house in the main floor living room, we seem to have dead spots in the basement and rear top floor.

We're currently with Shaw (300 @ $88), but Telus is offering 150 Fibre for $85, which the agent is claiming is going to treat us much better than Shaw's 300, and based on my understanding of how fibre works I'm inclined to believe it. They did say we'd have 30 days to return/cancel if we didn't see any improvement.

Would you recommend the booster puck rent-to-own deal for a house this size? It just seems crazy as I'd expect to have to boost wifi only in a much larger house. Our basement is also unfinished so there's very little (I would think) interfering interfering with the signal from the floor above.

1
Zihaela•

Hey! We don't have fibre so I cant speak to that but we have had no issues with our internet so I think the little boosters are doing a good job filling in the gaps. We are able to get wifi in all areas of the house including the basement. Would recommend although i dont know if they are any better or worse than the wifi extenders you can get yourself off Amazon....

2
FunkyardDoggSpruce Cliff•

Thanks! That's all I really need to know. I'm going to start with the basic fibre install and default modem and opt for the boosters if it looks like we're still getting dead spots.

1
[deleted]•

[deleted]

1
zombiehoffa•

Their mesh system isn't very good. What I usually tell people to do is buy the google wifi mesh 3 pack from best buy, turn off their router wifi and just use google mesh wifi. If they have the wired points in their house I tell them to set it up with wired backhaul to the main wifi mesh node following something like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xMWDrocCldc

That way each point sends all the data over wires back instead of over wifi. This solves nearly all problems.

1
seanondemand•

If you really want to amp up your networking setup, a wired setup with access points will crush a mesh setup every time. I wrote about one here

1
Mandalf_the_Ghey•

These things are junk. I don't see what they offer.

I have 600 mbps (supposedly) and these pods, one floor up, get me about 70. woopty doo

1