[Spoilers] some small suggestions that would've made this last season logically consistent and more enjoyable to watch
- split battles into two episodes, so they feel longer and harder. fill the rest of the episodes with the usual talking and conspiracies as we know it. this also would've affected the first 2 episodes, where nobody dies and nothing really happens except for different types of intercourse.
- show the decline of dany's hopes and the repeated rising of her mad side from the very beginning of the season - e.g. by her yelling at her advisors or whatever, as the north doesn't give her what she thinks she's giving the north.
- in e3, don't let the dothraki ride into the black, and make the battle tactics and troop constellation somehow understandable - the overwhelmingly overpowered, basically unkillable army of the dead is enough of a threat for the battle to be as hard as it was anyways. better have dialogues between army leaders about how to cope whatever move of the undead than show stabby sam lying between corpses 7 times.
- in e2 (i guess?), when arya and jon meet in the godswood and he asked her how she could sneak up on him, show that she has access to some secret tunnel (that maybe exits in the weirwood tree?) or something that helps to understand her sudden appearance above the night king in e3. alternatively, let bran fly her towards the night king with ravens or whatever, so he doesn't seem like a completely useless stick-in-the-mud playing drones fly.
- in e4, let rhaegal be seriously injured by the bolts of many scorpions, not be killed immediately by just 3 bolts. then, it would contribute a little to the fight in e5, but be killed by some passing civilian using an unmanned scorpion right in the beginning of the battle (or just when the bells start to ring) as it's wounded already. then, dany would face another stab in the heart that would even better explain her going full mad queen and her rage against everyone in the city.
- in e5, let cersei be wounded deadly by some rock so she suffers incredibly, kind of forcing jamie to kill her out of mercy with his last breath.
with these changes, the season would've worked so far, i guess.
still, i think it's produced in an extraordinary quality - but the plot is too weak compared to what we're used to.
Posted May 15, 2019, 11:01 AM UTC
But this doesn’t make any improvements. In fact it spoon feeds the information. It doesn’t enhance in any way
Season 8 is flawed but I’m glad your not writing it.
I mean a secret passageway - c’mon
preparing plot lines in this manner has been all over GoT, and it makes the twists comprehensible. the trick is to do it in a way viewers don't get it's important until it's revealed.
and yeah, no need for a tunnel, that was just an example that came to my mind during typing.
so you really prefer her just materializing above him? she could also have worn the face of some white walker, or whatever makes it understandable that she could get there without being recognized by thousands of undead while she was having serious trouble sneaking along just 5 of them a couple of scenes earlier.