Alanaan vs Fraux for fire Runeslayer
Preface:
I've seen a lot of posts talking about the evokers, and one of the things that stood out to me was people saying that the meta pick for fire was Alanaan due to his use in Runeslayer comps. He's an obvious upgrade to Yuel with 10% more echo, so it makes sense.
However, Fraux also brings something to Runeslayer comps: her Nightmare Scarlet debuff that adds 10% supplemental damage with no (known) cap. What makes supplemental damage interesting is that it applies to every damage instance at the end of the calculation which makes it multiplicative with everything besides other supplemental damage effects.
Basically, I wanted to test how strong Fraux's supplemental damage ends up being.
Results:
For my tests, I used a base Runeslayer comp of Shiva, Yuel, Tien5 with FLB Sun. Other cap increases were an Ultima/Opus auto cap key, Zhuque Malus, and a non-FLB SSR Seraphic. I also assumed a Tetrastreamer with the Humanity emblem for the 10% echo in every setup.
I made three different setups beyond the base by swapping Yuel/Shiva out for Fraux and Shiva for Alanaan plus one extra with both of the evokers, and here were my results:
| Slot 1 | Slot 2 | Slot 3 | Total damage |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shiva | Fraux | Tien | 78840859 |
| Yuel | Shiva | Tien | 80442702 |
| Alanaan | Shiva | Tien | 81447169 |
| Fraux | Yuel | Tien | 81492969 |
| Alanaan | Fraux | Tien | 82235889 |
Update: I updated the Fraux supplemental damage calculation as it was incorrect. The results have been adjusted accordingly and the old conclusion here was removed. Under ideal circumstances, we still see Fraux as a larger replacement over Shiva on your burst turn than Alanaan over Yuel, but the margin is much smaller.
Also I think a lot of people are drawing the wrong conclusions from this. I am not saying that Fraux is stronger than Alanaan - there are a ton of factors involved and I don't think you can accurately make a conclusion one way or the other. This is meant to showcase the possible damage on the burst turn with a relatively accessible setup (as much as an evoker and 5* eternal can be anyways) and also to show that Fraux isn't as weak as many people seemed to think.
Sorry for the confusion everybody.
I did all my calculations in a google sheet which I published here. There is some explanation for what things mean and how the math was done on the first page. If there's anything incorrect or missing that you think should be added, then please let me know so I can fix it.
Posted May 22, 2019, 11:01 PM UTC · edited