With the nerfs to super regen exotics coming, what if they’re reworked entirely?

Bungie Suggestion

I am of the opinion that super regen exotics break the game. They don’t make it more enjoyable, just easier. So what if the exotics were reworked to change a supers nature like nighthawk instead?

These are just ideas off the top of my head with no in-depth thought whatsoever.

Skull of Dire Ahamkara: changes your nova bomb into either shatter or lance

Shards of Galanor: adds an extra volley of knives (not particularly sold on this one tbh, but like I said, just off the top of my head)

Orpheus Rigs: pulls tethered enemies into the anchor

Ursa Furiosa: increased super damage based on amount of damage blocked (could maybe also extend super duration so you can block and deal more damage? Might be creeping into Doomfang territory there though)

Phoenix Protocol: I haven’t been able to come up with a change for this one. The first thing that came to mind was kills in the well grant ability energy, and kills with abilities grant super energy when well is not active, but I don’t like that very much. It feels lackluster. Maybe it extends the duration or size of it?

I think exotics that increase super duration like Gwisin Vest, Doomfang Pauldrons, and Geomag Stabilizers are fine as long as they don’t get too crazy.

I’m just trying to think of out of the box ways to still make these exotics relevant while doing away with instant super regen.

P.S. Bungie, please tell us if you have a wave of buffs coming for SoO too. There are some really lackluster exotics out there.

P.P.S. Much love to the whole team, but sometimes passion is expressed as anger and frustration. Listen to what your community is saying behind all the animosity.

Posted May 17, 2019, 11:13 AM UTC

317
Uncle-Smough•

I wouldn’t mind reworks, although I would start with exotics that desperately need them first like wings of sacred dawn or sanguine alchemy (being a warlock main these came to my head first). But one thing is for certain... You can’t convince me that unlimited nova bombs isn’t fun for a time.

5
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

I agree a lot of other exotics need work first. I disagree that unlimited novas are fun though. And that’s purely just my opinion.

Edit: let me rephrase that actually. It was fun absolutely melting shit a few times, but the realization that I may be stuck with that exotic when I want to run nova is what I don’t enjoy about it

0
Uncle-Smough•

Well in a game about space magic, what’s so wrong about even more space magic? I think the worst part about the armor is how much it gave, example being skull giving back full super after killing 10 or so red bars.

But I think the idea of an add clear super giving you super energy back for every kill isn’t a bad one, there has certainly been worse ideas put into practice. *cough aeon soul cough

3
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

I would be okay with them giving back, say, 33% of the super like nighthawk does.

And don’t get me started on the Aeon exotics lmao.

-1
arlondiluthel•

As a Warlock Main, if they were to just completely redesign the Exotics, here's what I'd like to see for my Exotics (granted these could just be brand-new Exotics)

Skull: Nova Bomb does less damage (55% of current base damage), but you throw 2 instead of 1 (for a damage increase of 10% overall)

Phoenix Protocol: (since Phoenix is in the name) Dying with a full Super allows you to expend your Super to revive (like Sunsinger in D1) instead of generating a Well of Radiance. The following restrictions apply:

  • in activities where a teammate cannot revive you until a certain amount of time passes (such as the Nightfall), you must wait that amount of time

  • if the wipe timer comes up, you cannot activate it

  • in a Raid, this will expend your revive token

  • in Crucible, you become marked to enemies

  • Only works with Well of Radiance

2
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

I like that Phoenix protocol one a lot

2
arlondiluthel•

Thanks! I understand the reasoning for getting rid of self-res, as it really was a crutch, but if there's an Exotic that gives us the ability, but with very specific limitations in high-level play, I think it'd be usable but not broken.

1
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

I agree. I don’t really know how feasible it would be to implement, but as a concept I think it’s great.

1
Uncle-Smough•

I’ve never really been a fan of self revive... at all. It was only useful for crutch situations which as you got better at the game the situations got less frequent, and with what you’re suggesting it would be limited in those situations so I don’t see the point.

If phoenix would get a rework (which I personally don’t think it needs) it would be much better if it instead got the other sunsinger super, which was where all your abilities got insane regen and any teammates close to you would also get increased regen, and this would be tied to well where if you press the super button it places a well but if you hold it then you get the sunsinger super.

It would be more interesting than simply self revive or getting super energy back but it could still fill the support role by giving allies increased regen while you’re in the super.

1
S0LWAY•

But they do make it more enjoyable... using Nova over the last couple of months has been a blast.

1
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

To you they do, but to me, they don’t. Not saying you’re wrong or I’m right, just offering opinion.

1
S0LWAY•

I’d say only a small percentage of players using Nova are thinking “wow this is crap”

1
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

And that’s fine, I just am not a fan of instantly getting supers back

1
WrappedInDichotomyIs there no middle ground?•

Just gonna throw this out there since your idea sucks ass, what if it made your well an aura? It would still work as normal but you'd be a roaming death puddle. Almost like an homage to D1 sunsinger.

0
mayofield22OPDredgen UwU•

You know they have the model to do it already from the Warpriest encounter. Granted that didn’t heal, but the concept is the same.

1
WrappedInDichotomyIs there no middle ground?•

EXACTLY! Just eliminate the super regen exotics entirely if they're generating that much trouble. Nerfing them over and over just feels bad. Especially when they'll still be the best options.

2