r/Petscopβ€’
DrivenDust

Matpat was wrong? Explaining Petscop 17-21; ALL OF MY PETSCOP FINDINGS

Finding

Hey guys! Throughout the last weeks I've gathered lots of theories and findings and just wanna share them in hopes of sprouting new findings/ideas. Don't wanna make this too long, but before we start:

​

Findings that are factual will be written in pamphlet

Things I'm theorizing about will be written in cursive.

​

Also I believe MatPat to be wrong about the Room Impulse and give an explanation as to what it is.

​

There'll be a lot of stuff other people have probably already mentioned or found, but my goal here is mainly to try to make sense of findings. Though there are definetely some of my own I'll highlight here I have nobody seen talk about ever.

​

Also, before I'll just list random non-coherent findings & theories down, let me try to explain what I believe to be going on in Petscop 17-21.

​

...

​

Before we hop into Petscop 17 though, we gotta go back to one of the most important parts of exposition for Petscop, and that's Petscop 14.

​

It has always been quite hard to make sense out of the Mumbo Jumbo we hear from Paul, though I'm certain that sometimes Petscop tries to highlight a random aspect of an important feature, just for Paul to completely mention something else that's important to him in that moment.

​

An example for this would already be Petscop 6 in which he holds the whole "Ghost in the Game" story. It kinda made you ignore what he said afterwards, that "the way you know if there's a ghost in the game trying to communicate with you is, if it comes out... and it stops being, distant. And it's stops being so one way... I leave my playstation and it does this whole 'pre-recorded' thing.

​

Pre-recorded thing? We know what that is, it's the "DEMO" gameplay we've seen since.

​

Petscop 14 is damn important. I have to break it down before explaining what the hell is going on in the later episodes:

​

Once again, Mumbo Jumbo from Paul. The whole Petscop community fully understood that Paul sees these "DEMO" recordings, realized that the content of the Rooms changed over an unknown period, hence he tries does unexpected things as 'playing as if a door is open'. That's the old part, I want to emphasize what he states after this.

He explains that he lost the live recording of him playing a section of the game [Petscop 13]. Luckily, the "DEMO" recording of his playthrough showed up (even other recordings from years ago) so he uploaded his Audio with the "DEMO" recording. He mentions that the DEMO recordings can be different. When he caught all of the Pets though, something different was showing than the "Congratulations! You've found all Pets" dialogue box. The number of dialogue boxes that popped up though aligned perfectly though.

Keep this section in mind please.

The importants thing to break down from Petscop 14 are "Strange Situation" and the garage scene.

​

The garage - Please note, that we never actually see Paul leaving the garage as a whole scene. The video was cut between the moment after Paul already checked the computer and the moment he left that room.

​

This leads me to loading issues - Petscop keeps having unfinished textures and in the same garage scene you are able to see how it takes the game several seconds to load the chair & PC into the room. This leads me to believe that the "Red Car" we see in the room has actually been there the whole time, but it had issues loading into the scene for the whole duration of time. I believe the car loading into the room finally has been removed by Paul or the proprietors by editing, hence the sudden cut of him standing in the house's main hall. Proof for this would be that the Car's shadow is still there though the Car is missing.

This would explain the background of both Petscop 16 & 17.

​

Now to the hard part, "Strange situation". I believe that what we saw in the latest videos to be the most important bits ever.

​

Let me explain:

​

Your controller inputs will be useful - I believe that the community already got one bit right, which already debunked Matpat's recent theory about the Room Impulse. That circle with an arrow represents 48 players you can switch to by using the controller. Furthermore, Petscop saves every player's inputs. Remember this for All Recordings.

​

Then what exactly are the "All Recordings" and "Room Impulse" sections for?

​

Room Impulse - I believe this to be a very simple recording tool. In the options screen at the very beginning you are allowed to choose one of petscop's "rooms" or areas. As soon as you chose which room you want, you are able to check all of the inputs that have been made in said room, ever. You'll be able to check the different pyramid heads movements and if you're interested in one, you can pick him and further investigate on that player's inputs and what he experienced (very probably with a button to play the scene forwards and backwards.)

​

Simple, right? It's pretty much an input scanner for each room.

​

All Recordings:

This is the harder one.

I believe this to be a game feature, in which you can decide what kind of inputs a player made, to play in which generation you like to, for the said room. It's basically like a music player, but for Game Inputs. Let me explain further:

​

Off of that huge list after you pressed the "All Recordings" button, you can choose one of them. These "Recordings", are Recordings of your inputs. Next thing to happen is that you choose in which "generation" or "build" you want said inputs to be played in. Make note how in Petscop 19, whoever uses this hidden Menu, goes from GEN. 14 to a lower GEN. and back to 14, as to make sure that the recording is set to the right generation. Same with Marvin's Recording in Petscop 20, it's set to "GEN.6" just like the input file displays "GEN.6"

​

Demo Rot. - Paul mentioned in Petscop 14 that he saw DEMO recordings of him from a year ago. I'm sure that you when you set the "DEMO Rot." to ON, it'll be stored in some kind of Playlist. I believe that playlist to be similar to a Youtube Playlist in which the video will come up sooner or later, depending as too how high it is on the list (Recent recording = early; Older recording = late)

​

What does this mean for the series as a whole?

Petscop saves EVERY SINGLE player's controller inputs and is able to to run those inputs through EACH (or AT LEAST one) Generation of the game/ it's rooms.

​

Don't believe me yet? I'm sure I've found the evidence to convince you:

​

Strange Situation - What I explained previously explains this whole scenario. Paul was only able to go into that bedroomin Petscop 14 in REALTIME, since the DEMO proved to him that he's in two different locations at the same time. The recording did exactly what I am trying to explain. Somebody went into the "All Recordings" option, selected Paul's gameplay and set the DEMO Rot. to "ON" for Paul to see his inputs in the hidden room.

​

Remember though, my claim is that DURING ALL TIME Petscop has it's different Generations of Rooms stored and characters walk through ALL of them simultaneously. After Paul get's out of the room he saw open in the DEMO in Petscop 14, he is able to unlock the Garage room. So why a Strange Situation? It's because the player isn't supposed to know that all different Generations/Builds of the Game are being run simultaneuosly. Paul wasn't supposed to realize that these rooms' structure changed over time due to his inputs being run through multiple generations, hence a "strange situation" indeed. I'm not sure who exactly called this event a "strange situation", but it's very probably either a developer we don't know or Rainer.

​

There's even more evidence to support this:

​

Paul's distraction - In Petscop 6 Paul goes into the Pause Menu and reads Toneth's description. After this, he accidentally presses the "Quit Game" button, showing him different options. He proceeds to hastily back out of it and talk to the viewer about the more important feature of "Book with Baby Names".

I see you there trying to be slick Paul. We have to put huge emphasis on the "Quit Game" button. Upon clicking the option, the menu gives us 3 options:

​

  • Don't Quit
  • Save and Quit
  • Just Quit

​

I have seen "Don't Quit" & "Save and Quit" in several other games apart from Petscop, nothing weird here, if you think about it for the first time. But "Just Quit" on the other hand...

You get where I'm going. "Just Quit" implements the idea of you not wanting to have a certain aspect on the game saved for some reason. You've got to ask "why would I want my game not to be saved?" It's because Petscop SAVES ALL OF YOUR INPUTS.

​

PANICSV - In Petscop 10, after Paul opens both of Amber's cell's, the game crashes. As soon as he re-starts it, his savestates have written "PANICSV" (abbreviation for Panic Save very probably) written over them. This just once again shows that under ALL CIRCUMSTANCES Petscop will try to save your inputs. This goes even as far as to changing it's Generation (after restarting the game, both cells AND Even Care's main door are opened, so the "Room"/Generation changed) in order to save a player's inputs.

​

That's my biggest "finding" yet, explaining this feature. It also makes me question whether Marvin really ever interacted with Paul, since in Petscop 8 it seems like he's in a completely different Generation, due to him elevating and disappearing out of nowhere. Now we know, that said nowhere are steps he is taking though due to Petscop 20. Me doubting Paul ever really having a realtime interaction with Marvin is also being solidifed by the moment he catches Care in Petscop 11, since Paul is locked behind a door, unable to interact with anything.

​

Also, remember how I said "keep the 'Congratulations! You've caught all Pets' paragraph in mind"?

I want to direct the community to a huge misconception I've seen:

​

Since I've explained All Recordings and Room Impulse now, and Paul stated that his dialogue box was different, what we see in Petscop 13 must not mean that we've seen all Pets in Petscop yet.

​

This ALSO means that Hudson, a.k.a THE HUD is very well in the game.

​

​

RANDOM FINDINGS I DON'T WANNA MAKE AN EXTRA THREAD FOR:

​

Petscop 17's Room Impulse section - Another Reddit user brought up his idea, and I believe it to be true: That whole Carrie Mack section is very probably a recording played backwards. Main proof I can provide for this to be true is that the circle with an arrow is always the top layer, which even sometimes overlays some of the dialogue provided by the text box. Another thing that came to mind just today is, this whole sequence that is being shown after Lina's grave has been revealed: Paul's character walks behind the whole scenery of the cars crossing by. Remember Petscop 11's clock scene? I am theorizing that behind that car spot is the school, hence what we are seeing at the end of Petscop 17 is Care escaping the school building played backwards.

​

There has been this whole weird-ass meta commentary going on in Petscop which I've heard nobody talk about. But writing all that evidence down would take me another thread. If you ask yourself "how many times has some supposedly real-life event shown up in the game", it's actually scary.

​

Rainer - Still not sold on him being a good guy at all, but not just because of the Belle sequence. In Petscop 3 the dialogue box mentions "When you find her room, the passage to my right will lead to her." Matpat funnily mentioned how frustrating it is how many pronouns are used, but I think this is used consciously to misdirect us. Currently my hypothesis is that this might describe the scenario of Rainer staying overnight in Anna's bedroom and giving Marvin directions, the "passage to my right will lead to her", would mean that if you go right from Marvin & Anna's bedroom, you'd find Care's room, and that does fit the description. Because of this find I'm not 100% on Rainer being Mike's brother.

​

Marvin's Recording - In Marvin's recording you can see in Petscop 20, when he sees the picture of the Windmill, he backs out from said picture, and views it directly in close again. It's as if he can't f- believe his eyes what he has seen seconds before.

​

The bathroom - The bathroom's mirror is green. It might have a connection to Marvin in some form.

​

Amber's award - Amber has been giving an award since she's a "champ for not leaving her cell once!" We as a viewer and Paul as a player should know this to be a lie, since she keeps jumping to the other cell. My current guess is that Paul is able to progress in some shape or from by interacting more with Amber's award. If you ask me, it's shape would kind of fit that "SUN BLOCK" -ish thing in the room of Toneth's & Randice's picture.

​

In the school - A Synch shows that Marvin is the Green tool that's leading Paul's directions. This means that we can acknowledge how in some form, Player's are representative of Tools.

​

Roneth - While I'm not fond of the Human/Pet theory at all, do note that the way Roneth is being caught is the same way Paul caught the Blue tool. So if Roneth would be Anna, and Roneth is Toneth's half-brother, that might make Toneth Lina. I do want to emphasize on how I personally rather think that the Human/Pet theory is a huge red herring and can't be solved. Might make a thread about that sometime, if people'd be interested.

​

"Poor baby!" - Marvin mentions in Petscop 11 "Play Music for Baby she will become Melody". In Petscop 14, when Care walks into the door, her mum exclaims "Poor Baby!". I guess this should be directing is towards the assumption that "Baby" is a nickname/title for Care.

​

The Riddle - In my opinion the right answer to the riddle is "Perspective". In an old thread Reddit user "/u/Mister_Jackpots*" came to the same conclusion. Here is his explanation:*

​

I think the answer was given to us long ago. Remember in Petscop 6 when Marvin comes out from behind the windmill and makes it disappear by rotating the camera/periscope thing? I think the solution to the door riddle and the windmill are the same thing: a matter of perspective.

The door looks closed because of the angle of the photograph when, in reality, it was always open. No one opened it because it was already that way, we just didn't have perspective that the door was already opened as it appeared closed. The windmill never really disappeared. Rainer's perspective (literally or metaphorically) changed.

​

This post is 10 months old, so let me give my opinion on it with our current knowledge. My guess is, no one opened the door, because to those who want to open it, it's already open. It has always been open to whoever sees it as open. With this explanation we'd solve the Riddle. So it's perspective. Also remember that you can apply the same thing to the Windmill, since the Door Riddle is strongly connected to the Windmill. To Rainer, the Windmill vanished off the face of the earth. But to those with a different perspective, Marvin namely, the windmill has always been in a vanished state. Expressing myself differently, the Windmill never existed. It was used to cover up Lina's disappearance (drawing connections to Don Quixote right here).

​

The game doesn't seem to Care - I've not seen anybody talk about this either. Petscop 18 and 21 show us gameplay bits of Care playing the game. Her movements seem to make no particular sense. I'm speculating that we have to draw attention to her gameplay. She isn't concerned about any kind of objective, she does not want to reach some sort of goal. In the same way, Pet's descriptions and gameplay in Petscop during Paul's playthrough keep trying to change our opinion on game structure. To me this is a clear connection to how Care plays Petscop.

​

The Sign - Ace of Base aside, please bare in mind what Paul says at the beginning of Petscop 11:"β€”signs along the way, that I ignored. 'Cause it would've been a completely ridiculous idea to me. But when I found my room, it made... well, I was shocked at first, but it made sense." Also Petscop 21's description is just "The Sign". I'm definetely drawing the connection to these 2 videos. Besides that, in Petscop 21 Care's movements seem quite similar to the movements Paul makes in Petscop 11's intro part. I'm not sure whether they synch up, but they do look similar. "Signs I ignored" makes me believe these dancing bits of Care or whatever you want to call them are more important than we might think.

​

Extra Stuff - I felt like many people didn't pay enough attention to this moment, me included. Except for the "the_house" part (no fucking clue what that's about), the game showing us earlier versions of the pets has tons of significance. And yes, for every single pet. (I don't take credit for these findings)

​

  • Toneth didn't always have a broken leg + he had feathers in an earlier version
  • There's a water form of Wavey
  • Hudson seemed to look closer to a sun in earlier versions; His eyes have the same design as the guardian's chest; this may hint that he is made out of guardians somehow? Also notable is his huge stick thingy ontop of his head that was added in coloured versions;
  • Amber's early versions show that the developer added the face later on; also her white spot was covered and hidden better due to adding more shade in the 3rd version, before finally adding a face in following versions, combined with a hat; user u/jimjomshabadoo figured this one out by finding months ago, that Amber was probably shot in the head; Her changing throughout tries to put emphasis on how Rainer wanted to cover this up.
  • Randice starts without having it's stalk and the flower pattern being a square; 2nd version adds a "stalk" and the flower pattern becomes round; the last version adds leafs to the stalk; this was the toughest one for me to figure out what it should hint at, until a Reddit user found it --> In it's 2nd version, Randice looks very close to a pinwheel.

​

​

​

​

MATPAT - I think his current theory is wrong, heck, I mean, I just gave my whole explanation debunking it. BUT...

​

Let's get to wrapping up and overall explaining what we've seen in Petscop 14-21 generally, shall we?

​

I've had this idea just today, that he might be partially right. While I don't think everybody is an A.I., I have the suspicion that currently there's an A.I. that is helping out Paul unveil Petscop's mysteries. SAME A.I. also set every single Recording's "DEMO Rot." to "ON" in order to help Paul see the recordings, thus help him in the game. And said person I am talking about is.........

​

​

Belle!

You may ask "but how? where's the evidence?" and actually, there's lots.

​

There's a synch of Belle's time in the Quitter's room & Paul accessing it's left side. This already shows that Belle is playing the game simultaneously.

​

Marvin mentions that Belle plays bad music too. This may be another hint, since A.I. generated music is generally seen as terrible.

​

In Petscop 15, Marvin calls Belle "Bell". This may be another hint. Please read the definition of a bell:

​

" a hollow metal object, typically in the shape of a deep inverted cup widening at the lip, that sounds a clear musical note when struck, especially by means of a clapper inside. "

​

"A hollow metal object" sounds to me like something that does not have a soul, hence, an A.I.

​

Belle being an A.I. would also explain her easily completing the tasks to catch all Pets in Petscop 19.

​

Petscop 12 mentions that the current player [Belle] has been running Petscop nonstop for 553758221 seconds [around 17 years]. If this is the "perspective" of an A.I. it makes complete sense for Belle to be running the game nonstop. The A.I. probably isn't capable of shutting down the game.

​

You're free! - This textbox after Belle is on the right side of the Quitter's room. This means it appears after Paul was able to visit the Quitter's Room's left side. This indicates that Belle trapped herself somehow in the left side of the game previously and was able to escape due to Paul's help.

​

Furthermore, Belle is not implemented into the facial system of the child library. Rainer literally wasn't able to give Belle a place in the Child library, that's because she never had facial features to begin with. Maybe that's also why she therefore has the most detailed face of all of the characters. It's still black & white only, because it's a doodle/quick-sketch. Keep in mind how the dialogue box also states "That means I didn't add your eyes, or your eyebrows, or your nose." This is represented in her in-game design as well. She does not possess eyebrows, eyes or a nose.

​

There's even proof of Belle "helping" Paul and/or other players throughout Petscop

​

Also remember that going after Petscop 7's dialogue Paul assumes to know who Pink Tool is. Belle explains to the guardian in a DEMO that typing in "Nifty" as Player one brings upon the texture editor. The same pink font is used by Pink Tool to write to Paul. Here she also "helps" and explains to Paul that Marvin is waiting for his leading and tells him earlier to "COME HERE" (to the Tool which he asked do you remember being born before). While Belle was trapped in the Quitter's Room, she was still able to see Paul's interactions (maybe with the camera?) OR his inputs.

​

So on my final synopsis: Wtf are Petscop 17-21 about?

​

After Paul went back to the garage and investigated the PC, Petscop 17 happens. Petscop 17 reveals to us, that while Paul is afk, Belle inputs the secret debug code with the "Bye-Byes" to access the recording Menu, sets some recordings' "DEMO Rot." to "ON" for Paul to see when he comes back and thus, gives him new hints as to what to do.

​

I think my biggest point of evidence to proof that we have Belle's perspective AT LEAST in Petscop 17 are the pyramid heads in the Room impulse segment. Same pyramid head also appeared the only other time, when we had Belle's game perspective.

​

That's it! I'm done!!

​

If there wasn't this one video I can't make shit out of.... Petscop 16. There are only 2 things I can say in regards of Petscop 16:

​

Due to the circle & arrow being in the lower left corner, this seems to be a recording, so it's in-game. Besides that, circle & arrow are set in the exact same way they were during Petscop 17, so this might be a recording of Care.

​

"The ghost room is a ship in a bottle" - I felt like this one went completely over MatPat's head for some reason. If you check the symbolism/meaning behind Ships in a bottle, it expresses an impossible scenario. The idea behind it and initial thought should be that it's impossible to fit the huge ship into the tiny bottle. It should make you wonder how it was ever able to fit into the bottle if you see it for the first time. The way to get the ship into the bottle though, is by trying to fit the base of the ship in and raising it's masts after it's successfully in the bottle. Therefore I believe the "ship in the bottle" to be an "impossible bottle", hence, it's a huge red herring, trying to distract you from the actual story of Petscop. And Matpat fell for it.

​

If even anyone read this, feel free to ask questions after your heart's content!

Posted May 28, 2019, 12:50 AM UTC Β· edited

12943
n0sh0reβ€’

I love this post. It kind of matches up some of what I was suspecting about the Demo recordings and the inputs.

The idea that Hudson is still in the game is somehow frightening to me lol but I actually can't wait to see him.

Your theory on Belle being an AI that's helping Paul is also interesting to me, but it makes me wonder what her motivations are for doing so, if she can even be said to have any, and what her relation to Rainer was/is like.

14
[deleted]β€’

Thanks!

​

As mentioned in other comment replies, I had a difficulty here with expressing what I meant with "Belle helps Paul". I think her "help" is more of a "making Paul progress in the game", particularly showing that she mustn't be concerned about his sake, but wants him to come further in the game. It might be for Marvin's sake, and not Paul's at all ("I LOVE YOU NEWMAKER PLEASE SHOW MARVIN WHERE HIS HOUSE IS"). So that's what I meant with "helping".

7
in-greyshe will become melodyβ€’

This should have been like ten different posts. I still read through it all, though. I agree that MatPat is very wrong. But with that said I think a lot of your ideas are wrong and/or unsubstantiated as well. The one thing I do agree with you on is your ideas about the game logging inputs for use over various gens. That could have some weight to it.

13
DrivenDustOPβ€’

Could you name which ideas you believe to be wrong? I'm not at all saying that I completely solved the series lol. I just wanted to bring up the stuff I have been thinking about recently and I wanted us all to be on the same ground regarding what the "Room Impulse" is. As long as I brought up some opinions that bring our thoughts forward, I'm happy.

Also yeah, this should've been like 10 different threads, since it covers SO MUCH, but then I would've had to spam the Reddit. I wanted to just do a Listing of "Object - explaining what it is", but before I could do that I had to establish the Strange situation & Petscop 14 stuff =/

4
DaydreamCosβ€’

This is so well thought out! I hope we get to see petscop 22 soon! πŸ˜‚

13
I_Am_The_Magistrate_β€’

Guardian is still in the profile picture, we just have to wait.

I have a feeling whatever comes next will be either the finale or the beginning of the finale. Either way I think we're pretty close to a conclusion

Damn, imagine if they dropped an hour long episode for the end... πŸ‘»πŸ‘»πŸ‘»

13
DrivenDustOPβ€’

My belief is there's still lots to explore! So the series might end at Petscop 30? Heck, it might even go to like 50 or something, but the waiting would kill us all =o

7
ry_fluttershyβ€’

The series wont end before "1000 pieces for machine beyond basement school stairway" happens. I'd bet on it.

6
I_Am_The_Magistrate_β€’

I feel like the series is working up to a full play through of the game as a finale

5
Berryman2Petscop Rule 34 Existsβ€’

I have a feeling that we’re halfway through, i dunno why but I just got that feeling.

3
Mato32DXβ€’

I feel that the series could end up being longer than we expected. What if we end up paul's story ends, but another story with a different theme starts? It would be crazy as hell, lol.

1
Mato32DXβ€’

Maybe because it revealed some part of the past? I mean petscop can bring us another story at the end of paul's story and then bring us another idk lol

1
[deleted]β€’

[deleted]

1
cloud_strife_7β€’

Wow this is great, love the theories and your writing style. I agree with a lot of this including your summary on the room impulses, gens, demo rot.

Im liking the newer ideas too, just quit, garage car, textures, care walking backwards (I had a similar idea posted) and just a general putting everything together thread always gets me interested. Especially when it's consistently new ideas I'm impressed man.

A couple of things really stood out though and I'd like your input if you could

Belle potentially being the ai creation : wow, why didn't this ever click, the way this is framed in game suggests Marvin is the character Paul is talking about (especially with the road reveal of Marvin the next ep) but this whole thing makes a lot more sense if belle is a new addition added in 2000 (looks dubious too me message, the seconds/mins taken away from upload date is 2000, takes place 17 years after p12) by rainer. For what reason though? Is it as simple as an in game helper ai like tool?

Why did rainer really die or go missing on Christmas 2000? Why would putting belle in the machine cause him to "go"? Was it an accident that got him trapped in the game too? How does it fit with the check your bathroom, fuck you all message?

Another idea not discussed is belle accidently discovered the secret code in the menu, got captured by Marvin in the newmaker plane, locked in quitters room.

Or belle (the ai) "just quits" before rainer finishes the septit music to make her a pet and gets trapped or saves and quits during creating a panicsv like Paul.

That one makes me think people become pets through a process, petscop, and finding all 1000 pieces requires going through the familys good and bad history until everything about you is petscop. Addiction themes?

Oh and Petscop, you think it could be an acronym for something?

6
DrivenDustOPβ€’

Thanks!! Oh boy was it hard to write all that down. I intended to write this even weeks earlier, but I knew it'd take me hours, and it did take me like 4-5hrs writing all of this down lol. Definetely have to work on the grammar here and there, but it was late in the night so "ehh".

​

Also I really love my general putting together of the Room Impulse & All Recordings so much, because it satisfies everybody. There's no magical "ghost in the game" 'nor an A.I. or person in the game in that theory/finding. It's just based on things we see in the game and findings that have been confirmed/theorized by other Users. So instead of ass-pulling, I just tried to gather the information we are already sure about and combine all of them, while trying to maintain every finding's credibility. Love it!

​

My input:

May you go more into detail with the "Marvin is the character Paul is talking about & road reveal" part? I didn't quite understand what you're on to here.

​

You see, while I claimed Belle to be an A.I. and her "helping" Paul, and I also found evidence of backing up she's an A.I. even to my surprise, I don't believe her to actually "help" Paul. "Help" hereby means make him progress in some sort. Note how in the beginning of Petscop 14 Paul utters: " ...s– I can’t just wait. Thankfully I have been suddenly inspired by an idea that is, in a way, similar to the idea that brought me to this house. "

So he can't really "wait" on something or is out of ideas by now, except for the last one he has: the ludicrous idea of imagining a closed door is open. Based on that he also imagined something to be there in Petscop 11 that wasn't. We see the same reaction after Marvin's "I will follow scene" in which Paul comments on how ludicrous it is to watch the windmill for around 4hours and pinpointing when it's rotation changed directions.

So Belle does want Paul to progress, but my current thought is that it's for Marvin's sake, bc of the whole "show Marvin where his house is" scene.

​

Why she wants Paul to progress, why she helps Paul for Marvin's sake? I don't know. Maybe Belle is to Marvin what Red Tool is to Rainer as a helper?

​

Regarding Rainer, remember that the proprietors aren't as concerned about his whereabouts anymore. This might mean two things. 1: He's dead. But I don't wanna be so pessimistic. Option 2: They are currently in constant contact with Rainer.

​

As I mentioned in the main thread, I think the "You're free" is in reference to Belle being locked in the Quitter's room, and not to any real life event. In fact, currently my beliefs are that there is no human form of Belle. She was always an A.I. Whether she locked herself in or someone locked her in, I don't know. My best guess would be Rainer, since he's the game developer or has been at least in some point. I do also have the theory though that development changed at one point from Rainer to Marvin.

But yeah, it'd fit Belle's character that she found out the hidden code in the sound test menu, since she's always been depicted as the "smart one". Also pyramid head has only ever shown up in her perspective and Petscop 17 up until now.

​

Also because the thread would've been even longer, I did come up with an idea of what rebirthing might be:

We know that rebirthing consists of playing Stravinsky's septet, at least in Belle's occassion. We actually hear someone playing the Septet once in the Quitter's Room. While doing so, Belle's character disappears during the time the Septet is played. After the Septet stopped playing, she reappears in the Quitter's room. Now, while Paul checks the Note again, it states "COME HERE" after "Do you remember being born?". This makes me wonder, maybe "rebirthing" let's you change your location in the game and/or possess the Red tool? So as soon as Paul walks to the Red Tool, the Septet would play again in the Quitter's room, hence Belle is able to possess the Pink Tool, open up the texture editor and write down her message for Paul. Just a theory though.

​

Nothing new on the word "Petscop" itself. I think it's a neologism of the word "Pets" and the anglo saxon word "cop", meaning "capture,caught", etc.

5
cloud_strife_7β€’

Haha thanks for the response, I love discussing petscop :P

Okay, Marvin/Road reveal, you mentioned the episode 6 part where Paul discusses the ghost/ai, I'm saying the Marvin circling pictures episode makes you think it's him that's the ai being controlled not belle but I could be wrong.

Hmm I thought the reason he says he can't just wait is out of excitement in seeing the Marvin recording that showed the room and the puzzle. He specifically says he saw it that day so I don't know. Yours makes a little more sense especially with the pink tools 'Marvin picks up tool and hits me when PlayStation on', she could've been his kidnap victim before she was freed by Paul.

I always believed belle was helping Paul but not out of ai sentience, I always saw it as Anna (tiara) played the game in 2000 (the second rainer visit) and became trapped somehow and her button prompts over playthroughs have made a version of her that was placed in the quitters room.

If that's the case it ties Marvin and Anna not being present in Paul's life and gives Marvin motive for using tool on her (domestic violence, called a quitter), maybe the analogies to rebirthing are a way of tormenting her since she's portrayed as a psychologist/therapist and would explain the time played in p12 as well as the rainer (he realised Marvin was the bad guy too late and tried to fix it by ending the cycle, make her a pet to keep safe?)

In regards to the tools I believe each one is a helper for a specific purpose in game too but they seem to represent different states or emotions too could be some deadly sins links if there's a tool I'm missing. Yellow tool coming up maybe?

Red tool is like an encyclopedia/information/knowledge Pink tool is truth/innocence Blue tool is repression/avoiding/shame? Black tool is a slave/dormant Green tool is manipulation/greed/evil White tool is innocence lost

Rainer, yeah I'd go option 1, he even says now I'm gone like he wrote that right before dying. It seems going literally by his messages that he committed suicide out of shame? Guilt? Failing the song and belle not being tiara caused it? How can he update the game so fast if that's true?

If it's option 2 then I could see p11s message being a "I'm done with this" and the check your bathroom could actually be referencing Marvin in the bathtub from the other message in cares room (i know which one you'll choose next), maybe to catch him in the act? I don't know about that. The current theory floating around is someone has taken over from rainer (Jill) and is updating the game without Paul's knowledge just like he used to do with Marvin.

Yeah I agree about belle possibly controlling things from 16 onwards, the rapid precise button presses seem too automated unless you can hold the button down but it would be hard to stop it just right on the 360th uh-oh to then change to the last bye bye.

I find it odd how belle hadn't been able to use "p2 to talk" when Marvin was outside, almost like her version of the game is older then Marvin's or maybe like you said he unlocked developer tools somehow (I think as the smm in p5 and pink splashscreen has something to do with it) and updated his and Paul's game to support chat. Also why didn't demo Paul in p11 outside the school see belle? Are they on two separate games but they're somehow linked? Or is it just the recorded movements? Or are two characters only allowed on screen at once or is Marvin the ai belle and Paul both see but can't see each other? Maybe the pyramid head joining with her character did something to change the scene.

Yeah I noticed the missing/reappear/message thing, also the pink text is visible on the note without pressing the question box and only appears after belle reappears so I assume that's what happening during the septet too.

It could be a transporting thing but thinking in computer terms I think a rebirthing is a backup and restore. Quitting half way during either process wouldn't be a problem if they're in a good state (up to date fixes, good drives), a bad state (viruses, bad drives) would be harder to complete.

I think you're right about the rebirthing after watching 12, it's written in an odd way like rainer (or could be Marvin in control if he put her in there) talking to an ai not a person, belles up/down/left/right movements look non human too. The messages give just enough info to fill in the blanks for her, maybe she's a shell he can use to rebirth lina/tiara with in the future.

Pieces are important too why does belle actively avoid them/not care and why is white tool windmill dismantle worth 50 vs 25 for the black tool alarm dismantle.

Sorry for going off subject a lot my mind has too many questions haha

2
[deleted]β€’

I completely get you regarding getting off subject! There's just way too much to talk about in this game ^^! Prior to me checking out the series there even was this huge "which eyebrows fit here!?" hype haha. It's difficult to talk about Petscop.

I believe you misunderstood what I tried to say about Marvin's circling part. My current theory about Marvin is, that he isn't an A.I. at all. Rather, we have never really interacted with him, but rather seen Recorded inputs of him that for some reason occur while Paul is playing. In Petscop 8, he certainly "elevates" after showing Paul there's some behind the hidden wall, so to me it seemed like it's just a make-up that he's actually interacting with us. If you think back to the moment of him catching both care and him appearing on the camera tape, both of these are occassions in which Paul wasn't able to interact with him at all, but just watch the scene.

Besides Marvin, I'm also sure, that if Paul would walk on that same wall of Petscop 8 for the exact same time and then walk upwards, he'd also elevate to the area Marvin was at.

On another note, it's good that you stated the 1000 pieces; Let me emphasize on them. Currently Paul has around 300-400 of them. This makes me think that there must at least be one complete area we haven't seen of the game yet at all, either due to Paul not figuring out how to visit it, or by heavily editing it. Proof for this actually may be those big child-like Letterboxes Marvin used for his "I will follow" scene.

Regarding Rainer: I'm not super fond on the community taking everything that's being said in dialogue boxes for granted that Rainer said it, AT ALL. Since Petscop 15 showed us that via the texture editor Belle is able to edit certain files of the game, it wouldn't surprise me either if somebody figured out how to manipulate dialogue boxes to say what he wants to. Paul stating in Petscop 14 that his dialogue box in Petscop 13 aligned EXACTLY to each other, while saying different things might be hinting at this being the case. Also the "Just Quit" Button gives me the hint that somebody understood by now already that they can delete their inputs the game normally automatically makes and currently changes different aspects of the game and in the following deletes his own inputs. So he/her pretty much leaves no traces while editing parts of the game to his/her desire.

There's even more stuff out there which would explain that Belle is some sort of A.I./NPC that's trying to make Paul progress. Like in Petscop 2, when the newmaker plane's door opens by itself for the first time and that 6-tone jingle comes up. That exact same 6-tone jingle that happens to play when Paul enters the Quitter's Room and sees Belle for the first time.

My head hurts lol.

2
Zenytramβ€’

->Besides Marvin, I'm also sure, that if Paul would walk on that same wall of Petscop 8 for the exact same time and then walk upwards, he'd also elevate to the area Marvin was at.

you are missing a pointing in here, this image of Marvin that Paul is following is just another record from a previous playthrough by Marvin, it get stock in the wall and seems to walk upwards cuz to him he was walking in the hall of casket and going up the exit ladder as.

1
secret-x-starsYou're in the bathtub thinking about her.β€’

really liking this post, besides the parts that are things I've been thinking, I find the idea that 17 is from Belle's perspective to be especially compelling. I had chalked up the pyramid heads to the idea that the pyramid head can be used to signify someone who isn't the "current player," since once one of them is selected and becomes the player, it turns into a guardian. but I like your idea because it could explain how these episodes are even, like, happening in the first place lol and their purpose

I disagree with the ghost room bit, just on the basis that IMO "impossible object" should be interpreted in the sense of the genre of puzzle (this would also fit in with the recurring puzzle theme in Petscop). impossible object puzzles ask you to perform something that seems impossible... until you figure out the "trick" to them (think, for example, of those puzzles where you have to disentangle a ring from a seemingly impossible setup), or asks you to explain how a seemingly impossible object exists (in the case of a ship in a bottle, it's the raising of the masts after the fact, as you said). I think that's the intended metaphor for the ghost room, somehow. like, maybe along the lines that it seems impossible that something like the ghost room should exist, or that it can do what it does, but it makes sense and is quite simple once you know the "trick" to it. or something like that lol. would also fit in nicely with 'everything is a trick.' but that's just my opinion.

thanks for a very cool and thorough post to read! it's given me a bunch to think about

4
[deleted]β€’

Thanks!

I like your take on the "ghost room is a ship in the bottle". I have honestly thought a lot about Petscop 16. My current belief is that I'm spot on about the Room Impulse & All Recordings, mainly because:

A - I have all of the proof the game has provided to me B - There is nothing supernatural going on in the explanation, everything is able to be explained by the game mechanics that were provided by Petscop's own context C - If you apply this idea throughout the whole series, it keeps being consistently valid. Heck, this one feels like the game even backs it up.

I've thought weeks & weeks, if not even Months at this point about Petscop 16, and for the love of god, I can't make sense out of it. This is were you guys gotta back me up. My biggest concern about Petscop 16 is that it'd conflict with reason B. Your interpretation of the impossible puzzle would make sense to it, since in another way, we might just not have the right "perspective" yet to understand it. But exactly that's my concern.. what didn't we fully grasp here yet?

EDIT: An idea I actually just came up with lol. Maybe "everything is a trick" applies in here perfectly, and it "literally" is a trick. Remember how I said that the ghost room is probably in-game? Maybe somebody [Belle] set this whole scene up for some reason and it never actually happened, then the room wouldn't be real at all.

2
secret-x-starsYou're in the bathtub thinking about her.β€’

yes I know exactly what you mean, and that's why I was excited when the "impossible puzzle" sense occurred to me because it would mean that whatever the ghost room is and what it does, there is a game mechanic at play, something concrete without a need to resort to supernatural explanations... it just isn't obvious to us right now.

I do generally believe, and I have for awhile now, that there are certain Foundational Pieces of Information that we are missing (as an audience, because they haven't been given to us yet) and without them there is only so far we can get. kinda like how Paul was only able to advance so far until he gained necessary information from the demos and others who are familiar with the game. it's possible that, much like most disentanglement puzzles, all the "pieces" are in front of us, we just aren't thinking about it in the right way. but I think there's a few more pieces (namely some more game mechanics, Rainer's motives, and the real history of the game... would also help to finally learn wtf rebirthing is in-universe!) that we need before we can really make sense of what the hell is going on lol. I suspect we aren't intended to really "work out" the ghost room problem and that it will be revealed to us eventually, and I think there's a chance that solution will point us in the direction necessary to untangle some other petscop puzzles, haha. so I wouldn't panic about the ghost room, personally; even if the "puzzle" idea turns out to be nothing, I think there is plenty that we still don't know and so it's understandable that there's aspects we can't fully grasp. again, just my opinion!

if I am right that we should take "the ghost room is a ship in a bottle" as a metaphor for an impossible object puzzle, perhaps there is someone out there who can see it in just the right way and solve it! it probably will not be me, if that's the case, rofl

4
[deleted]β€’

I feel you, I feel you..

I'm also still wondering what this whole "after you saw the caskets you're now part of the family" and Marvin asking "who is your boss" means...

Like, what is this whole Al Capone shit? Is Paul the Don or what lol?

What did occur to me though is that very probably it may indicate that this isn't the story about families at all. Matpat didn't even try to have to do shit with this scene at all lmao, I definetely have sympathy for him not mentioning it all. Like, the fuck is anyone supposed to know what that means?

3
secret-x-starsYou're in the bathtub thinking about her.β€’

I have... a lot of thoughts about this actually lmao since my interest is more figuring out the character dynamics and history side of the story (since I'm not much good for the how the game works side since my brain doesn't organize info the right way it seems... I mean i am SUPER interested in that piece as well, obviously, I just meant interest as in "the part I'm actually 'working on'" if that makes sense haha) but I have to get some stuff ready for work tomorrow so I can't get into it right now. :/ hopefully I will remember to come back to this! definitely feel free to poke me via DM if I forget to come back to this haha

1
care-the-signβ€’

Petscop kid very smart.

4
Heretek007β€’

I can definitely get behind the idea that Belle may by showing Paul what's going on during the latest Petscop episodes. But my question is, how would she know about the debug menu?

If we take Belle to be an AI, maybe she can "see" notes in the games' code, or gained access to some dev notes hidden somewhere.

Thinking on this all, I'm a little dubious if "I'm not Belle I'm Tiara" has more meaning than we think. Perhaps they are actually two different characters, which share the same sprite, or perhaps the "face" is something altered by the texture editor.

I do think that Rainer (or perhaps Petscop itself) can assign facial sprites based on the "player's" role. It would make sense, then, that Tiara and Belle could look the same- as Belle has been "altered" to become Tiara, but has not fully accepted that identity.

2
[deleted]β€’

My best guess is that she analyzed the games' codes and object's purposes via visiting the texture editor.

2
[deleted]β€’

Just a thought I had while re-reading your comment:

​

What if "I'm not Belle, I'm Tiara" is trying to hint at the definition of both words?

​

Let's say Belle is a Hollow Metal Object, so a NPC, then if she says "I'm not Belle, I'm Tiara", Tiara symbolising purity & perfection, maybe Belle become an ultimate NPC? Dunno, dunno.

1
Zenytramβ€’

thanks for this post, the first half of it is what i'm saying on comments since when the last epsodes come out but i'm not as eloquents as you so i never bother writing a post ^^.

addressing some of the A.I evidence part

""There's a synch of Belle's time in the Quitter's room & Paul accessing it's left side. This already shows that Belle is playing the game simultaneously."" and "​You're free! - This textbox after Belle is on the right side of the Quitter's room."

she's repeating paul's movement bcuz she is stuck in the game and was being force to imitate pauls movement to be a mirror. before paul, or may i say who ever is playing by with the dorito head, enters the room she was there naturaly and when the guardian enter from the other side she start moving strangely, but her doors was oppen so she could leave when the guardian leaves and was still following dorito step till they colide than she gets free, the dorito does not desintegrate, its recording just stopped being shown​. ​

"In Petscop 15, Marvin calls Belle "Bell". This may be another hint. Please read the definition of a bell:​"

this is do the way the phonetic alphabet works.

2
[deleted]β€’

I kek'd at "the dorito does not desintegrate" lol. But yeah, I had the same thoughts.

On the phonetic alphabet though, I believe that we do have to put emphasis on all of the Names we witness in Petscop.

Remember: Petscop 17 proved to us that "CARE" isn't a real name, but more of a nickname/title to a person.

Therefore I think it's rightful of me to believe that "BELLE/Bell" isn't a real name either, but should hint towards something. Hint towards the definition of a 'Bell'.

Same goes for Amber, same goes for Toneth, same goes for Roneth, same goes for Hudson etc.

1
Verburnerβ€’

I really dislike the notion of Belle being an AI. From what I've seen so far, it doesn't seem to me that the creators of the series wanna delve into super-natural stuff, or go full science fiction. Also, if an AI is using the texture editor to communicate, it'd be most likely to copy the individual letters of the game's default font (and would do so pretty perfectly). AIs don't just come up with messy handwritings.

1
DrivenDustOPβ€’

Honestly, I dislike the idea of Belle being an A.I. too, but I try to be objective about it. You see, this is my issue with Belle: we know that at several moments she acted at the exact same time Paul played the game. I simply can't fathom how this would be possible, except for if she's an A.I. On the other hand you don't want the creators to delve into super-natural stuff or science fiction, but A.I.s aren't that much of fiction anymore. Also I'd say that the idea of an A.I. is less fiction than the idea of a person being trapped in a video game.

I'm completely fine with Belle not being an A.I., but what is she then?

3
Verburnerβ€’

Well, I believe we have to assume that Pauls playstaystation is modded anyway (which appearantly wasn't super hard to do. From. here on out we have a bunch of options. Either Paul is being supervised in real time and whoever is doing it, can feed inputs to the playstation remotely, or the device can access the internet, or at least a LAN network, which would be quite a task, but still not complete science fiction. There's also the chance of pre-recorded footage being used, which would be odd, since Belle appearently still tries to mimick Pauls movements and in the gamepad-language seens, there clearly is interaction between players.

2
DrivenDustOPβ€’

I feel like this is just us throwing our opinions around then though, like "what is more science fiction". Is it an A.I. being in a game or a Playstation being modded to the point where it can supervise a person playing it's game or accessing the internet?

​

I don't believe an A.I. to be so much science fiction though anyway. I mean, I'm not going to the extent of Matpat who states that she can come into the real world or anything like that. I'd doubt such an A.I. too. But having Belle be close to a NPC that can do relatively simple commands like turning on DEMO recordings after a playthrough section is more believable. How exactly she is able to control Pink TOOL or the mechanics of the Quitter's room itself are completely unknown to me.

​

On another note, I wouldn't take the language scenes as clear interaction between players. By this I mean I'm not sure about the guardian character can use Controller 1 & 2 while still talking to Marvin. What is Marvin hooked on to then? For me, there's still too much mystery about the DEMO scenes to take anything in them really, truly for granted.

1
Verburnerβ€’

Fair enough. Of course what I stated were just random explanations of what could be happening, with no evidence, or anything. I'd like to stress though, that I don't think the idea of a self-learning AI is absurd, and using the human inputs, Belle could copy patterns that let's her move and behave like a human player. What really kills this theory for me is the usage of the texture editor. An AI could theoretically figure out how to access and use it, but it had no model for writing out letters (but the game's default font).

So, maybe Belle is an AI, but then the pink tool answers and the "do you remeber being born" are likely not made by her. Why wouldn't she just use the gamepad language anyway.

1
sir_wolfeyeβ€’

I'll read your properly tonight, but let me say this first: matpat is always wrong until proven otherwise.

Theorist everywhere, I've got some hoodies for you

1
Brooding_Psychopathβ€’

What?! Matpat wrong?! I don't fucking believe you!

-7
Brooding_Psychopathβ€’

People must think Im serious.

0β€