r/canada•
SnarkHuntr

Quitter Politicians

Ok, so this is something that's annoyed me for quite a while. I don't think this is a partisan concern (it certainly isn't for me) but one that applies to politicians of all parties.

I get mad when a politician quits their job. We've seen three freaking elections in Nanaimo because the (NDP) politicians there wanted to move to other positions. We saw Stephen Harper's petulant middle-finger to the constituents of Calgary-Heritage when he couldn't be the PM again. I'm sure there are other examples, but I can't think of any good ones at the moment.

I think that barring ill-health, criminal charges, or family emergencies, politicians should serve out the term they've chosen to stand for election for. When you stand up and say that you want the privilege of representing the people of a particular community, you shouldn't be abandoning that responsibility because you see greener grass elsewhere or because you don't get to be prime minister. Either you want to represent your constituents or you don't, and if you don't, you shouldn't be running at all.

At the very least, a politician who chooses to step down mid-term should be required to pay Elections Canada back for the cost of the by-election.

​

Agree/disagree?

Posted May 13, 2019, 9:55 PM UTC

024

Yes, because a better idea is having a sitting MP say "fuck it", and not show up to the House to represent their constituents because actually quitting would cost them money.

Congrats you've just deprived ~100k people of representation.

With a situation like Di Iorio he should have been booted sooner, not be let allowed to tag along for however long he did.

11
SnarkHuntrOP•

That's a separate problem, but an important one. We should definitely have minimum service standards for politicians, every other job in the country has performance requirements, they should as well.

​

But a politician resigning also costs their district representation. How long did the Libs hold off on calling the byelection in Burnaby? Even with a promptly called election, there's still a lengthy period where the position is vacant.

0†

We should definitely have minimum service standards for politicians, every other job in the country has performance requirements, they should as well.

You would have to change the constitution for that and even then about the only thing I can see working is attendance requirements like the Senate has. ​

How long did the Libs hold off on calling the byelection in Burnaby? Even with a promptly called election, there's still a lengthy period where the position is vacant.

That's on the PM of the day and GG, not on the person who resigned.

3
SnarkHuntrOP•

Even with a promptly called election, there's still a lengthy period where the position is vacant.

0

And what do you think constitutes "promptly"?

The PM and GG absolutely have the authority to call them quickly, far more quickly than some breaks in the sitting schedule.

3
SirToxILot•

I think when a politician quits before their term is up, they should loose all benefits and pensions. An election costs tens of thousands of dollars

7
EngineeringKid•

An election costs tens of thousands of dollars

Hundreds of thousands of dollars for a single by-election.

6
SirToxILot•

Even more reason then.

-1
EngineeringKid•

I'd love to see a "term bonus". You get 70% of your pay while in office. At the end of the appointed term, you get the remaining 30%. If you quit/change parties/resign/get suspended before the end of the appointed term, you forfeit that 30%.

​

Now that I type this out....I'd even say 40% "term bonus".

​

I've followed the Nanaimo thing as well, and it really irks me. Politicians have no honour now.

0
SwarezSauga•

You don't think people should be able to quit jobs in Canada?

This country should not go down that road.

5
bpapao•

So why run if you plan to leave in case X happens? Why dont you have commitment?

1
SnarkHuntrOP•

You've heard of contracts? If I take a position with a term, I should be serving it out. If that's too onerous, I always have the option of not accepting the position.

Given that their capricious decisions impose a cost on the taxpayer, I think some kind of recompense is appropriate.

-4
altacct123456•

You can always leave a contract job. They're not gonna chain you to your desk...

3
bpapao•

Also, this is an especial case, they provide rights for the people. It's not like a baker leaving resulting in bread not being baked. Point is, they provide an essential right for the people they represent so quitting and not having a substitute should be illegal as it would leave people's rights open to manipulation.

0
RedBeardBockCanada•

I am also in Nanaimo so can give some insight. MLA Lennard Krog stepped down to run for mayor because we had an awful city council and got 70% of the vote. He thought that he could serve the city better in that role. You would say that he could not do that because it would be "abandoning responsibility" while it could be arguing it was the more responsible thing to do given that there were no other good options. That caused a by-election for the MLA spot to which the MP Sheila Malcolmson sipped down to run for. This was extremely important because the balance of power in BC was only one seat and to have someone who already represented the people do so on a lower level of government is a gain far from abounding responsibility. The final MP by-election was historic in voting in the second ever Green MP. This is an extreme circumstance but effective politics and they all stepped down a level so it would be hard to see it as greener pastures. But Nanaimo might be an edge case. What do you think about leaders of parties who win their seat but their party looses big time. Tradition is they resign and let a new leader take the helm. You want harper forced to stay as an MP at the entire time Trudeau is in power? Politicians paying for elections is not how this works and would favour richer candidates. There is already a high cost a barrier to entering politics the higher they are the fewer qualified candidates will run. Its not black and white, wanting to represent or not and that can change during a term.

3
SnarkHuntrOP•

Well, that's very forgiving of you. But Nanaimo had a terrible city council when Leonard Krog was making his last run for MLA, so it's not like he couldn't have just said "I'm going to take a pass on this Federal election so that I can serve the people of Nanaimo better."

Remember, he wasn't just Nanaimo's MP - he had constituents outside of the city as well. Krog's decision to serve the people of Nanaimo instead of the people of his former federal provincial riding was his to make, but he should have made it before he stood for his Provincial seat. This would have eliminated the need for Sheila Malcomoson to leave her seat to make a (failed) run for the Provincial spot.

I understand that these people have personal reasons for wanting to change jobs mid-term, but as it represents a cost (financial and otherwise) to their

As far as party leaders resigning if their party doesn't win the election - that's party politics. We don't elect parties, we elect MPs and MLAs. If someone has no interest in representing a riding, if they intend to use that position solely to access a higher seat of power, they should be making that position absolutely clear to the voters when they're running.

1
stereofonix•

Well let’s round up the Liberal side as well as there are those you missed like Nicola Di Lorio, Scott Brison and Denis Codere. That being said I do agree that MPs should finish their term regardless. Admirably, I’ll give Harper and eventually Trudeau or whenever and PM or Premier loses that role as after X amount of years burning the midnight candle that is the one time I can see it being ok, especially since that’s when a party should rejuvenate themselves

2
SnarkHuntrOP•

See, I'm not willing to extend that courtesy. If you're not willing to be an MP, then you don't get to be PM. If the party wants to elect a new leader, then you sit back on the backbench and actually represent the community you claim to have wanted to represent. If the person's position is that they're too good to be the MP for (Insert name of region), then they should be making this crystal clear to their consistutents during the election.

ie, Trudeau should be sure to emphasize to the people of his riding that he has no intention of representing them in the federal government, unless he also gets the big chair.

1
RightWingRights•

It is annoying when it happens constantly and generally just so they can go to a better position or better pay like a business executive who always jumps ship. That’s why businesses usually have punishing contracts with employees.

On the other hand do we want to keep someone who doesn’t want to be there in a political position?

I would say each case is unique and generally a politician we elect quitting ship will lose the party votes as voters do get annoyed which is likely the best punishment.

2
[deleted]•

[removed]

1
daddyhominum•

Politics is a very demanding career especially for those who have hobby horses they ride. I think limiting provincial and federal parliamentarians to a single term would be interesting.

1
latortuebleue•

I agree 100%. Prentice resigning after losing the Alberta election was another prominent example on the national stage and here in Victoria we'll have a local counselor trying to win a federal seat for the NDP without even serving a full year in her current position. This habit of many politicians is a colossal waste of time and money for everyone involved and I also think it shows a high level of disregard for the citizens they claim to represent and advocate for. If you can't honour a commitment you made to thousands of people why should they give you another chance for office ever again?

0†