Two jailor games in a row, two vastly different results.

Story/Rant

Game 1: I call for tp/lo(while not outright claiming jailor to avoid arso/witch). My jailed target blatantly stalls before claiming medium. I don't trust it, and indeed I was killed by the SK I jailed. The problem is, doctor(Who also died that night) wasn't on me.

SK gets lynched, I get revived night 2. I jail a sus person night 3 and exe him. I also get shot by a witch controlled vigi. The game ends with evils winning. All of this, because the doctor decided not to heal the tp request night 1.(LO died night 2, but also was never on me)

Game 2: I again call for tp/lo. I jail one person, they stall before going "why me?" instead of giving a role so I tell them I'm exing them tomorrow. Day 2, LO whispers me and tells me a player(who turned out to be the bg) visited me. Night 2, I exe the person jailed yesterday and they were framer.

A few tp claims come out, another player who was mildly suspicious claims to have protected me night 2. The Lookout claim, who was still on me, claims that this wasn't true. I exe that person night 3, and they were Godfather.

Later down the line people suspect a doctor claim(BG ccs them). He would have been lynched, if not for the LO whispering that he saw the doc claim visit me. Said doctor gets voted down. After an unfortunate spy mislynch, the last mafia gets executed and town wins.

Was never attacked, but the LO alone confirmed several people and helped narrow down the suspects.

The moral, of course, being to fucking go on the tp/lo claims if you're tp/lo. (And if you're vet, maybe not ask for those since bad vets may be the reason why some people don't visit as often...)

Posted May 21, 2019, 11:48 PM UTC

93
I_lenny_face_you•

Good comparison OP.

I did notice in your story though that it sounds like in the good game, the doc wasn't on you n1 (although the BG was). In your bad game, the doc not being on you led to serious problems. This doesn't invalidate your points, but it suggests maybe the doc could've played better even in the good game.

Unless 1) there was another TP request, and/or 2) if I misunderstood something?

Unlike u/Chronos_the_Cat, I haven't died to a tp/lo request for a while now. Sux when it does happen tho.

2
Chronos_the_Cat•

That bit about vets and TPLO is exactly why I ignore all TPLO requests on D1 as TP/LO.

They've also recently begun to claim survivor before alerting, as if that's any better.

...Then I get shot anyway to a silent alerting vet I just happened to visit...

0
I_lenny_face_you•

They've also recently begun to claim survivor before alerting, as if that's any better.

It's not good, but if it's All Any, they could kill a Vampire, so maybe a little better?

2