Nooooope•

I've read this and five other Turtledove novels. I kept coming back because I loved his ideas, but I actually really dislike his writing style... dialogue feels fake to me. That said, he's still the first example of alternate history that comes to mind.

10
0and18126•

I always take them as very boiler plate pulp. Great ideas but very rough drafts with little character development or subtext, just churned out to feed the market

4
Hell_MelOP2•

Yeah. I definitely prefer good character writing to good story writing if I can only have one, but this book does good enough with premise to make up for a lot else. At least for me.

2
Hell_MelOP2•

For what it's worth, it's the single best alternate history novel I've ever read.

5
miork2056•

Have you read Man In The High Castle? When I think Alternate History, this is the benchmark I think of

7
Hell_MelOP2•

I have!

Honestly I don't generally count Phillip K. Dick as the benchmark for anything. Not because he's not amazing, but more because it's not fair to anybody else.

5