[SPOILERS] What really changed after Season 6

SpoilerSpoilers

I think the biggest change in the show was the elimination of the secondary stories.

In seasons past, the main story lines would be interrupted (sometimes by several episodes) while small detailed stories were being developed.

Take a character like Ros, the prostitute. She's a tread between Tyrion, Jon, Theon, Littlefinger, Pycelle, Joffrey, Cersei, Varys, Poddrick and Sansa. She was a prop to tell certain aspects of the story.

Even though many of those characters never met until she was dead, we could follow a thread of relationships via Ros.

George was very skillful to add these secondary characters to pull the threads together. They are not essential to tell a story but they make it a lot more engaging.

When Martin's material ended, we lost that part of the storytelling. D&D had to concentrate in finish the main storylines.

George takes years (even a decade) to come up with all those intricate character details. It's unfair to think D&D would be able to fill that void and still run the show. If George couldn't write his own material fast enough, how do we expect D&D to do better?

Posted May 17, 2019, 6:01 PM UTC

67
WhereIsGhost:Arya_Stark: Arya Stark•

Honestly, GRRM is getting off way easy on all of this and D&D are taking all the blame. And look I get it, they should get some of the blame for some of the half ass-ery. But lets not forget that George guaranteed them he would have the books done in time by the time the show caught up. That was almost 5 years ago and there's still no books. I dont think D&D take this deal if they knew in the beginning that George wouldnt have had the books done in time.

4
Oldmanbilly23•

Ros wasn't in the books, GRRM may had a part to put her in the show, but I believe it was D&D who put her in the story.

2
ppercaOP•

While that's true, the material used to develop her came from the books.

https://awoiaf.westeros.org/index.php/Ros

Although her character was created specifically for the TV series, she is based in part on a character in A Game of Thrones known as the "red-headed whore". Additionally, some of Chataya and Alayaya's roles have been folded into her character.

My point is, D&D had plenty to use to develop the rich show we saw in S1-6. When that material dried up, they had to concentrate on what they had already built. That felt like a big change and it was.

While the previous seasons were a very ornate tapestry, the last 2 were mere stripped down follow ups. But it's not really D&D's fault, since they never signed up to replace George.

It's called adapted and not original screenplay for a reason.

2
AutoModeratorMODNow My Watch Begins•

Spoiler Warning: All officially-released show and book content allowed, including trailers and pre-released chapters. No leaked information or paparazzi photos of the set. For more info please check the spoiler guide.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1
Hydrokratom•

The writing went down from season 5 on, starting when they passed the books, but it got worse from season 7 on partially because of the rushed nature.

1
bdbr:Faceless_Men: No One•

Tyrion stopped saying clever things, too. "I drink and I know things" was probably his only clever line from the last few seasons. Plus, he basically stopped knowing things.

Also, main characters still made bad decisions but there weren't consequences like Ned or the Red Wedding. Jon was always bailed out.

1
jaylovesyou2•

It's like watching two different shows. The last two seasons are full of special effects and great cinematography, mainly focused on the dragons blowing stuff up. It's like watching a superhero movie with little to no dialogue. Becomes unbelievable, it looks great, that human scheming and character development has gone. Like a big story arc such as, Jon finding out who he is, becomes a small scene and dialogue, needed more drama and method acting. A lot of people watch the show for the characters and story, they want Bran doing something, Cersei doing something other than standing at a window.

1